Blackbeard vs Garp compared to Blackbeard vs Kizaru/Aokiji

[Warmmedown]

Should Blackbeard have a tougher time with Garp than with the logias? Because Garp hasn't developed a fighting style dependent on being a logia, whereas the logias have, so having their fruit removed by touch would cause more problems for them. Yeh, when punched with haki they also lose their logia ability and can be hurt, but in that case they can still use their own haki to defend against the haki punch and not take as much damage, due to retaining some of their logia nature by using their haki to defend it the opponent's haki. Plus haki is used for punches, but we haven't seen someone use it to GRAB a logia, like Blackbeard did.
Plus BB can nullify attacks when touching them and actively using his fruit, so it's harder to counter him with DF-based attacks. We saw this when he fought WB. Yeh, Admirals have haki, but they're used to using logia-based attacks and those are probably their strongest.

 

[SSJ2]

Yeah I'd be very curious about this. His fruit causes him to take more damage, so how does he handle non devil fruit powers near his level? He has WB's fruit now to help, but how would he fight someone like Mihawk?

Blackbeard was willing to back down when Rayleigh showed up, even though Rayleigh knew he could never beat him in a fight. But maybe Blackbeard does have some level of caution against non-fruit users.