sei'taer said:
Narrative tropes exist for a reason and there's certainly nothing wrong with using them. Y'all spend way too much time hating on things you don't enjoy.
There's a difference between using tropes in a way to make an interesting story/character and using them for convenience/lack of creativity, the latter of which becomes far easier to do if lacking the talent and causes many series to fall into the generic category of seeming like more of the same. Tropes can indeed be of use, but it's all about execution and treading the line between the familiar and being a carbon copy.
Moreover, the thread isn't explicitly about tropes we find to be universally problematic (though there are several tropes that can generally weigh down the quality of a work), but about cliches within the medium in general.
Or to summarise, there's a difference between using a cliche and using it well.
Trying to subvert tropes for the sake of it gives us things like The Last Jedi.
Again, it's all down to execution. There are many cases where the "subverted expectations" angle ruins a work, but also many where the ability to mess with narrative conventions improves a work drastically. Something like No Country for Old Men, The Sopranos or (more fitting for this anime discussion) Neon Genesis Evangelion are unarguably better than
like The Last Jedi or Game of Thrones Season 8, despite all of them doing something to intentionally mess with narrative conventions.