Hyoga (start the Arc de Hades) vs Shaina (start the Arc de Hades)?

[SIAD]

This would be just as both were about to face in the beginning of the Arch of Hades, if they had fought, who would win?

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Hyoga oneshots as far as manga canon goes. Anime-wise, it's a closer competition due to the filler scene of Hyoga struggling against Silver Saints, though I'd still give Hyoga the win. At this point he doesn't really have much trouble raising his Cosmo to Gold Saint tier either.