base Gohan (boo arc, pre sword) vs #17

[ahill1]

Since against #18 Gohan won unanimously, what about her sibling?

 

[GSM123]

Now I think he loses here. Slightly weaker and with way worse stamina.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Gohan ought to lose. He's at best marginally stronger than the kids (if even that, if you take the Daizenshuu's word on the matter), who in turn are at best not significantly above #18. Couple this with #17's infinite energy, and it won't take long for Lapis to win.

 

[SSJ2]

Gohan loses this. If Piccolo couldn't beat 17 at equal powers, there's no way Gohan could do it after a 7 year layoff with minimal training.

 

[Six Trails]

Power-wise they are roughly the same but with Gohan's rustiness and 17's limitless stamina I'd say Gohan loses.