Captain Cadaver said:So, is this Z/Pre-God or Post-God SS3 Goku? That makes a lot of difference.
Also, what about character mindsets? That can make a huge difference when taking into account the hax most Saint Seiya characters have and Galu's trend of not going for the win immediately/letting his guard down.
The difference between the low end of Solar System level and the high end of Multi-Solar System level is at least trillions times wide and battle powers aren't a linear judgement of energy output, so scaling wouldn't be a strong argument in those situations.Tapion said:Multi Solar System level is more like Toei Freeza, actually, since the Namek explosion was portrayed as hundreds, if not thousands of light years wide.
And, well, Broly destroyed a fraction of the South Galaxy while he was being restrained by Paragus. And Hatchiyack, who is on par with FP LSSj Broly, was shown warping and messing with nebulaes all over the North Galaxy as soon as he was born, which was followed with King Kai stating his power was so huge he might as well spell the North Galaxy's end. Multi Solar System is a grievous low end. Take the following feats into account:
We aren't given much of an accurate scale on Otherworld's size, beyond the Kaioshinkai making up 10% of the DB Macroverse, plus shaking/disruption feats generally aren't the most solid when considering Solar System level characters such as manga SS3 Gotenks and Evil Boo can still make holes in space-time.1. Toei Goku shook the entirety of the Other World (which is, of course, universal in size) when he powered up against Janemba.
This could easily be considered part of his reality warping ability rather than actual power, so I'd say that's questionable.2. Janemba warped the entirety of the Other World as soon as he was born.
Vegetto states that "the universe would be crushed by multiple dimensions!", which is a fair bit different from saying it'd be done by Boo's power outright which was just creating the cracks to allow it. In principle, it's the same as saying a construction worker is a building buster for being the one to pull the trigger on the vehicle or explosives demolishing it.3. Gohan-Boo (who in Toeiland is weaker than Pure Boo)'s Vice Shout was tearing the living world apart and gradually creating distortions that were going to quickly destroy the entire universe.
The feat shown in the anime shows their gradual destruction, being little different from M8 Broly's feat, still being Multi-Solar System level.4. A suppressed Pure Boo was stated (and shown) on Shin's flashback to have destroyed several galaxies during his rampages
This part is actually interesting. Do you have a link for the statement.5. Pure Boo created an energy ball that was going to destroy the Grand Kai's world, which is visible and orbits next to Heaven - a planet that is stated in the Daizenshuu to be as big as the living world itself.
The key word there is gradually, implying it would take a lot of time for the entire universe to be corroded, thus being via chain reaction as well as likely being from Liang Xing Long's pollution ability.For Gogeta, consider that he instantaneously purified Yi Xing Long's Negative Karma Ball, which possessed enough spread-out energy to gradually destroy the entire universe. That's probably a Universe level feat, since the entirety, non-spreadout condensed energy was Universal and Gogeta instantly overrode it.
Captain Cadaver said:The difference between the low end of Solar System level and the high end of Multi-Solar System level is at least trillions times wide and battle powers aren't a linear judgement of energy output, so scaling wouldn't be a strong argument in those situations.
Captain Cadaver said:We aren't given much of an accurate scale on Otherworld's size, beyond the Kaioshinkai making up 10% of the DB Macroverse, plus shaking/disruption feats generally aren't the most solid when considering Solar System level characters such as manga SS3 Gotenks and Evil Boo can still make holes in space-time.
Captain Cadaver said:This could easily be considered part of his reality warping ability rather than actual power, so I'd say that's questionable.
Captain Cadaver said:This could easily be considered part of his reality warping ability rather than actual power, so I'd say that's questionable.
Captain Cadaver said:Vegetto states that "the universe would be crushed by multiple dimensions!", which is a fair bit different from saying it'd be done by Boo's power outright which was just creating the cracks to allow it. In principle, it's the same as saying a construction worker is a building buster for being the one to pull the trigger on the vehicle or explosives demolishing it.
Captain Cadaver said:The feat shown in the anime shows their gradual destruction, being little different from M8 Broly's feat, still being Multi-Solar System level.
Captain Cadaver said:This part is actually interesting. Do you have a link for the statement.
Heaven
Area: Afterlife
Special Characteristics: The world where dead good people reside.
Events: Goku practiced for the 25th Tenkaichi Budoukai here. (Daizenshuu 4, p.73/ Daizenshuu 7, p.36)
Anime: Those sorted out as good people among the dead gather here. It is about as wide as the universe, and its entire surface is a field of flowers.
Captain Cadaver said:The key word there is gradually, implying it would take a lot of time for the entire universe to be corroded, thus being via chain reaction as well as likely being from Liang Xing Long's pollution ability.
Anime-wise, that's debatable, since the Steve Simmons translation translates it as "destroyed" and the term used definitely doesn't translate to "enslaved" and this is relevant if we're talking about the anime. Also, Goku isn't really too aware of Freeza's personality and only knows he's strong, evil and destroys planets, so Goku's impression of him being a planet destroying maniac could fit well with his limited knowledge.Tapion said:Goku's statement referred to the universe being enslaved by Freeza, and not him destroying it. Unlike Cell, who after his zenkai decided to go beyond Dr. Gero's plans and use IT to threaten all planets in the universe, Freeza had no reason to go around destroying everything. This comparison doesn't work out at all.
I just found this: http://vsbattles.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:Kepekley23/Dragon_Ball:_Goku_Shakes_the_Afterlife2. What do Gotenks and Super Boo's small space time holes have to do with anything at all? I'm talking about quakes. Causing tremors is a quantifiable energy feat, doing so on a universal scale is anywhere from galactic+ to multi-galactic in energy output. And it was done with excess ki alone.
Ah, fair enough. I wasn't aware of the statement. I wouldn't say Vegetto's compliment directly reinforces it, since it was clear he required effort so Multi-Galaxy or not, he'd make the statement regardless.Captain Cadaver said:The Daizenshuu elaborates on the feat, saying Gohan-Boo was expanding the distorted space, which would have eventually covered the entirety of the living world and obliterated the universe. Going by the fact that Vegito says "it was close" when he stops it, it was clearly going to be done extremely soon. That's easily multi galactic in scale.
Likewise, after Vegito stops the Vice Shout, he compliments Gohan Boo, saying he sure had awesome power and that he should use that exact same energy he wielded to try and hit him. Therefore, it's a legitimate feat from Boo's part.
Captain Cadaver said:The feat shown in the anime shows their gradual destruction, being little different from M8 Broly's feat, still being Multi-Solar System level.
I never argued he only destroyed one, just that as the feat implies, it wasn't instantaneous galaxy busting.The Dragon Ball Kai website posted a clip of that exact same scene, and the caption under the clip states that Boo had nearly destroyed the universe the last time he rampaged: https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/vsbattles/images/b/bb/038c09cd-e5cf-407d-8fda-f86b94fb2ae2.png/revision/latest?cb=20160424230730
That makes no sense if the destruction was limited to a single galaxy.
Powerscaling wouldn't get him to a completely different tier though.2. Lastly, Pure Boo did that feat while suppressed, as indicated by the fact that he goes around on a planet destroying spree after his revival on Earth, exactly as he was stated to have done when the Kaioshins assembled to try and stop him, and Goku is shown fighting him as a mere Super Saiyan 2. Even if we were to take the visual at face value and assume he only destroyed one galaxy, he was holding back plenty of power.
I got your point, but I still have my disagreements with it. After all, the Minus Energy corrosion is likely the ability inherited from Liang Xing Long, who's pollution certainly wasn't something that could be condensed down or even really be attributed to his level of power.You didn't get my point. Sure, it'd be gradual and slow, however, all of that gradual energy originates from the same source - the Negative Karma Ball. Yi Xing Long threw it at Gogeta, who instantly purified ALL the energy inside that same ball, which had the condensed energy to destroy the universe.
That's still quite questionable, considering we never saw the feat and destroying all the galaxies around it is still somewhat vague without an actual image, especially considering Popo's basic speech pattern.Lastly, Yi Xing Long''s feat of destroying galaxies wasn't low end. It was stated that he instantly destroyed all the galaxies surrounding his home world. That suggests he destroyed a cluster of galaxies, not just a couple.
Hence why I only said he'd get up to the Winged 8th Sense Bronze Saints, who are the weakest/slowest characters capable of these hyperbolic speed feats (traversed a universe sized space in a matter of minutes). You could technically argue Capricorn Shura with Athena's Ichor and a Miracle was the weakest of this tier (the one who surpassed the Big Bang's expansion), but that speed feat is obviously greater and he has the same soul manipulation hax as they do.Tapion said:As far as speed goes, however, Goku's best feats and scaling are at most in the trillions to quadrillions of times FTL (going by the Other World Arc, where he traveled half of the Other World in a couple minutes), while the Saint Seiya's cast best feats include surpassing the speed of the Big Bang's expansion and exchanging blows from several universes of distance, all of which are in the quintillions to sextillions.
Composite in this context means taking into account all of a characters' feats and abilities, including outliers, in order to create a peak version of them.SIAD said:What is this TOEI Goku SSJ3 Compound?
Captain Cadaver said:Composite in this context means taking into account all of a characters' feats and abilities, including outliers, in order to create a peak version of them.SIAD said:What is this TOEI Goku SSJ3 Compound?
Normally, Toei SS3 Goku would just be considered Multi-Solar System level, but with his outlier Galaxy level feat from Fusion Reborn and scaling from Gohan Boo's Vice Shout filler, he'd end up as Multi-Galaxy+ level when taking them into account.
Toei SS3 Goku is. Manga SS3 Goku is just Solar System level.SIAD said:I understand, then Goku SSJ3 obviously is Multi level Solar System.
It would be stronger than those two, since Gogeta and Yi Xing Long are just suggested to be Multi-Galaxy level, capable of destroying only several galaxies or so.If we talk about Goku SSJ3 Compound would be Multi-level Galaxy +, or would be even more powerful than it is Omega Yi Xing Long and probably Gogeta SSJ4.
Not within the vacuum of the Boo Arc, but when brought into the scope of Toei's continuity, it becomes hazy to take it into account as consistent. After all, none of GT's feats or statements quite measure up to it with a Multi-Galaxy feat of a far less impressive nature being treat as far more impressive overall. That, and supplementary material only refer to Yi Xing Long's base form as Galaxy level.Tapion said:Multi Galaxy isn't an outlier considering there are like...5 feats on that level in the Boo Arc.
Captain Cadaver said:Not within the vacuum of the Boo Arc, but when brought into the scope of Toei's continuity, it becomes hazy to take it into account as consistent. After all, none of GT's feats or statements quite measure up to it with a Multi-Galaxy feat of a far less impressive nature being treat as far more impressive overall. That, and supplementary material only refer to Yi Xing Long's base form as Galaxy level.Tapion said:Multi Galaxy isn't an outlier considering there are like...5 feats on that level in the Boo Arc.
As for Super, of which the anime should follow Kai's continuity, things get a lot more difficult to take it into account as consistent with Toei's overall continuity when considering Beerus and Whis treat Solar System busting in a manner as if it even meant anything to the main cast, which would hardly be the case if Enraged Vegeta ought to be Multi-Galaxy+ level via-scaling if taking into account Boo's Vice Shout.
Tapion said:Also, I still strongly maintain that Super Gogeta 4's energy output is Universal.
Gogeta instantly purified the entirety of the energy contained inside the Negative Karma Ball, which works by emitting pockets of energy off to gradually corrupt planets, until the entire universe is wiped out. All of that energy comes from the same source, it is just emitted gradually. However, Gogeta overrode and converted all of the source energy, making his energy output Universal.
To better explain my point of view, imagine that the energy required to destroy the universe is 1,000,000, and the Negative Karma Ball only emits 1 point of energy at a time. However, after some time, the Negative Karma Ball will have emitted all of the 1,000,000 points without having had its source fully depleted. That means the condensed energy inside it is 1,000,000 (aka universe destroying), it's just spread out over a long time.
However, Gogeta converted all 1,000,000 points, all the energy at once and instantaneously. Therefore, he overrode enough energy to destroy the universe.