- Joined
- Sep 4, 2015
- Messages
- 14,407
So many agree that the Cell arc is the one in which more plot holes, immersion breaks decisions and asspulls began to appear and damage the work's quality overall.
I'd like to speak about the main problem, most damaging one to me: characters writing.
We have two main examples within the characters writing that sticks out in the Cell arc: Vegeta and Gohan. Both act different to a point they were used to movement the plot.
For one side, Vegeta isn't the pragmatic warrior he once was... Not wanting to take chances and taking the less problematic route possible. In the Freeza's arc, we have seen this Vegeta in action, wanting Kuririn to wound him before Freeza could enact his final act, for instance. In the Cell arc, he throws this cautious into the wind... Wanting to battle the androids and wanting nothing of destroying the lab, also allowing Cell to become perfect instead of killing Semi Cell. If you think about it, the latest sequence of the Cell arc occurred only due to Vegeta. That's ridiculous.
As for Gohan, we've seen how prepared to combat the enemy he was in earlier instances, as examples him killing one of Freeza's henchmedn upon their arrival on Namek, wanting to train to protect the Earth from Vegeta and actively trying to kill Freeze (more notably, when firing a Masenko at him). Suddenly not wanting to kill Cell and wishing to talk their way out of it came outta nowhere. You could argue he became more pacifist during this time, but this should be subteily shown somehow or another. This pacifista mentality was sudden and didn't link with Gohan's former behavior.
There're other problems as well, of course (like the Android's retconment, vagueness and contradictions towards character's standing and power), but I believe these are the most glarring ones, in a sense they actively are used to move the plot.
I'd like to speak about the main problem, most damaging one to me: characters writing.
We have two main examples within the characters writing that sticks out in the Cell arc: Vegeta and Gohan. Both act different to a point they were used to movement the plot.
For one side, Vegeta isn't the pragmatic warrior he once was... Not wanting to take chances and taking the less problematic route possible. In the Freeza's arc, we have seen this Vegeta in action, wanting Kuririn to wound him before Freeza could enact his final act, for instance. In the Cell arc, he throws this cautious into the wind... Wanting to battle the androids and wanting nothing of destroying the lab, also allowing Cell to become perfect instead of killing Semi Cell. If you think about it, the latest sequence of the Cell arc occurred only due to Vegeta. That's ridiculous.
As for Gohan, we've seen how prepared to combat the enemy he was in earlier instances, as examples him killing one of Freeza's henchmedn upon their arrival on Namek, wanting to train to protect the Earth from Vegeta and actively trying to kill Freeze (more notably, when firing a Masenko at him). Suddenly not wanting to kill Cell and wishing to talk their way out of it came outta nowhere. You could argue he became more pacifist during this time, but this should be subteily shown somehow or another. This pacifista mentality was sudden and didn't link with Gohan's former behavior.
There're other problems as well, of course (like the Android's retconment, vagueness and contradictions towards character's standing and power), but I believe these are the most glarring ones, in a sense they actively are used to move the plot.