Giran [Piccolo Daimao arc, Anime] vs Karin Tower Goku

[Animelover5487]

Giran stomps by my point of view. Giran did much better against Tambourine than Krillin surviving tons of kicks and attacks from Tambourine and even landed a hit of his own that made Tambourine mildly frustrated to the point of using a ki amplified strike to finally kill him off that's a lot more than what Krillin can say, who was killed by Tambourine simply stepping on his head.

 

[Papasmurf]

Kuririn's fight with Tambourine was off-screen in the manga. All we know is that Kuririn fought him and died. Although for what it's worth, Tambourine wasn't entirely sure he killed Kuririn off until Goku informed him of it.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Manga-wise, the only thing to suggest Giran is on par with Post-Karin Goku is Tambourine killing Kuririn without meaning to, whilst Giran at least managed to take a kick from him. Since we can't really judge something that wasn't shown, we can't use this as comparison though, plus, I doubt Toriyama intended for Giran to have made such gains.

Giran only wins here if it's his anime incarnation.

 

[Animelover5487]

Manga-wise, the only thing to suggest Giran is on par with Post-Karin Goku is Tambourine killing Kuririn without meaning to, whilst Giran at least managed to take a kick from him. Since we can't really judge something that wasn't shown, we can't use this as comparison though, plus, I doubt Toriyama intended for Giran to have made such gains.

Giran only wins here if it's his anime incarnation.

It is Anime as it says in the title.