ToP Hit vs ToP SSJ-Blue Vegeta

Goku9001

Mid Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2016
Messages
878
Age
26
@Natasha Romanoff

It's not my job to prove Jiren was using full effort. You are the one who made the claim that Jiren was holding back in effort. It's up to you prove it. I already addressed that Vegeta's statement of "You were fighting harder against Kakarot!" was made to provoke Jiren. That coincides with Whis' statement where he clearly stated that Vegeta was trying to achieve Ultra Instinct in the same vein as Goku did. By clashing with powerful energy, he would also break his limits just as Goku did.

What we do know is that Vegeta claimed that Jiren's current energy was the strongest that he had encountered.

Episode: 122
Time: 9:45-9:50
Context: Blue Vegeta interrupts Goku and begins to battle Jiren.
Vegeta: "I've never encountered an energy as strong and heavy as this."

Vegeta's fists were pounding against Jiren's body as he made this claim. His claim clearly refers to Jiren's energy in its current state. Vegeta never encountered Jiren's full power. No one ever calls Jiren's power into question as Vegeta watches him drive him back. In fact, everyone believed Vegeta had countered him when he successfully evaded Jiren's fastest attack similar to UI Omen Goku. During Episode 109, Vegeta had an outside perspective of the situation. Kaioken x20 Blue Goku saw the attack coming in plain sight yet Goku and Vegeta didn't have the speed to react to it. This isn't the case of Frieza/Hit vs. Dyspo. Dyspo's attack was described as linear and predictable. Evading Jiren's attack was directly compared to Ultra Instinct.

Jiren never suppressed his effort against Hit. This is another convenient assumption you are making. This is what we are told.

Episode: 111
Time: 5:21-5:30
Context: Hit begins to battle Jiren and feels the weight of his blows.
Hit: "So these are...the attacks from Jiren that Son Goku took. Now that I've felt them. They are heavy indeed."

There was no suppression here. Android 17 is a defensive player which means he can withstand blows far beyond his paygrade. In fact, the blow directed at Blue Evolved Vegeta was one that Android 17 took directly. He still recovered from it but the narrative made it clear that he was out of submission for a notable period of time.

The only questionable thing here would be Android 17 trading blows for a while but this is an anime trend in general. There is no narrative significance behind Android 17's feats and he's immediately forced on the defensive. Vegeta's feats hold narrative weight, are consistent, and are constantly being emphasized. There is no comparison. Aside from that, Jiren "suppressing" himself in one instance doesn't prove he suppressed himself in other instances. It would be the equivalent of claiming that since a person has been wrong before, he must be wrong in other instances where his intelligence is called into question. That's not a fair argument to be making.

Here is what we do know. Jiren uses a higher power against Vegeta than he does against Hit. You believe Jiren was sandbagging against both of them. However, it takes Hit far longer to land a blow on Jiren than Vegeta does. On top of that, Hit never had to deal with Jiren's fastest attack. Jiren's standard attacks were enough to deal with Hit's Time Skip. In contrast, Vegeta evaded Jiren's fastest attack which was compared to Ultra Instinct. The only thing I'm doing here is establishing a lower bound for Vegeta's improvement and he's at least above Kaioken x20 Blue Goku (109) by a wide margin.
 

Natasha Romanoff

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2022
Messages
1,452
@Natasha Romanoff

It's not my job to prove Jiren was using full effort. You are the one who made the claim that Jiren was holding back in effort. It's up to you prove it. I already addressed that Vegeta's statement of "You were fighting harder against Kakarot!" was made to provoke Jiren. That coincides with Whis' statement where he clearly stated that Vegeta was trying to achieve Ultra Instinct in the same vein as Goku did. By clashing with powerful energy, he would also break his limits just as Goku did.
Ok. If this is an statement coming from someone that wants to provoke him, why didn't he mock him or use sarcastic comments with an smile (something which is particular in Vegeta's case specially when he is in advantage)? That route would lead us to believe that Vegeta somehow became off-character for one split second which doesn't make sense, but the comment understands it for Vegeta wanting to fight Jiren with the same amount of power he was using with Goku and him recriminating him that.
What we do know is that Vegeta claimed that Jiren's current energy was the strongest that he had encountered.

Vegeta's fists were pounding against Jiren's body as he made this claim. His claim clearly refers to Jiren's energy in its current state. Vegeta never encountered Jiren's full power. No one ever calls Jiren's power into question as Vegeta watches him drive him back. In fact, everyone believed Vegeta had countered him when he successfully evaded Jiren's fastest attack similar to UI Omen Goku. During Episode 109, Vegeta had an outside perspective of the situation. Kaioken x20 Blue Goku saw the attack coming in plain sight yet Goku and Vegeta didn't have the speed to react to it. This isn't the case of Frieza/Hit vs. Dyspo. Dyspo's attack was described as linear and predictable. Evading Jiren's attack was directly compared to Ultra Instinct.
Okay, I have never ever disagreed with this I actually make you the correction that characters can't sense anyone hidden power when I used Vegeta stating Jiren not using his full strength even after he take him down on the floor.

Suppressed Jiren is stronger than everything Vegeta faced, so?

Nobody also called Majin Buu's power into question, yet most in the crowd believed Vegeta had a chance against him, even though, Majin Buu (as well as Jiren) was toying with him all the time. Everyone as well believed that the Final Flash would defeat Jiren, yet it failed, this is the typical skeptism the writers script and characters tend to act like that, this happen a lot in fiction, if there's something that actually add to the current situation it'd be a good point to be made, but in this case it is not.

Evolved Blue Vegeta was compared in method to Ultra Instinct of "broking his shell", so, where does this even lead us?
Jiren never suppressed his effort against Hit. This is another convenient assumption you are making. This is what we are told.
I have to say that at least I keep some skeptism to Hit's statement, in DBZ, Vegeta compared Kid Buu's impacts with what he used on Goku, even though, Kid Buu used more effort on Goku and Buu. The reason I think that in this case is a 50/50 is due to Jiren stating that all the strong fighters have gone letting Toppo and Dyspo to take out the rest which he considered garbage.
There was no suppression here. Android 17 is a defensive player which means he can withstand blows far beyond his paygrade. In fact, the blow directed at Blue Evolved Vegeta was one that Android 17 took directly. He still recovered from it but the narrative made it clear that he was out of submission for a notable period of time.
Being a defensive player doesn't work too much on here, when you consider that 17 also could stand up even after the impact from Jiren impacted the three fighters, also, when you consider that he re-appeared after the fight of Vegeta and God Toppo having finished, even though, before Jiren threw a blast towards him and Freeza.
The only questionable thing here would be Android 17 trading blows for a while but this is an anime trend in general. There is no narrative significance behind Android 17's feats and he's immediately forced on the defensive. Vegeta's feats hold narrative weight, are consistent, and are constantly being emphasized. There is no comparison. Aside from that, Jiren "suppressing" himself in one instance doesn't prove he suppressed himself in other instances. It would be the equivalent of claiming that since a person has been wrong before, he must be wrong in other instances where his intelligence is called into question. That's not a fair argument to be making.
Except that 17 is fighting the far stronger Jiren and that 17 actually gave Goku a idea to defeat Jiren, or at least to create a plan to take him down, so it has narrative significance. You trying to cover the sun with a finger doesn't make it any less valid.

When we consider the big image of what the story tell us (when it comes to Jiren) then it does. If far weaker characters can outmatch those characters than what he can do or that he showed far better feats in one instance to other, we can tell those are just low passes. In same instance, making a PS and justify it with low passes ain't also a good route to be taken.
Here is what we do know. Jiren uses a higher power against Vegeta than he does against Hit. You believe Jiren was sandbagging against both of them. However, it takes Hit far longer to land a blow on Jiren than Vegeta does. On top of that, Hit never had to deal with Jiren's fastest attack. Jiren's standard attacks were enough to deal with Hit's Time Skip. In contrast, Vegeta evaded Jiren's fastest attack which was compared to Ultra Instinct. The only thing I'm doing here is establishing a lower bound for Vegeta's improvement and he's at least above Kaioken x20 Blue Goku (109) by a wide margin.
How we can know this?

If we cherrypick feats randomly: Jiren used his glare on Hit and even after he eliminated him was conscious, Vegeta got in the floor when Jiren actually tried. Plus, in one instance, Jiren view Vegeta as a few thing and Hit even before he analyzed him and decided to dispatch him by himself, why didn't he do the same with Vegeta?

At the very best what we can get from this is is an inconclusive analogy based on incomplete evidence that only lead us to use personal stats make for two characters which are solely deductions from someone and nothing more.
 
Top