Captain Cadaver said:The translation is right and I'd agree with it, given the reasoning I provided for Dabura > MSSJ Goku in the other thread. It's worth noting, however, the anime gives Dabura and Gohan buffs such as the former's meditation or the latter being suggested to have gained a Zenkai, plus the anime leans heavily towards Gohan being a SS2 in the fight with him telling Dabura he's going all-out.
Captain Cadaver said:The translation is right and I'd agree with it, given the reasoning I provided for Dabura > MSSJ Goku in the other thread. It's worth noting, however, the anime gives Dabura and Gohan buffs such as the former's meditation or the latter being suggested to have gained a Zenkai, plus the anime leans heavily towards Gohan being a SS2 in the fight with him telling Dabura he's going all-out.
Captain Cadaver said:I was speaking about Anime Dabura and Gohan, since this is the version being discussed here.
As for your points about Dabura, that only shows Vegeta's SS2 self was stronger than he thought rather than him only thinking Vegeta had access to SSJ. If anything, Vegeta made it pretty clear to Goku he did have access to the form as it was very apparent Vegeta caught on to Goku having achieved the form and still declared he wanted to fight Goku.
Dabura stated that he found a more suitable opponent for them rather than a stronger one, suggesting he didn't think Vegeta would surpass him. There's also little reason to believe Goku was suppressed against Yakon when his aura was clearly flaring unlike in previous suppressions and he didn't try to bring out more power in his SSJ state and instead resorted to SS2. If anything, this and Dabura's assurance of Babidi's safety support him being above MSSJ Goku/Majin Vegeta, regardless of which form Gohan was using against him.
Vegeta has SS2 and stronger than Gohan in equal forms, so him defeating Dabura instantly is still something he can accomplish. Goku has been consistently shown in the Cell Arc to only have his aura blaring as he did against Yakon when he uses his full power in the form, so the art supports him being at full power, not to mention having no real in-universe rationale for being suppressed. This leads to one of two paths:Super Saiyan said:I think you could have a case for Gohan, but Goku not so much. Vegeta is frustrated by Gohan's inability to beat Dabra, implying that he personally would be able to. Goku was far ahead of pre-Majin Vegeta, so I don't see how he could be weaker than Dabra. Goku himself said SSJ Gohan wasn't completely losing.
Standing Ki is consistently shown to be far below a fighter's actual power even in Super Saiyan. The most blatant example would be Gero still believing #19 could handle SSJ Goku, as well as Trunks needing to test Goku in battle rather than just reading his Ki.SIAD said:I agree with what you say, the only thing that differs is that if Goku knows that Majin Vegeta SSJ is equal to Goku SSJ. Logically, Goku would know that Goku SSJ2 is equal to Majin Vegeta SSJ2.
Goku also talked about defeating Majin Vegeta in record time. Sounds like it's a single hit. I don't think that Goku SSJ2 (Boo) defeats Vegeta SSJ2 (Pre Majin) with one blow.
Captain Cadaver said:Vegeta has SS2 and stronger than Gohan in equal forms, so him defeating Dabura instantly is still something he can accomplish. Goku has been consistently shown in the Cell Arc to only have his aura blaring as he did against Yakon when he uses his full power in the form, so the art supports him being at full power, not to mention having no real in-universe rationale for being suppressed. This leads to one of two paths:Super Saiyan said:I think you could have a case for Gohan, but Goku not so much. Vegeta is frustrated by Gohan's inability to beat Dabra, implying that he personally would be able to. Goku was far ahead of pre-Majin Vegeta, so I don't see how he could be weaker than Dabra. Goku himself said SSJ Gohan wasn't completely losing.
1. Gohan was a SS2 against Dabura despite what the lack of lightning suggests (of which a case could be made for, but that's a shitstorm for another thread)
2. Dabura wasn't going all-out against Gohan.
Standing Ki is consistently shown to be far below a fighter's actual power even in Super Saiyan. The most blatant example would be Gero still believing #19 could handle SSJ Goku, as well as Trunks needing to test Goku in battle rather than just reading his Ki.SIAD said:I agree with what you say, the only thing that differs is that if Goku knows that Majin Vegeta SSJ is equal to Goku SSJ. Logically, Goku would know that Goku SSJ2 is equal to Majin Vegeta SSJ2.
Goku also talked about defeating Majin Vegeta in record time. Sounds like it's a single hit. I don't think that Goku SSJ2 (Boo) defeats Vegeta SSJ2 (Pre Majin) with one blow.
Depends on the continuity. For the anime, definitely Gohan being SS2 as he suggests so pretty heavily through his statements. Manga-wise, it's more difficult to gauge. Most of the art points to him being a SSJ, whereas most of the statements and general narrative conventions lean more towards him being a SS2, as would supplementary guidebook statements. It's something I'm on the fence about at the moment.SIAD said:Which option are you going for?
Captain Cadaver said:Depends on the continuity. For the anime, definitely Gohan being SS2 as he suggests so pretty heavily through his statements. Manga-wise, it's more difficult to gauge. Most of the art points to him being a SSJ, whereas most of the statements and general narrative conventions lean more towards him being a SS2, as would supplementary guidebook statements. It's something I'm on the fence about at the moment.SIAD said:Which option are you going for?
There seems to be a definite difference between standing Ki and when simply standing around and standing Ki when prepared for a fight, the latter of which applies to both the Yakon and Majin Vegeta situation. Goku/Vegeta being far above Cell Game Gohan wouldn't really work when Pre-Majin Vegeta is likely below him based on his comment and Piccolo suggests the gap between them isn't anything huge.SIAD said:I'm thinking that maybe Goku SSJ went with everything against Yakon, but being in a state of rest, maybe Goku SSJ exceeded 3,000 Kiris.
Another point that I got to thinking about is that maybe Goku and Majin Vegeta SSJ2 could be even stronger than we thought, since when Vegeta mentions that Goku surpassed the Gohan 7 years ago, Goku was in a state of rest.
Captain Cadaver said:There seems to be a definite difference between standing Ki and when simply standing around and standing Ki when prepared for a fight, the latter of which applies to both the Yakon and Majin Vegeta situation. Goku/Vegeta being far above Cell Game Gohan wouldn't really work when Pre-Majin Vegeta is likely below him based on his comment and Piccolo suggests the gap between them isn't anything huge.SIAD said:I'm thinking that maybe Goku SSJ went with everything against Yakon, but being in a state of rest, maybe Goku SSJ exceeded 3,000 Kiris.
Another point that I got to thinking about is that maybe Goku and Majin Vegeta SSJ2 could be even stronger than we thought, since when Vegeta mentions that Goku surpassed the Gohan 7 years ago, Goku was in a state of rest.
Captain Cadaver said:There seems to be a definite difference between standing Ki and when simply standing around and standing Ki when prepared for a fight, the latter of which applies to both the Yakon and Majin Vegeta situation. Goku/Vegeta being far above Cell Game Gohan wouldn't really work when Pre-Majin Vegeta is likely below him based on his comment and Piccolo suggests the gap between them isn't anything huge.SIAD said:I'm thinking that maybe Goku SSJ went with everything against Yakon, but being in a state of rest, maybe Goku SSJ exceeded 3,000 Kiris.
Another point that I got to thinking about is that maybe Goku and Majin Vegeta SSJ2 could be even stronger than we thought, since when Vegeta mentions that Goku surpassed the Gohan 7 years ago, Goku was in a state of rest.
It's more a testament to Vegeta's mental fortitude than his power, considering his strength of character and ambition is a defining trait of Vegeta's, not to mention the depths of his power (ie. SS2) already exceed Dabura's anyway.SIAD said:The only thing that yes, Babidi managed to control Dabura, while Majin Vegeta SSJ did not succeed. Will Majin Vegeta mean SSJ> Dabura?