Spiderman (Maguire) vs Spiderman (Garfield)

[GSM123]

Who wins? Win by KO, both in character.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Garfield Spidey stomps. Scaling from Electro's feats place him at Multi-City Block level, whereas Maguire Spiderman's best feats (stopping a train and hurting the New Goblin more than his own Pumpkin Bombs did) are just Small Building level.

 

[Darker]

Maguire is stronger and tougher. Garfield only has speed on his side.

 

[Nèro]

Maguire would win because of how overrated he is.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

Tobey Maguire would cry again mid-battle, earning Andrew Garfield's sympathy and thus Garfield gives-up so Tobey can feel good again.

 

[Symbiote]

Maguire's too much of a pussy.

 

[VampireWicked]

Spiderman (Garfield) is more agile.
Spiderman (Maguire) is slower.

I say Spiderman (Garfield)