Goku (Super Kamehameha / TB23) vs

SIAD

Elite
Member
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
8,343
Age
34
1.- Goku (Heavy Clothing / BoZ)
2.- Goku (Without Heavy Clothing / BoZ)
3.- Yajirobe (Arc Saiyajin)
4.- Raditz.

  How far can the Super Kamehameha of Goku (TB23) go?

  And how far can the Chōbakuretsumaha from Piccolo (TB23)?
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,964
Doesn't even beat 1. 23rd TB Goku was able to endure Piccolo's Chobakuretsumaha which was stated to be the greatest Ki up to that point (ie. superior to the Super Kamehameha) and yet Goku still withstood it. An even stronger and more durable Goku like his weighted BoZ self won't be taken out by any attack from his 23rd TB self.
 

ahill

Super Elite
Donor
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
15,191
Captain Cadaver said:
Doesn't even beat 1. 23rd TB Goku was able to endure Piccolo's Chobakuretsumaha which was stated to be the greatest Ki up to that point (ie. superior to the Super Kamehameha) and yet Goku still withstood it. An even stronger and more durable Goku like his weighted BoZ self won't be taken out by any attack from his 23rd TB self.
Is weighted Goku (BoZ) > his full power from 5 years ago?
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,964
That's what's implied when Piccolo removed his weighted clothing. Piccolo and Goku were comparable in their weighted levels, Goku had no idea Piccolo was using weighted clothing, he stated Piccolo must've been doing intense training and didn't seem to believe Piccolo was suppressing his Ki (which his 322 reading and Raditz still sensing them as they arrived at the Pod area should make obvious). All this points to BoZ Weighted Piccolo being at least equal to his FP 23rd TB self, whilst his moon bust makes it apparent that he's in fact far above that version of himself (even if not viewing the DB Moon as dense as the real world's, nothing really contradicts the speed of the feat being leagues above any of 23rd TB Piccolo's attacks).
 

Tapion

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2016
Messages
2,417
Age
29
What is this idea about the DBZ Moon?

Toriyama stated the distance between it and our world was the same as in real life, and since it still looks as big as the real life Moon is when you look at the sky, it's the same diameter.Nothing at all suggests it is different in any way, be it density or size. Piccolo is a moon buster and it isn't an outlier. The very next arc was planet busting.
 

GSM123

Super Elite
Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2017
Messages
15,898
Age
24
Tapion said:
What is this idea about the DBZ Moon?

:CC has theorized that the DB Moon might not be as big as our Moon, given how Roshi blowing it up is portrayed as a lesser feat than Piccolo Daimao blowing up a city + The lack of Moon seemingly didn't affect Earth, implying it's gravity (And by consequence, it's mass) isn't as massive as the real moon's.
 

ahill

Super Elite
Donor
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
15,191
Captain Cadaver said:
That's what's implied when Piccolo removed his weighted clothing. Piccolo and Goku were comparable in their weighted levels, Goku had no idea Piccolo was using weighted clothing, he stated Piccolo must've been doing intense training and didn't seem to believe Piccolo was suppressing his Ki (which his 322 reading and Raditz still sensing them as they arrived at the Pod area should make obvious). All this points to BoZ Weighted Piccolo being at least equal to his FP 23rd TB self, whilst his moon bust makes it apparent that he's in fact far above that version of himself (even if not viewing the DB Moon as dense as the real world's, nothing really contradicts the speed of the feat being leagues above any of 23rd TB Piccolo's attacks).
I get your point, but the numbers don't allow us room enough to work with the implications. Having 23rd Budokai Piccolo at less than 322 would be problematic with the implications of how he scales down compared to everyone but Goku and the statement that he has powered up many times compared to his former self.
 

Tapion

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2016
Messages
2,417
Age
29
GreatSaiyaman123 said:
Tapion said:
What is this idea about the DBZ Moon?

:CC has theorized that the DB Moon might not be as big as our Moon, given how Roshi blowing it up is portrayed as a lesser feat than Piccolo Daimao blowing up a city + The lack of Moon seemingly didn't affect Earth, implying it's gravity (And by consequence, it's mass) isn't as massive as the real moon's.

Feat disparity has zero bearing on solid facts. Going by this I can safely disregard literally any feat in the series. Vegeta isn't a planet buster because Recoome only changed the shape of a planet, despite the fact literally every guidebook and alternate source confirms the statement.

Toriyama said the distance between the Moon and the Earth on DBZ is 384,000km, just like in real life. Therefore the precedent is already set for legit parameters for the Moon.

If we're going to nitpick scientific portrayal then the Planet Trade Organization's space pods aren't FTL because going faster than light is impossible, despite the fact that they travel galactic distances within weeks. It doesn't work that way at all, sorry. If I can use a non canon example, Paragus summons a star sized comet to New Vegeta on Movie 8, but that comet's density disparity would be so immense it'd collapse into a black hole, which doesn't happen either.

DBZ's Heaven is also a planet the size of the literal universe. But it doesn't collapse into a multiverse consuming black hole, which is what'd happen in real life.
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,964
ahill1 said:
I get your point, but the numbers don't allow us room enough to work with the implications. Having 23rd Budokai Piccolo at less than 322 would be problematic with the implications of how he scales down compared to everyone but Goku and the statement that he has powered up many times compared to his former self.
1. Gaps and statements for Part 1 don't matter when the numbers given are already inconsistent with 50% Old Daimao >> Roshi. Feats and statements are far more solid evidence than an arbitrary thing like battle power gaps.
2. Even taking into account the gap, BoZ Weighted Piccolo > 23rd TB FP Piccolo works when considering 23rd Weighted Goku should be below 250 given Ten's reading.
 

Tapion

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2016
Messages
2,417
Age
29
If we're talking feats, 23rd Piccolo's ki blasts were fast enough to cross Papaya Island, which is thousands of kilometers wide, in a split second. And post King Piccolo Goku is confirmedly faster than lightning, too. As far as feats go, they are both Massively Hypersonic+. Not massively different from BoZ Piccolo's relativistic, just considerably so.
 

ahill

Super Elite
Donor
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
15,191
There is nothing implying that feats display do scale linearly with battle powers though. Have you guys an idea of how much power is needed to blow the moon in comparison to blowing an island or whatever feat 23rd Budokai Piccolo could accomplish? Piccolo would need to be thousands of times (if not more) stronger to accomplish such. AT is just not trying to fit the battle powers with feats display, and trying to gauge a character's development based on current feats vs earlier feats is folly, as we know Piccolo hasn't gotten that stronger.

Blowing the solar system requires infinitely more energy than bursting a relatively small planet like the Earth... and whilst Cell is way stronger than the first planet burster shown (Vegeta), we know that there isn't an unquantifiable gap between them as per feats that actually matters -- and by that I mean feats of characters fighting other ones, not destruction capabilities.
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,964
Exactly, which is why using battle power gaps as an argument for Weighted Piccolo not being > 23rd TB Piccolo doesn't really work.
 

ahill

Super Elite
Donor
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
15,191
I'm saying that using Piccolo's feat as a way to prove he has gotten astronomically stronger doesn't work. Piccolo isn't thousands of times more powerful than he was at the Budokai.
 

SIAD

Elite
Member
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
8,343
Age
34
The other thing that can be done are 2 listings. I made a list with Scouters numbers and another one with numbers of what I should do on a real scale according to the exploits.

 In the line of Hazañas Unity are the Joules, the human average for each hit is approximately 100 Joules. Then I started to analyze the capabilities of each character.

 Vegeta being a destroyer of Planet Earth has a power of 288,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 Joules approximately. Then Dodoria not being a destroyer of something superior to Planet, has a power of 352,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 Joules.

 Personally I see the feat of Piccolo (BoZ) as an atypical feat, since Nappa launched an attack of approximately 1,563,979,200,000,000,000,000,000 Joules, that attack frightened Krilin and scared Piccolo, so I doubt that even Piccolo (Arc Saiyajin) exceed that level. Then when a destroyer of a superior structure appears, that character inflates his level of fight in that list.
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,964
ahill1 said:
I'm saying that using Piccolo's feat as a way to prove he has gotten astronomically stronger doesn't work. Piccolo isn't thousands of times more powerful than he was at the Budokai.
It doesn't matter about the realism of the gap when it still shows that his speed and power are at least above himself at the 23rd TB and is still a more solid basis for A > B than arbitrary battle power logic being the opposing factor.
 

SIAD

Elite
Member
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
8,343
Age
34
ahill1 said:
I'm saying that using Piccolo's feat as a way to prove he has gotten astronomically stronger doesn't work. Piccolo isn't thousands of times more powerful than he was at the Budokai.

No, since the feat of Piccolo (BoZ) must be an atypical feat, since Nappa launched an attack of approximately 1,563,979,200,000,000,000,000,000 Joules, that attack frightened Krillin and scared Piccolo, therefore I doubt that even Piccolo (Arc Saiyajin) exceeds that level. To destroy the Moon, a much higher energy is needed. Personally I have this:

Piccolo (TB23) = 625,000,000,000,000,000,000 J
Goku (TB23) = 630,000,000,000,000,000,000 J

Piccolo (BoZ) = 1,275,000,000,000,000,000,000 J
Goku (BoZ) = 1,300,000,000,000,000,000,000 J

Vegeta (Arc Saiyajin) = 288,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 J.
 

ahill

Super Elite
Donor
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
15,191
Captain Cadaver said:
ahill1 said:
I'm saying that using Piccolo's feat as a way to prove he has gotten astronomically stronger doesn't work. Piccolo isn't thousands of times more powerful than he was at the Budokai.
It doesn't matter about the realism of the gap when it still shows that his speed and power are at least above himself at the 23rd TB and is still a more solid basis for A > B than arbitrary battle power logic being the opposing factor.
If you are taking such feat at face value, you might as well argue then that Piccolo's blast is faster than light since it reached the moon in seconds (at least according to the anime)... and if Raditz dodged that, his reaction speed is also ftl, being able to avoid an attack potentially more powerful than one that could reach the moon in seconds. Yet we see that everyone is baffled at the thought of Goku traveling 10,000 kms (the distance between the land in which his spaceship landed and Kame's house) in seconds, at a time everyone was already blowing Raditz Arc Piccolo's power out of the water.

So either you take it serious and its entire implications, or admit that such was probably AT being inconsistent with destruction feats much like he's with battle power gaps.
 

Latest profile posts

Fantastische Hure wrote on Very fast Coconut's profile.
Hello hello is this chase?
Very fast Coconut wrote on JefferyWA's profile.
Jeffery are you okay ? Should we contact the police ?
Very fast Coconut wrote on Fantastische Hure's profile.
Why is your name yellow now ?
Top