Isn’t Sanji a hypocrite?

[Fantastische Hure]

He demands Jinbe to die for Arlong, even-though he had his reasons & marines were much more complicit, but was fine with saving his family who were million-times worse than Arlong.

Hypocricy

 

[SSJ2]

He cares more about Nami than the random people who've been affected by his family.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

He cares more about Nami than the random people who've been affected by his family.

He’s the worst among the crew in-terms of compassion. Double-standards & all, yet he’s written to be the kindest l0l.

 

[Future Warrior]

I think he may have just been speaking impulsively to Jinbe.

I think I also recall Sanji saying he wouldn’t care to leave the Vinsmokes to their deaths earlier in WCI.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

Impulsively or not he was still out-of-line I think. Even Nami was less angry than him.

Yet he still saved all of them. At-least show a panel or some-thing (maybe there was) with the same panel & then Sanji saying some-thing like “now I understand”.

 

[Future Warrior]

Either way I think Oda shouldn’t have made Sanji say that to Jinbe. It wasn’t his place to intrude himself into that conversation with such tactlessness.

 

[Warmmedown]

He's a proponent of care ethics, like Nel Noddings (care ethics - I was reading about it recently and have a lot of issues with it...how does care ethics not lead to nepotism, which damages institutions and actually cause harm so is less caring towards all of society? Can't it be used to justify racist or other discriminatory policies - I care for a race more, therefore I treat them better? And how does care ethics not become deontological/duty ethics (considering it considers itself non-deontological? A duty to those you have a stable, caring personal relationship with. And how does it account for empathy fatigue or similar reductions in empathy - does the lack of caring feeling become a valid moral reason to not give care?)

 

[Warmmedown]

But yeh maybe he's a hypocrite. Is he saying one thing and doing another though? Is he? How so?

I guess Jinbei he blamed for raising Arlong into a pirate and not stopping Arlong from going to East Blue. He blames Judge for turning his siblings into killers.

Also didn't he forgive Jinbei eventually, once he knew he was regretful about Arlong?

Inb4 "ur guessing from like three youtube clips"

 

[Fantastische Hure]

Arlong & Jinbei were like brothers & Arlong was a pirate before Jinbei ever became one I think.