- Joined
- Sep 4, 2015
- Messages
- 14,402
So according to Herms, what Cell stated was more like:
Cell : Take a look. Vegeta and Trunks are barely holding their own
With the "ya", being a non-exhaustive term, possibly indicating Vegeta and Trunks weren't necessarily the only ones holding their own, just the first examples to come to Cell's head.
Though I asked @BedroomBully about that, and he said that's not the case, that while the "ya" is used to suggest options, like a "or", for the statement to include others, grammatically, it should have a “達” after Trunks' name, while without its usage, it'd make no sense for Cell to be considering anyone else. Since Cell mentions only Vegeta and Trunks without the "達" suffix, it suggests that he is specifically referring to those two individuals. The absence of "達" indicates that he is not including others in his statement, although the non-exhaustive "や" (ya) leaves the statement slightly open-ended. It's a subtle distinction, but in the context of Cell's character and the situation, he is likely only pointing out Vegeta and Trunks by name due to their prominence as the strongest fighters there rather than making a generalized statement about all fighters present.
Credits to @BedroomBully
as I'd be totally clueless if he didn't point it out
Cell : Take a look. Vegeta and Trunks are barely holding their own
With the "ya", being a non-exhaustive term, possibly indicating Vegeta and Trunks weren't necessarily the only ones holding their own, just the first examples to come to Cell's head.
Though I asked @BedroomBully about that, and he said that's not the case, that while the "ya" is used to suggest options, like a "or", for the statement to include others, grammatically, it should have a “達” after Trunks' name, while without its usage, it'd make no sense for Cell to be considering anyone else. Since Cell mentions only Vegeta and Trunks without the "達" suffix, it suggests that he is specifically referring to those two individuals. The absence of "達" indicates that he is not including others in his statement, although the non-exhaustive "や" (ya) leaves the statement slightly open-ended. It's a subtle distinction, but in the context of Cell's character and the situation, he is likely only pointing out Vegeta and Trunks by name due to their prominence as the strongest fighters there rather than making a generalized statement about all fighters present.
Credits to @BedroomBully
as I'd be totally clueless if he didn't point it out