Luffy vs Mr. 1

[Fantastische Hure]

In Alabasta.

Who wins?

 

[SSJ2]

Mr 1. Without Hali, Luffy's rubber is going to get sliced and diced.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

I know it's hard to tell but can you actually hurt Mr. 1 without smashing/cutting his iron? Zoro had him on the ropes a few times that way but he couldn't cut him until he could hear the breath of things. Mr. 1 does IIRC say he is as hard as iron, so I would guess nothing'd hurt him unless you get through the iron.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Assuming he made no gains after Alabasta, Daz Bones wins due to his durability. Considering it managed to take an attack from Mihawk intended to injure Luffy, I'd say his durability can only be overcome by non-Haki users through powerful enough cutting attacks or far more blunt force than Luffy can dish out at this point.