My Ideas & Personal Perspective On The Boo Saga

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,116
Age
28
Toriyama has recently stated that Majin Boo's himself doesn't know how powerful he is. Goku says that Majin Boo's Chi is like a 'lie', so because of that, he believes Fat Boo is actually greater than himself.

Why is Majin Boo's Chi like a lie? Because he absorbed the Kais and it's proven that they have a weird affect on him. So it's only a reasonable assumption that they would also have a weird effect on his Chi, and make it appear 'like a lie'. So when Boo becomes Pure, then and only then does Goku conform to the idea that he could defeat Majin Boo. Up until that point -Super Boo, Fat Boo, were originally viewed as superior to himself.

As for Gotenks, Goku only made a prediction. Characters are fallible, the author is omniscient. Nothing 'predicted', was ever concluded as fact, literally, nothing. Using characters whom are calling his Chi 'amazing', or 'tremendous', isn't really the building blocks for any sort of foundation for logic -it actually makes zero sense to me.

The Daizenshuu 7 states he was weaker until he leveled up the Super Saiyan states and until he hit the RoSaT -not before, this doesn't contradict anything seen in the Manga either. Herms has also made it clear that Gotenks wasn't sensed from the World Of The Kai's, so the entire basis of him being stronger than Majin Boo, or sensed from the World Of The Kais is best to be taken as a grain of salt -it's never, at any point of the story, confirmed to be true. However, Goku does state -on two separate occasions, that he wanted the younger generation to figure things out 'on way or another'. If Gotenks Pre-ROST was already stronger than Majin Boo then he could just go pummel Boo into oblivion and it would defeat the purpose of Goku's previous statement. So no, Gotenks doesn't have to be stronger by default.

If we move along, we'll notice that Piccolo sent the boys into the RoSaT early, as soon as Super Boo appeared. Why? Well because, this new Majin Boo had a better body for fighting (Like his movie counter-part Janemba), and reached Super Saiyan 3 tier power (like his movie counter-part Janemba). However, the
major difference is that he was able to sense Chi and went immediately to the look-out and put everybody -including Earth's last hope, in danger. They didn't have a few days left to train and Piccolo needed to act on the fly.

It wasn't until Super Boo & Gotenks Ssj3 came outside of the RoSat were they sensed -Gotenks, not beforehand.

Toriyama has stated that the Z-Fighters in Battle of Gods & Dragonball Super were at peak strength in the Majin Boo Saga & could not get any stronger. Therefore this discredits when people try to assume Goku trained in between the Boo Saga & Super/BoG to surpass Gohan &/or Gotenks.

Toriyama has also stated that he re-read the original Japanese Manga. Which is more accurate than the Herms translations -Herms has been uncertain about certain things, so it's almost insulting to think Toriyama
isn't capable of understanding his own language he grew up with.

Yet in Dragonball Super, we have a statement from Vegeta -that doesn't rely on false predictions, that basically says; 'After defeating Majin Boo, Goku became the strongest in the Universe'. This means the only person stronger than Goku beforehand was Majin Boo. Hence why Goku says he needs to 'train and train', just to catch up to him and defeat him during the 10 year break. Vegeta's statement mimics -but is more direct, than the statement about Goku being #1 in the Universe, way back in the Boo Saga. There is a reason the two statements do relate to one another. Because Toriyama re-read the Manga and wanted to make it abundantly clear that Goku was originally intended to be the strongest in the Boo Saga.

There is that original statement & Beerus stating that Goku provided him with the most 'fun', and he never dared mentioned anybody else except Raging Vegeta. 'Fun' is always, synonymous with strength in Dragonball. It stretches way back to Dragonball, Dragonball Z & finally, Dragonball Super.

Toriyama has further stated in another inview that Goku doesn't matter if it's a good guy or bad guy, he wants to be the best and strongest fighter. This means, that even though Gotenks is his half son, or Gohan is his son by blood, he would seek to surpass them, regardless of whether or not they were related. It's also stated that Goku views his family as more like friends, than actual family. I felt the need to post this so people cannot try to counter with the argument; 'Well Goku wouldn't want to fight his family'.

Conclusively, the author -who re-read the original Japanese Manga & wrote several statements in Db Super, versus 'predictions' (like Nostradamus)? Well, I'll have to side with the author on this one. If Goku in Dragonball Super is as powerful as he was in the Boo Saga -as is everyone else, and is stated, on two separate occasions, to be the strongest ... well than, he's just that and always was.

This is essentially how I view the Manga now. I was once a firm believer of Gotenks Ssj Pre > Goku Ssj3 > Fat Boo; however, new material and the author are all stressing just how inaccurate that actually was. It just takes a little research to tie all the loose ends together.

Anyways, this is just my own personal perspective, you do not have to follow it or make fun of it. I'd just like to know what you think of my analysis?

I've put alot of thought into it.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
I think that Gohan > Gotenks > Goku is solid but the backlash from the fans and the lack of appeal of Goku not being top dog made him pretty much forget that ever happened and not look back.

Goku definitely should not be anywhere near Gohan, Goku's face is literally orgasmic watching Gohan power up.
 

Zoom

Low Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2015
Messages
273
Toriyama has also stated that he re-read the original Japanese Manga.

really? What about Frieza's power statement about 1.3 million? FnF is a movie Toriyama was involved from the start of production.
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,116
Age
28
Wonton Soup said:
Toriyama has also stated that he re-read the original Japanese Manga.

really? What about Frieza's power statement about 1.3 million? FnF is a movie Toriyama was involved from the start of production.
That was Frieza's original estimate. He obviously blew way past it in the end. Unless something confirms that he was at 1,300,000 during the ending portion of the movie, it's best taken as a grain of salt.
 

withheldforprivacy

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jun 19, 2015
Messages
8,308
h0kuten said:
Toriyama has recently stated that Majin Boo's himself doesn't know how powerful he is. Goku says that Majin Boo's Chi is like a 'lie', so because of that, he believes Fat Boo is actually greater than himself.

Why is Majin Boo's Chi like a lie? Because he absorbed the Kais and it's proven that they have a weird affect on him. So it's only a reasonable assumption that they would also have a weird effect on his Chi, and make it appear 'like a lie'. So when Boo becomes Pure, then and only then does Goku conform to the idea that he could defeat Majin Boo. Up until that point -Super Boo, Fat Boo, were originally viewed as superior to himself.

As for Gotenks, Goku only made a prediction. Characters are fallible, the author is omniscient. Nothing 'predicted', was ever concluded as fact, literally, nothing. Using characters whom are calling his Chi 'amazing', or 'tremendous', isn't really the building blocks for any sort of foundation for logic -it actually makes zero sense to me.

The Daizenshuu 7 states he was weaker until he leveled up the Super Saiyan states and until he hit the RoSaT -not before, this doesn't contradict anything seen in the Manga either. Herms has also made it clear that Gotenks wasn't sensed from the World Of The Kai's, so the entire basis of him being stronger than Majin Boo, or sensed from the World Of The Kais is best to be taken as a grain of salt -it's never, at any point of the story, confirmed to be true. However, Goku does state -on two separate occasions, that he wanted the younger generation to figure things out 'on way or another'. If Gotenks Pre-ROST was already stronger than Majin Boo then he could just go pummel Boo into oblivion and it would defeat the purpose of Goku's previous statement. So no, Gotenks doesn't have to be stronger by default.

If we move along, we'll notice that Piccolo sent the boys into the RoSaT early, as soon as Super Boo appeared. Why? Well because, this new Majin Boo had a better body for fighting (Like his movie counter-part Janemba), and reached Super Saiyan 3 tier power (like his movie counter-part Janemba). However, the
major difference is that he was able to sense Chi and went immediately to the look-out and put everybody -including Earth's last hope, in danger. They didn't have a few days left to train and Piccolo needed to act on the fly.

It wasn't until Super Boo & Gotenks Ssj3 came outside of the RoSat were they sensed -Gotenks, not beforehand.

Toriyama has stated that the Z-Fighters in Battle of Gods & Dragonball Super were at peak strength in the Majin Boo Saga & could not get any stronger. Therefore this discredits when people try to assume Goku trained in between the Boo Saga & Super/BoG to surpass Gohan &/or Gotenks.

Toriyama has also stated that he re-read the original Japanese Manga. Which is more accurate than the Herms translations -Herms has been uncertain about certain things, so it's almost insulting to think Toriyama
isn't capable of understanding his own language he grew up with.

Yet in Dragonball Super, we have a statement from Vegeta -that doesn't rely on false predictions, that basically says; 'After defeating Majin Boo, Goku became the strongest in the Universe'. This means the only person stronger than Goku beforehand was Majin Boo. Hence why Goku says he needs to 'train and train', just to catch up to him and defeat him during the 10 year break. Vegeta's statement mimics -but is more direct, than the statement about Goku being #1 in the Universe, way back in the Boo Saga. There is a reason the two statements do relate to one another. Because Toriyama re-read the Manga and wanted to make it abundantly clear that Goku was originally intended to be the strongest in the Boo Saga.

There is that original statement & Beerus stating that Goku provided him with the most 'fun', and he never dared mentioned anybody else except Raging Vegeta. 'Fun' is always, synonymous with strength in Dragonball. It stretches way back to Dragonball, Dragonball Z & finally, Dragonball Super.

Toriyama has further stated in another inview that Goku doesn't matter if it's a good guy or bad guy, he wants to be the best and strongest fighter. This means, that even though Gotenks is his half son, or Gohan is his son by blood, he would seek to surpass them, regardless of whether or not they were related. It's also stated that Goku views his family as more like friends, than actual family. I felt the need to post this so people cannot try to counter with the argument; 'Well Goku wouldn't want to fight his family'.

Conclusively, the author -who re-read the original Japanese Manga & wrote several statements in Db Super, versus 'predictions' (like Nostradamus)? Well, I'll have to side with the author on this one. If Goku in Dragonball Super is as powerful as he was in the Boo Saga -as is everyone else, and is stated, on two separate occasions, to be the strongest ... well than, he's just that and always was.

This is essentially how I view the Manga now. I was once a firm believer of Gotenks Ssj Pre > Goku Ssj3 > Fat Boo; however, new material and the author are all stressing just how inaccurate that actually was. It just takes a little research to tie all the loose ends together.

Anyways, this is just my own personal perspective, you do not have to follow it or make fun of it. I'd just like to know what you think of my analysis?

I've put alot of thought into it.
Explain...
-Piccolo's statement (when Goten first sees Super Buu): ''Everything about him is greater than before''.
-Piccolo's statement about Base Gotenks in spirit room.
-AT's statement that Gohan is the strongest unfused character.
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,116
Age
28
-Everything is definitely greater than before. Super Boo can still be 'greater' but weaker than Goku Ssj3 & Gotenks Ssj3.
-Piccolo was over-estimating Gotenks based on how perfectly they performed they performed the fusion. Further-more, he was in a dire situation and still believed you couldn't turn Ssj after fusing. He believed Gotenks Base is the best they had.
-AT never states Gohan is the strongest un-fused character.

P.S.
Another point that further proves my theories is that Goku wanted to fuse with Gohan or Vegeta because he still believed Fat Boo was stronger than him -due to his Chi becoming a lie and being under the influence the Kaioshins.

It isn't until he becomes Pure does Goku acknowledge his superiority -and not before.
 

withheldforprivacy

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jun 19, 2015
Messages
8,308
h0kuten said:
-Everything is definitely greater than before. Super Boo can still be 'greater' but weaker than Goku Ssj3 & Gotenks Ssj3.
-Piccolo was over-estimating Gotenks based on how perfectly they performed they performed the fusion. Further-more, he was in a dire situation and still believed you couldn't turn Ssj after fusing. He believed Gotenks Base is the best they had.
-AT never states Gohan is the strongest un-fused character.

P.S.
Another point that further proves my theories is that Goku wanted to fuse with Gohan or Vegeta because he still believed Fat Boo was stronger than him -due to his Chi becoming a lie and being under the influence the Kaioshins.

It isn't until he becomes Pure does Goku acknowledge his superiority -and not before.
1. Before spirit room: Piccolo says SSJ Gotenks will lose
After spirit room: Piccolo says Base Gotenks has a chance

2. AT says Gohan is the strongest unfused character in an old interview
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,116
Age
28
1- Boo's Chi is still a lie up until this point, he is being influenced from the Kaioshins. I don't see how Piccolo or anyone -which is probably why nobody directly states Fat Boo or Super Boo is 'so and so strong', could accurately dictate whether or not Gotenks would either defeat Fat Boo or Super Boo. The best conclusion is that Gotenks really was still weaker than Boo the entire time -hence why nobody said he wasn't, and had to enter the RoSaT to train quickly. Because Super Boo can now sense Chi -and grew stronger.

2- Herms debunks it http://www.kanzenshuu.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=22680
 

withheldforprivacy

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jun 19, 2015
Messages
8,308
1. Still, it shows he believed Base Gotenks post>SSJ Gotenks pre, since those two were not ''like a lie'' and
Piccolo felt Base post as greater than SSJ pre.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
Base > SSJ is retarded and doesn't work. It should be thrown out.
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,116
Age
28
withheldforprivacy said:
1. Still, it shows he believed Base Gotenks post>SSJ Gotenks pre, since those two were not ''like a lie'' and
Piccolo felt Base post as greater than SSJ pre.
Actually, I over-looked my power levels and do have Gotenks Base Post > Gotenks Ssj Pre. But I also use lower multipliers. Goku Ssj3 is still stronger than Gotenks Ssj3 Post who in turn is stronger than Super Boo.

Further-more, I am going to do some more thinking and decide what to make of the Base Post > Ssj Pre thing, but at the moment, that's what I am currently following.

I also had another theory. That the more 'perfect' the fusion dance is performed, the
better the sum. Meaning the kids don't have to get 'that' much stronger for a stronger fusion result, they just need to perfect the technique. Piccolo notices that the dance was performed perfectly and comments on this. Which could possibly be the reason he reacted the way he did. Gotenks Base-Post never even powered up or attacked when he stated what he did. So it's a long shot for the quote to actually be true.

Once Gotenks Base-Post does attack, Piccolo contradicts his statement.
 

Six Trails

Elite
Legend
Admin
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
9,203
SS Gotenks pre has no change against Evil Boo, while Base Gotenks post does. How can one argue for the former's superiority? It's simple A > B logic. Arguing against it because of numbers is ridiculous.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
Why? The author has no idea how the boosts work clearly. He doesn't realize how it is a numerical impossibility therefore it renders it invalid.
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,116
Age
28
Mike said:
SS Gotenks pre has no change against Evil Boo, while Base Gotenks post does. How can one argue for the former's superiority? It's simple A > B logic. Arguing against it because of numbers is ridiculous.
I explained why above, and pretty clearly.
 

Six Trails

Elite
Legend
Admin
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
9,203
p123 said:
Why? The author has no idea how the boosts work clearly. He doesn't realize how it is a numerical impossibility therefore it renders it invalid.
That's completely arbitrary. It's only a numerical impossibility because you're making it one.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
No it's a numerical impossibility because it is. Why don't you show me how to exhaust all the options since you want to act like you know what the fuck you are talking about. Show me numerically how Mike.
 

Six Trails

Elite
Legend
Admin
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
9,203
That's your argument? "It's a numerical impossibility because I say so."? That's supposed to be a valid reason to ignore statements?

If anyone has to show anyone anything, why don't you show me what makes it a numerical impossibility? Back up your claim.
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,116
Age
28
P123 claims to be a 'legendary debater', but I'm fairly confident I could walk circles around him.

Anyways, he's fairly biased and isn't open to alternative ideas.
 

Fantastische Hure

Zeta Elite
25k
Joined
Jun 1, 2015
Messages
30,769
Age
29
"numerical impossibility" (wtvr that is) doesn't exist in dragonball

u are as strong as the plot needs u to be
 

Lightsworn

Low Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
376
I don't think Toriyama wrote the manga for us to get out calculators and check for "numeric possibilities" for Base Gotenks...or anyone really..

I'd say the gag argument is better. That the intention of the scene was for laughs. Or Gotenks in general is for laughs.
 

Latest profile posts

LlfudXi.gif
Trump is the rightful democratically elected president of Brazil :trump
Top