Mr. 5 vs Arlong

[ahill]

vs

Who wins?

 

[SSJ2]

Arlong imo. Mr 5 was treated like trash by Luffy and Zoro who could basically one shot him while they were focused on fighting each other. They are obviously stronger than they were against Arlong, but I'd still give Arlong the advantage here.

 

[ahill]

Arlong imo. Mr 5 was treated like trash by Luffy and Zoro who could basically one shot him while they were focused on fighting each other. They are obviously stronger than they were against Arlong, but I'd still give Arlong the advantage here.

What about Mr.2 (Bon-Clay) vs Arlong?

 

[SSJ2]

I'd give it to Mr.2. He was pretty well on par with Alabasta Sanji.

 

[xmysticgohanx]

Hmm mr. 2 vs arlong is a tough one.

 

[Pocket-God]

I give the match to Arlong, since he has two dicks while Mr.5 only has one :elmo

 

[Diamond Ryan]

Arlong rapes hard. Luffy beat the tar out of Mr. 5 before he even got serious, while Luffy's initial warm up attack did nothing to Arlong.

 

[SSJ2]

Luffy powered up...

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Same as the majority already said. Whiskey Peak Luffy shouldn't be much stronger than the version who beat Arlong, yet he and Zoro didn't even treat Mr. 5 as worth acknowledging during their scuffle. Arlong wrecks hard. Even Hachi and Kuroobi probably low diff him too, though I'd imagine Mr. 5 could beat Chew without much problem.

As for Mr. 2 VS Arlong, I'd say Mr. 2 wins fairly easily. He was shown capable of damaging a foe that Impel Down Luffy needed his Gears for and wasn't implied to have become any stronger during his imprisonment.

 

[Diamond Ryan]

Luffy powered up...

Not by any noticeable amount imo. Certainly not enough to stomp Arlong before he even gets serious.

 

[SSJ2]

Then you're wrong and you should feel wrong.