M8 Broli vs M10 Gohan

[Southern Gothic]

Who wins?

 

[Fantastische Hure]

Gohan wins, because Movie 8 Broly is lower than any Super-Saiyan 2, in my opinion.

 

[Six Trails]

He'd easily win as a Super Saiyan 2.

 

[Clearin]

I'm not too good with movies, much less movie 10, but I'll give it a shot:
Gohan thinks he can beat Broly, which certainly suggests Gohan could beat Broly from movie 8, but Gohan also says Broly is "as bad" as he was 7 years ago. It also seems Gohan may have overestimated his strength since he says he was "supposed" to have gotten stronger, suggesting he actually didn't (which fits with canon).

Going just by the movie strength checker over on F, I can't actually see any quotes that say Broly actually got stronger. Wasn't there a line about him getting a zenkai? I could have sworn I remember that.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

It was stated in the Daizenshuu, I think.

 

[Southern Gothic]

There's no line in the movie about a zenkai. And just to play devil's advocate, the line about "supposedly getting stronger" also works in relation to Broli's power. As in, Gohan's new strength pales in comparison. Considering how weak Gohan was in M8, powering up doesn't mean very much.

I do think Gohan takes this, but I think it comes down to whether you believe M10 Gohan is his own character, or he is meant to be his Boo Saga self.

Since Gohan is flying around in his dogi, ready for action (very much unlike Boo arc Gohan), I comsider this a different incarnation.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

There's no line in the movie about a zenkai. And just to play devil's advocate, the line about "supposedly getting stronger" also works in relation to Broli's power. As in, Gohan's new strength pales in comparison. Considering how weak Gohan was in M8, powering up doesn't mean very much.

I do think Gohan takes this, but I think it comes down to whether you believe M10 Gohan is his own character, or he is meant to be his Boo Saga self.

Since Gohan is flying around in his dogi, ready for action (very much unlike Boo arc Gohan), I comsider this a different incarnation.

I very much agree.

 

[Ryuzaki]

If M8 Broly is as strong as in M10 (though I doubt it, otherwise he would have wrecked everyone in one blow), he stomps. Otherwise, Gohan wins easily.

 

[Super Saiyan Overlord1007]

SSJ Gohan stomps RSSJ Broly but gets stomped by LSSJ Broly. SSJ2 Gohan would smash his face in.