Should we really base gaps off of the Namek arc?

Pyro

Elite
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
9,061
Going by the officially released numbers, either through the guidebooks or the manga, Kui, Dodoria, Zarbon, and Vegeta (pre-zenkai) are all within the 18,000 to 24,000 range.

Vegeta: 24,000
Zarbon: 23,000
Dodoria: 22,000
Kui: 18,000

That's a fairly small range of only 6,000 units, yet Vegeta was able to essentially one-shot Kui, easily overwhelm Dodoria, and take down Zarbon with somewhat more effort than Dodoria.


138-_Y8n7f.jpg

139-96qf_I.jpg

140-wm2w4.jpg

141-me_Vbb.jpg

142-_UE22_P.jpg

143-_P1l_Ka.jpg

038-_Fxh_Mb.jpg

039-y_Mg_ZO.jpg

040-_SBMLD.jpg

041-h8a_HS.jpg

042-e68fi.jpg

043-sgv_RA.jpg

045-_FKpio.jpg

046-_Ske_QM.jpg

047-z7g_Ax.jpg

106-4ec1h.jpg

107-5qys_C.jpg

108-_JOJyc.jpg

109-ju_CVa.jpg

110-b_PKgw.jpg

111-g_M6m_P.jpg

112-_IU6_EA.jpg

113-o70_Vw.jpg

114-_V46_IV.jpg

115-_C2v_Pj.jpg

116-nz_Fu_F.jpg

118-_Crdy_T.jpg


Vegeta owned Kui basically as savagely as Goku did using Kaio-ken x3.

As you can see in his fight with Dodoria, the most visible effort he needed to put forth was in his finishing blast to obliterate him. He was straining to hold Dodoria's arms back, but even then, he was smiling as well, so I put it at a little less effort. Other than that, he was easily blocking and dodging Dodoria's attacks.

Zarbon was similar in inferiority to Dodoria, but Vegeta was more visibly putting effort into his assault than he did with the latter. Zarbon is almost completely unable to track Vegeta's movements, and is unable to defend himself from the physical hits. I wouldn't peg Zarbon as too much stronger than Dodoria based on their performances. Then Zarbon transformed and owned Vegeta just about as well as Vegeta owned Kui, which I previously likened to Kaio-ken x3 Goku vs Vegeta on Earth.

We know from the power levels given in the manga that Goku was "over 8,000" and Vegeta was sitting pretty at about 18,000. Using Kaio-ken x3, that would put Goku at over 24,000, giving him a solid 25% advantage over Vegeta. With the way that slaughter went, 25% sounds very reasonable. With the tables turned, Vegeta being at 24,000 and Kui being at 18,000, the way the fight played out was to be expected. A 25% advantage seems like a total slaughter, and it's backed up by two fights.

However, Dodoria was owned pretty easily, which you wouldn't think would be possible given he'd be only roughly 9% weaker. Zarbon would make it even more bizarre being only roughly 5% weaker. Firstly, would a 4% difference allow Zarbon to elicit noticeably more effort from Vegeta? And secondly, would Vegeta really be able to make a fool out of Zarbon and Dodoria with only a 5% and 9% advantage, respectively? That seems crazy to be able to own two guys that are both less than 10% weaker than you, with one who might as well be on equal footing. Working together, those two would be able to take someone who could trounce them individually.

But the problem doesn't disappear even if their levels are lowered with Dodoria at 20,000 and Zarbon at 21,000. That would make them 17% and 13% weaker, respectively. It's a bit better, but still, is it enough to actually believe in such uneven fights? 17% sounds fair enough, but Zarbon being at 87% of Vegeta and still soundly being defeated turns up a boiled fish. Comparing a 25% difference beatdown to a 5%/13% and 9%/17% beatdown looks out of whack and inconsistent. How does one go from being completely devastated and puking up blood at 25% inferiority, to being manhandled and unable to see the opponent at 9%, to just slightly less damning at 5%? That seems like a lot of similar ownage for too much of a numerical discrepancy to me.

Most commonly I see 1-15% being on equal footing to rivaling, 20-30% being a stomp, and 30%+ being rape. How did we get there from the Namek arc's hilariously tiny gaps?

For future bouts, do we use 5% as a good indicator of being able to maybe track an opponent but still being totally unable to win, and then 9% as being unable to track and unable to win, and all the way up to 25% being a Doom massacre? What about anything between 9% and 25%? And if 5% is a one-sided battle, what qualifies as equal—a 2% difference?

Anyway, I'm beginning to sound like a half-blown retard. I hope you get what I'm trying to ask here.
 

Fantastische Hure

Zeta Elite
25k
Joined
Jun 1, 2015
Messages
30,769
Age
29
I'd say 9 - 13% (even-though I usually just go by 12 - 13%) is distant-rivalling range. In that they can somewhat put a fight or just about last, but they are very obviously out-classed.
 

Diamond Ryan

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,809
Age
23
21 to 22k is fine for Zarbon, as with a similar-ish gap Vegeta was easily overwhelming Kaioken Goku.
 

Pyro

Elite
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
9,061
That doesn't leave much room for Dodoria to be comfortably ahead of Kui while remaining under Zarbon.
 

Let's Go Fearless!

Zeta Elite
25k
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
41,541
Age
25
Because they lacked of parts of ki that played a huge role on their fight against Vegeta especially that they haven't fought someone strong!
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
The OP is why I see battle power gaps as being inconsistent, not to mention Kaioken x2 Goku VS Vegeta being a solid advantage before Vegeta even dished out his full power. As Fearless said, gaps aren't entirely consistent due to the necessity of a balance between Shouki, Yuuki and Genki needed to fight at one's fullest capabilities.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
Vegeta/Kiwi 22,500,000
Dodoria 30,000,000
Zarbon 32,500,000
Vegeta 37,500,000


My levels account for all of this. Kiwi was was simply finished way too easily to be a 75% gap. Lowering Dodoria to 20k may fix the issue between he and Vegeta, but it creates the issue of Vegeta's old power and Kiwi being rivals of Dodoria, which is never implied. Dodoria should be on the lower end of rivaling Zarbon, but both Dodoria and Zarbon should be head and shoulders above Kiwi and Vegeta's old power. That's my interpretation of the narrative.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
And I go with the Kaioken theory...

Full Power Vegeta 22,500,000
KKx2 Goku 20,000,000
Initial Vegeta 17,500,000
Kaioken Goku 15,000,000
Base Goku 10,000,000


Kaioken being a 1.5x boost works for this situation best.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
My gaps are as consistent as possible, you have to throw away the scouter numbers and use them as a guideline to have anything close to any sort of consistency. It will never be perfect, but doing this way severely limits the options that are not reasonable. There's really only a handful of inconsistency in my levels, almost everything has been accounted for.
 

Pyro

Elite
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
9,061
Fuck, man, I'm beginning to just disregard gaps entirely. They're kind of fucking retarded.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
Lol, why? You do the best you can with what you got.
 

Future Warrior

Elite
Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
6,149
Age
22
Honestly, it's better to analyze a characters strength by feats and statements rather than looking at it from a numerical standpoint. Battle powers are good for indicating who's stronger than who, but they clearly aren't linear.

Vegeta (Post-Zenkai) >> Zarbon > Dodoria >> Saiyan arc Vegeta/Cui >> KKx2 Goku

That's what the story tells us.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
Nearly everything in life can be broken down into numerical value. Surely something as simple as battle powers can as well.

Also, you are wrong on that. Vegeta is not so superior that he can defeat the team of Zarbon and Dodoria.

This is why actions, fights, statements must all be taken into account to determine what the proper placement is...

Then it comes to simple math, you set out a few numbers, compare and contrast and get a standard among the people debating it. This is really not all that difficult people, it's a kid's cartoons show haha
 

Future Warrior

Elite
Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
6,149
Age
22
Whatever, I just use 20/21/24 and I'm fine with it. Work with what we have like you said.
 

withheldforprivacy

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jun 19, 2015
Messages
8,308
Pyro said:
Going by the officially released numbers, either through the guidebooks or the manga, Kui, Dodoria, Zarbon, and Vegeta (pre-zenkai) are all within the 18,000 to 24,000 range.

Vegeta: 24,000
Zarbon: 23,000
Dodoria: 22,000
Kui: 18,000

That's a fairly small range of only 6,000 units, yet Vegeta was able to essentially one-shot Kui, easily overwhelm Dodoria, and take down Zarbon with somewhat more effort than Dodoria.


138-_Y8n7f.jpg

139-96qf_I.jpg

140-wm2w4.jpg

141-me_Vbb.jpg

142-_UE22_P.jpg

143-_P1l_Ka.jpg

038-_Fxh_Mb.jpg

039-y_Mg_ZO.jpg

040-_SBMLD.jpg

041-h8a_HS.jpg

042-e68fi.jpg

043-sgv_RA.jpg

045-_FKpio.jpg

046-_Ske_QM.jpg

047-z7g_Ax.jpg

106-4ec1h.jpg

107-5qys_C.jpg

108-_JOJyc.jpg

109-ju_CVa.jpg

110-b_PKgw.jpg

111-g_M6m_P.jpg

112-_IU6_EA.jpg

113-o70_Vw.jpg

114-_V46_IV.jpg

115-_C2v_Pj.jpg

116-nz_Fu_F.jpg

118-_Crdy_T.jpg


Vegeta owned Kui basically as savagely as Goku did using Kaio-ken x3.

As you can see in his fight with Dodoria, the most visible effort he needed to put forth was in his finishing blast to obliterate him. He was straining to hold Dodoria's arms back, but even then, he was smiling as well, so I put it at a little less effort. Other than that, he was easily blocking and dodging Dodoria's attacks.

Zarbon was similar in inferiority to Dodoria, but Vegeta was more visibly putting effort into his assault than he did with the latter. Zarbon is almost completely unable to track Vegeta's movements, and is unable to defend himself from the physical hits. I wouldn't peg Zarbon as too much stronger than Dodoria based on their performances. Then Zarbon transformed and owned Vegeta just about as well as Vegeta owned Kui, which I previously likened to Kaio-ken x3 Goku vs Vegeta on Earth.

We know from the power levels given in the manga that Goku was "over 8,000" and Vegeta was sitting pretty at about 18,000. Using Kaio-ken x3, that would put Goku at over 24,000, giving him a solid 25% advantage over Vegeta. With the way that slaughter went, 25% sounds very reasonable. With the tables turned, Vegeta being at 24,000 and Kui being at 18,000, the way the fight played out was to be expected. A 25% advantage seems like a total slaughter, and it's backed up by two fights.

However, Dodoria was owned pretty easily, which you wouldn't think would be possible given he'd be only roughly 9% weaker. Zarbon would make it even more bizarre being only roughly 5% weaker. Firstly, would a 4% difference allow Zarbon to elicit noticeably more effort from Vegeta? And secondly, would Vegeta really be able to make a fool out of Zarbon and Dodoria with only a 5% and 9% advantage, respectively? That seems crazy to be able to own two guys that are both less than 10% weaker than you, with one who might as well be on equal footing. Working together, those two would be able to take someone who could trounce them individually.

But the problem doesn't disappear even if their levels are lowered with Dodoria at 20,000 and Zarbon at 21,000. That would make them 17% and 13% weaker, respectively. It's a bit better, but still, is it enough to actually believe in such uneven fights? 17% sounds fair enough, but Zarbon being at 87% of Vegeta and still soundly being defeated turns up a boiled fish. Comparing a 25% difference beatdown to a 5%/13% and 9%/17% beatdown looks out of whack and inconsistent. How does one go from being completely devastated and puking up blood at 25% inferiority, to being manhandled and unable to see the opponent at 9%, to just slightly less damning at 5%? That seems like a lot of similar ownage for too much of a numerical discrepancy to me.

Most commonly I see 1-15% being on equal footing to rivaling, 20-30% being a stomp, and 30%+ being rape. How did we get there from the Namek arc's hilariously tiny gaps?

For future bouts, do we use 5% as a good indicator of being able to maybe track an opponent but still being totally unable to win, and then 9% as being unable to track and unable to win, and all the way up to 25% being a Doom massacre? What about anything between 9% and 25%? And if 5% is a one-sided battle, what qualifies as equal—a 2% difference?

Anyway, I'm beginning to sound like a half-blown retard. I hope you get what I'm trying to ask here.

2x Kaioken Goku vs Vegeta provides a good starting point; the minimum gap for ensured victory (when both sides
have considerable fighting skill), is about 1.11x. Vegeta/Zarbon gap is in the same range. Zarbon held his own
(he followed Vegeta's movements in the beginning and Vegeta had to exert effort to deflect the blast) before
losing his cool (yuuki).
3x Kaioken Goku vs Vegeta was not a solid 1.33x gap, because Goku's power was dropping rapidly. So that fight is
not a good model for gaps.
 

Future Warrior

Elite
Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
6,149
Age
22
Goku using standard Kaio-Ken 3 times before using 3 fold outta made him a good deal weaker than normally.
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
p123 said:
Lol, why? You do the best you can with what you got.
p123 said:
My gaps are as consistent as possible, you have to throw away the scouter numbers and use them as a guideline to have anything close to any sort of consistency.
Because ignoring what numbers are shown in the series and being fuelled by pure headcannon is making the best out of what we're given. :ladd
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
The 18/20/21/24 numbers are not as bad as the 18/22/23/24 numbers, but they both alleviate only one problem. There are several.

1) Vegeta's dominance over Zarbon and Dodoria need to be pronounced. 22/23/24 just isn't going to cut it, if that were the case, we would have insanely small gaps for nearly everything.

2) Zarbon and Dodoria can definitely beat Vegeta if they team up together. The gaps shouldn't be so pronounced that making this a reality should be difficult.

3) Dodoria's power is treated on a completely different level than Cui. This is where I agree with the 18/22. I believe that is an accurate spacing between Pre Earth Vegeta and Cui's standing next to Dodoria. However, giving Dodoria a 22 here makes him too close to Vegeta.

This is why using your own numbers is infinitely better. AT literally slopped these numbers together and didn't give these numbers a second thought. The community as a whole is fanatical in following these numbers. We've had time to dissect every moment and compare and compare and contrast as a whole over the course of several years. Anyone arguing for scouter numbers or guidebook numbers is absolutely insane. It's like arguing against Skyrim's mod authors for "belittling" the original creation. It's madness.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
Don't be so foolish CC. Cherry picking statements now? You are better than that.

You should use the scouter numbers to set guidelines, then let following statements, fights dictate the parameters and compare and contrast. Stick with what works, discard what doesn't.

This isn't an unreasonable request. This is the best option. Foolish child.
 
Top