Manga Goku-Black vs Super-Saiyan 3 Vegetto (Boo Saga)

[Fantastische Hure]

Goku-Black in his regular state, pre-Zenkai.

Who wins?

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Goku and Vegeta's lower forms have obviously become vastly stronger given Base Goku can fight off someone who can take down 10% SSB Vegeta and someone roughly equal to SS2 Vegeta like SSJ Black wasn't oneshotted by his SSB form. Base Black oneshots.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

Goku and Vegeta's lower forms have obviously become vastly stronger given Base Goku can fight off someone who can take down 10% SSB Vegeta and someone roughly equal to SS2 Vegeta like SSJ Black wasn't oneshotted by his SSB form. Base Black oneshots.

Less than 10% but yeah.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

It's also worth noting that even manga-wise, BoG Vegetto >>> Boo Arc Vegetto. In Goku's image training in the first chapter, it's implied he only needs regular SSJ to take on Pure Boo, making BoG SSJ Goku more or less on the same level as Boo Arc SS3 Galu, and SSG Goku is in a completely different dimension to BoG Vegetto by his own words.

 

[Pyro]

That would make Kid Boo only ~50x stronger than 100% Freeza, assuming he's not much weaker than SSJ Goku (since we didn't see their fight) and Base Goku ~ 100% Freeza.

SSJ3 Goku (Boo): 100
SSJ Goku: 100
Kid Boo: 100
SSJ2 Goku (Boo): 25
SSJ Goku (Boo): 12.5
100% Freeza: 2
Base Goku: 2
Base Goku (Boo): 0.25

Unless Goku got about 8x stronger between Boo and BoG, which isn't hinted at manga-wise, this is mathematically impossible since SSJ3 Goku (Boo) ~ Kid Boo.

 

[SSJ2]

Menga Black will win.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

That would make Kid Boo only ~50x stronger than 100% Freeza, assuming he's not much weaker than SSJ Goku (since we didn't see their fight) and Base Goku ~ 100% Freeza.

Considering in the manga Beerus doesn't bother bringing up Goku surpassing Freeza until after he uses SS2, it's probably best to treat the Freeza > Base Goku statement with little value as to avoid any problems. Assuming Beerus was basing it purely on appearances due to seeing SSJ Goku VS Freeza is probably the best in terms of keeping things consistent.