Battle City duelists' rate

withheldforprivacy

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jun 19, 2015
Messages
8,308
It is highly implied Yugi initially stood almost zero chance against Marik and finally had some hope because of
the card Kaiba gave him. On the other hand, Joey technically beat Marik and also technically lost to Odeon.
Ok, i know duelists aren't DBZ fighters and can't be judged with the PL system, but can we conclude:

Odeon>Joey>Marik>Yugi (minus Kaiba's card)>Kaiba
 

Animelover5487

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2015
Messages
2,787
Marik was toying with Joey, he didn't even use most of the cards or strategies he used against Yami that almost put him in a corner.

Anyway my Battle City chain would be:

Yami Yugi > Yami Marik >= Kaiba > Normal Marik > Odion >= Joey > Ishizu > Yami Bakura > Mai Valentine
 

Pyro

Elite
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
9,061
I don't agree with OP's chain at all. For one, Yugi (and by extension Kaiba) was always ahead of Joey, especially with an Egyptian God Card in his arsenal. Secondly, it was made clear that Yami Marik was toying with Joey the entire time and simply mistook Joey's dopiness for incompetence, hence why he didn't foresee Joey withstanding a hit from Ra and didn't have a plan if that failed; the guy was owning Yami Yugi with ease for 99% of their duel, after all. Thirdly, Odion was considered to be inferior to normal Marik, let alone Yami Marik, who changed his play style and most of the cards in his deck to make it much stronger. Fourthly, Kaiba should be almost exactly equal to Yami Yugi given his performance in their semi-finals duel; Yugi simply had to win because it was his destiny to stop Marik. Lastly, nobody could seriously contend with Yami Marik on their own. It took the combination of Kaiba's intelligence and Yugi's skill/plot armor to take down Ra. On their own, Kaiba and Yugi each admitted they couldn't do it (well, Kaiba's confidence is a bit inconsistent because he thinks he can win with just Obelisk but then also thinks he needs Slifer to stand a chance).

Yami Marik > Yugi >= Kaiba > Marik > Odion >~ Joey >~ Yami Bakura > Ishizu >/< Mai Valentine

That's what I'd put the chain as when considering all of the above reasoning. I put Ishizu that low because without her future-seeing necklace, she's not implied to be anything special.
 

Pyro

Elite
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
9,061
At the moment I'm not sure.

It honestly shouldn't be too much different. The only person I'd rate lower is Yami Marik, only because he relied so heavily on Ra that we only got glimpses of his skill without it. I'd put Kaiba and Yugi above Yami Marik. It's more difficult to rate this arc due to the saturation of the God Cards; real strategy took a backseat.

I know Yugi and Bakura's manga duel is a bit different, with Yugi not being at such an obvious disadvantage without Slifer. Not sure about their anime duel.
 

Latest profile posts

Trump is the rightful democratically elected president of Brazil :trump
SHOW ME UR PREZIDENT FACE!!!
Top