WOuld it be better if AT chose Majin Piccolo instead Vegeta?

[Let's Go Fearless!]

 

[kriss-]

Or both Majin Piccolo and Majin Vegeta. It would at least make Piccolo relevant again and visit the old ideas of him being a vanilla.

 

[xmysticgohanx]

Piccolo is relevant in Super

 

[kriss-]

You mean when he got his arm effortlessly ripped off by Tagoma, or when he got defeated by nothing more than Beerus' aura? Or how about the time Frieza humiliated him for a second time? Or the time when he spent an entire episode charging up his special attack only to miss?

 

[Let's Go Fearless!]

You mean when he got his arm effortlessly ripped off by Tagoma, or when he got defeated by nothing more than Beerus' aura? Or how about the time Frieza humiliated him for a second time? Or the time when he spent an entire episode charging up his special attack only to miss?

He's relevant in Universal tournament.

 

[Tapion]

You clearly didn't watch the episode. Frost was fodder to Piccolo until he cheated with that sharpy poison thing.

 

[kriss-]

Oh okay, he 'cheated'.

 

[Victorious]

No, because Piccolo back to being Kamiccolo now, he shouldn't be able to go Majin IMO.

 

[Clearin]

Maybe the Manga could give us a 2 page fight between Gohan and Majin Piccolo

 

[Papasmurf]

The manga would probably skip it instead like the whole FNF shit

 

[kriss-]

Piccolo being Kamiccolo shouldn't have no relevancy as to whether or not he could go Majin. Kamiccolo is like 90% Piccolo, whom was evil at one point. If the merged resulted in it being entirely composed of Kami -which it isn't, than it would be a viable theory.

 

[Papasmurf]

Even still, Kaioshin suggests one could fight off the possession by emptying the mind, which given Piccolo wouldn't want to be controlled unlike Vegeta, he could probably pull off.

 

[kriss-]

Now you're speaking in terms of hypothetical situations which aren't back by any sufficient evidence. If the plot required Piccolo to become a Majin, than it's obviously not out of the realm of possibility, given Piccolo's history of being evil.

 

[Papasmurf]

Piccolo turning Majin in of itself is hypothetical, as is "plot demand." But we do have a manga statement from Kaioshin himself stating there's a way to fight off the possession. With Piccolo being less evil than Vegeta, and the latter's admission that he let himself be controlled, there's a good possibility - even if not a certain case - that he'd be able to fight it off.

 

[kriss-]

The plot can demand whatever it wants without any valid reasoning and it can completely work against fan ideologies that are as valid as a grain of salt. Frieza surpassing Base Saiyans is an example of this and how the plot contradicted the common norm. Summarily, this particular scenario of Piccolo becoming a Majin is not exempt from this rule. If the plot demanded it than it's entirely plausible because of Piccolo's history.

Try again.

 

[Papasmurf]

And you obviously don't get to dictate the plot nor is there an already preexisting statement that invalidates Boo arc statements on the matter, so right backatcha.

 

[kriss-]

And you obviously don't get to dictate the plot nor is there an already preexisting statement that invalidates Boo arc statements on the matter, so right backatcha.

You clearly don't understand a very simple concept.

The plot can demand whatever it wants without any valid reasoning and it can completely work against fan ideologies that are as valid as a grain of salt.

Nothing says Piccolo could fight off the Majin charm, especially if he was evil at one point before. That's speculative and biased on your part.

All I'm saying is that if the plot demanded it, than it's entirely possible because of so and so reasons. However, you're trying to ascertain that's it's impossible due to whatever approach you're trying to take.

 

[Victorious]

Piccolo being Kamiccolo shouldn't have no relevancy as to whether or not he could go Majin. Kamiccolo is like 90% Piccolo, whom was evil at one point. If the merged resulted in it being entirely composed of Kami -which it isn't, than it would be a viable theory.

Kamiccolo is just back to where he started.If the original Kamiccolo couldnt become God of Earth, until ridding himelf of evil, then i don't think Kamiccolo can go Majin unless ridding himself of the good. At best i'd say he could go Majin but not be controllable unlike Dabura or the others Babidi fully controlled. So maybe he could get a boost but he would not have started fighting Goku and company.