My problem when making tier lists

[Six Trails]

So, I'm not sure if this happens to anyone else, but when making tier lists, I always have trouble separating tiers/characters. For example, let's take Fat Boo, SS3 Goku, and SS Gotenks.

I do think Fat Boo and Goku are in the same tier, I do think Goku and Gotenks are in the same tier, but I don't think Boo and Gotenks are in the same tier. Do you see the problem? Where would I separate the characters into different tiers? Or do I just put them all in one? :|

 

[Fantastische Hure]

That's a problem I had, too. I remember early DragonBall Z with the Saiyan to Namek Saga that happened a lot.

I think, maybe just draw a line in how the show portrays both characters, and treats them. If Majin-Boo gets treated like a joke once Super-Boo shows-up that obviously means neither can be in the same tier, so try to draw the line from there maybe.

Like Bardock and Vegeta (Saiyan-Saga) can't be in the same tier (in my opinion), because Vegeta thinks nothing of someone at Bardock's level of power.

 

[sei'taer]

I'd put them all on the same tier, just with buu at the bottom and gotenks at the top.

 

[Zippy]

Number them in the same tier as 1. 2. 3. Weaker as you go down.

 

[Pyro]

I'd just make broader tiers, so even if Fat Boo isn't close to SS Gotenks, they're still both nowhere near SS3 Gotenks/Super Boo.

 

[Let's Go Fearless!]

I don't have Gotenks that much stronger than Boo.

 

[MissingUTAH]

I think they can all fit in one tier as long as you're only using SSJ1 Gotenks.