- Joined
- May 30, 2015
- Messages
- 31,008
I've seen it. It sucked
Factually, Yuyu Hakusho shouldn't have gone past the Sensui arc.
- Thread starter ScottyFamalam
- Start date
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2023
- Messages
- 502
Comics almost always get streamlined when adapted into live-action feature films; details and plot points get changed or glossed over because not everything from the source material can be carried over to the big screen. The story has to be simplified so that casual watchers will have an easy time following it because there's only so much you can show in an hour-something or two-hour-long movie. The Netflix series here is essentially a feature film that got broken into five episodes, or parts. A second season was never guaranteed, so you have to ask yourself if it's better to only adapt the early parts of the series and hope that a continuation will be green-lit or if it's better to mainly cover the most iconic moments of the series in case there won't be another chance to show them. If you ask me, though, yeah, they should have just adapted the Spirit Detective and Saint Beasts arcs.
The first episode would have Yusuke dying, coming back to life, and becoming a Spirit Detective. The second episode would have him meeting Kurama and fighting Gouki and Hiei. The third episode would have him fighting Rando and being chosen as Genkai's disciple. The fourth and fifth episodes would adapt the Saint Beasts arc; Kurama fights Genbu, Kuwabara fights Byakku, Hiei fights Seiryu and the finale would be Yusuke fighting Suzaku. That's the best way for the Netflix adaptation to go without feeling too cramped or rushed. I get that they wanted to adapt the most iconic moments of the series, but you kind of defeat the purpose of doing that when you're just cramming everything into just five episodes as that doesn't do the source material much justice. Another season would be more likely to get green-lit if the first one is successful. And even if it doesn't come out, as long as the first season is a quality product that adapts the source material faithfully enough, fans and critics will be satisfied.
The showrunners just opened themselves up to a ton of criticism from fans for cramming a bunch of things into five episodes. Whereas if those episodes only focused on the earlier arcs, no one would be criticizing them as long as they're well-made, faithful adaptations of the manga. People would be disappointed if a second season adapting the iconic Dark Tournament never came out, but they wouldn't take issue with the first season itself. Any disappointment over the lack of a follow-up would be a testament to how well-received the first season covering the earlier arcs was, meaning the showrunners would have done a good job. I don't see why there wouldn't be another season if the first one was successful, anyway. This is just yet another example of corporate greed ruining another comic book adaptation.
The first episode would have Yusuke dying, coming back to life, and becoming a Spirit Detective. The second episode would have him meeting Kurama and fighting Gouki and Hiei. The third episode would have him fighting Rando and being chosen as Genkai's disciple. The fourth and fifth episodes would adapt the Saint Beasts arc; Kurama fights Genbu, Kuwabara fights Byakku, Hiei fights Seiryu and the finale would be Yusuke fighting Suzaku. That's the best way for the Netflix adaptation to go without feeling too cramped or rushed. I get that they wanted to adapt the most iconic moments of the series, but you kind of defeat the purpose of doing that when you're just cramming everything into just five episodes as that doesn't do the source material much justice. Another season would be more likely to get green-lit if the first one is successful. And even if it doesn't come out, as long as the first season is a quality product that adapts the source material faithfully enough, fans and critics will be satisfied.
The showrunners just opened themselves up to a ton of criticism from fans for cramming a bunch of things into five episodes. Whereas if those episodes only focused on the earlier arcs, no one would be criticizing them as long as they're well-made, faithful adaptations of the manga. People would be disappointed if a second season adapting the iconic Dark Tournament never came out, but they wouldn't take issue with the first season itself. Any disappointment over the lack of a follow-up would be a testament to how well-received the first season covering the earlier arcs was, meaning the showrunners would have done a good job. I don't see why there wouldn't be another season if the first one was successful, anyway. This is just yet another example of corporate greed ruining another comic book adaptation.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2023
- Messages
- 502
The most direct translation for the title would be "Hidden Journey White Paper".
Hidden means "occult" in this context and "occult" literally means "hidden". So, "Occult Journey White Paper" would be the best translation if you want to get the message across.
Hidden means "occult" in this context and "occult" literally means "hidden". So, "Occult Journey White Paper" would be the best translation if you want to get the message across.
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2015
- Messages
- 10,126
- Age
- 31
Factually Scotty shouldn't have gone past "factually" before closing the browser
Booyaka
This show aged badly, but the outfits aged well
Booyaka
This show aged badly, but the outfits aged well
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2023
- Messages
- 688
Ahh unfortunate.
I heard they skipped Rando and Saint Beasts…I guess they didn’t expect more than 1 season.
- Joined
- May 30, 2015
- Messages
- 31,008
They basically skipped all of DT too and went straight to the Team Toguro fight
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2023
- Messages
- 688
Jesus does that sound rushed….
Sounds like the Yukina arc but with Bui and Karasu included lol
- Joined
- May 30, 2015
- Messages
- 31,008
Pretty much exactly what it is, only the final setting is on hanging neck island like the actual DT arc
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2023
- Messages
- 688
What a fail…
Just re-animate the anime like they did
for HxH and be done with it lol.
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2023
- Messages
- 502
Changed my mind. It's understandable why the Netflix series crammed a bunch of stuff into 5 episodes. A second season was never guaranteed, so it makes sense to just adapt the most iconic moments of the series. And it's not totally unnatural to combine the Yukina Rescue and Dark Tournament arcs; Yusuke fought Toguro in the Yukina Rescue arc, so if you only got one season, it makes sense to combine their first and final fights.
The bigger issue with the series is that it looked stupid; the fighting is too overly choreographed and the characters look silly. Some things don't translate well to live action. But at least it made a lot of money and got decent reviews. It's certainly better than Dragon Ball Evolution, if nothing else.
The bigger issue with the series is that it looked stupid; the fighting is too overly choreographed and the characters look silly. Some things don't translate well to live action. But at least it made a lot of money and got decent reviews. It's certainly better than Dragon Ball Evolution, if nothing else.
