- Joined
- May 31, 2015
- Messages
- 27,967
It goes without saying that Dragon Ball is a flawed series filled with many plot holes, contrivances, character inconsistencies and numerous retcons. Still, it must also have a fair amount of positives to keep us interested in it for so long (assuming it's not just nostalgia that keeps you going). That said, what would you cite as the best aspect of the franchise?
I'd say one that comes to mind is seeing how vastly characters change over time, particularly in settling down to their new lifestyle, growing up and having children to make it somewhat of a generational story in a way that many of the Shonen inspired by it don't accomplish to the same degree; mainly due to being either purely superficial "growth" or leaving things such as becoming family leaders down to just the finale (cough cough Naruto). It wasn't accomplished anywhere near as well as in JoJo's Bizarre Adventure due to the insistence to keep Goku in the spotlight, but was still something that allowed it to stand out from a lot of other Shonen both at the time and since.
Another is more to do with a specific period of the franchise, being the training segments up to the end of the Saiyan Arc. Dragon Ball and early DBZ put a lot more effort into portraying interesting training regimes with steady in-universe pacing and a clear philosophy behind them that helped them stand apart from many other Shonen of the time and still hold up well today. This unfortunately was phased out from the Freeza Arc and onwards where training methods just became extreme versions of Kaio's gravity training without any additional lesson behind them and were nowhere near as prevalent as quick, cheap power ups, but this strength of early DB is one still worth giving praise to.
What element probably holds up the best for the longest stretch of the series, however, is its balancing between genre and tone. The gradual transition from a primarily comedic action/adventure series to a serious battle Shonen was well done due to the tones of comedy and seriousness being well placed and perfectly balancedas all things should be from the Red Ribbon Arc and onward until fully establishing itself as a serious work with comedic elements around the Piccolo Daimao Arc. On top of that, it managed to transition from a series rooted in eastern martial arts and mythology into what was mainly a sci-fi action series without becoming dissonant from the story's core genres by building upon it and providing the proper context for them to mesh well, something that is worth a lot of praise when so few series nowadays are able to maintain the elements that drew in fans initially by becoming completely different.
Unfortunately, this strength hasn't remained constant throughout the series' run. Many could cite the Boo Arc as seeming a bit out of place in its return to very comedic moments and more of a mystical element than most of Z. Whilst I'd say the tones were still well balanced enough once the arc's main conflict started to kick off, I will cite GT and Super as being unable to keep tones balanced by both wanting to immediately go back to Part 1's comedic roots and than shift entirely to serious DBZ elements without the proper transition. Still, the fact that this element managed to hold up for at least the majority of the manga's original run is worth commending and an aspect that is fairly overlooked as a great strength of the series.
Enough of me rambling about what I consider the best things about DB. Feel free to share your own thoughts now.
I'd say one that comes to mind is seeing how vastly characters change over time, particularly in settling down to their new lifestyle, growing up and having children to make it somewhat of a generational story in a way that many of the Shonen inspired by it don't accomplish to the same degree; mainly due to being either purely superficial "growth" or leaving things such as becoming family leaders down to just the finale (cough cough Naruto). It wasn't accomplished anywhere near as well as in JoJo's Bizarre Adventure due to the insistence to keep Goku in the spotlight, but was still something that allowed it to stand out from a lot of other Shonen both at the time and since.
Another is more to do with a specific period of the franchise, being the training segments up to the end of the Saiyan Arc. Dragon Ball and early DBZ put a lot more effort into portraying interesting training regimes with steady in-universe pacing and a clear philosophy behind them that helped them stand apart from many other Shonen of the time and still hold up well today. This unfortunately was phased out from the Freeza Arc and onwards where training methods just became extreme versions of Kaio's gravity training without any additional lesson behind them and were nowhere near as prevalent as quick, cheap power ups, but this strength of early DB is one still worth giving praise to.
What element probably holds up the best for the longest stretch of the series, however, is its balancing between genre and tone. The gradual transition from a primarily comedic action/adventure series to a serious battle Shonen was well done due to the tones of comedy and seriousness being well placed and perfectly balanced
Unfortunately, this strength hasn't remained constant throughout the series' run. Many could cite the Boo Arc as seeming a bit out of place in its return to very comedic moments and more of a mystical element than most of Z. Whilst I'd say the tones were still well balanced enough once the arc's main conflict started to kick off, I will cite GT and Super as being unable to keep tones balanced by both wanting to immediately go back to Part 1's comedic roots and than shift entirely to serious DBZ elements without the proper transition. Still, the fact that this element managed to hold up for at least the majority of the manga's original run is worth commending and an aspect that is fairly overlooked as a great strength of the series.
Enough of me rambling about what I consider the best things about DB. Feel free to share your own thoughts now.