Rate The Manga Arcs

[Alex Boss]

Dragonball

Pilaf arc: 3/10
Budokai arc: 4/10
RRA arc: 4.5/10
Baba arc: 2/10
Tenshinhan arc: 7/10
Piccolo daimao arc: 7/10
Piccolo junior : 6.5/10

Saiyan arc: 6/10
Namek arc: 6/10
Frieza arc: 7.5/10
Android arc: 5.5/10
Cell arc: 6/10
World tournament arc: 2/10
Babidi arc: 3/10
Boo arc: 2.5/10


One Piece

Romance Dawn arc: 4.5/10
Syrup village arc: 5/10
Baratie arc: 6.5/10
Arlong arc: 7/10
Loguetown arc: 6/10

Reverse mountain arc: 4/10
Whiskey peak arc: 6/10
Little garden arc: 5/10
Drum island arc: 6/10
Alabasta arc: 7.5/10

Jaya arc: 7/10
Skypea arc: 8/10

Long ring long arc: 1/10
Water 7 arc: 8.5/10
Ennies Lobby arc: 9/10

Thriller Bark arc: 6.5/10

Sabaody arc: 9/10
Amazon lily arc: 6/10
Impel Down arc: 8/10
Marineford arc: 9/10

Fishman island arc: 3/10
Punk Hazard arc: 4/10
Dressrosa arc: 5.5/10

Naruto

Land of Waves: 6/10
Chuunin exams: 8.5/10
Invasion of konoha: 7/10
Search for tsunade: 6/10
Sasuke retrieval:7/10
Kazekage rescue: 3.5/10
Sasuke and sai: 3/10
Hidan and kakuzu: 5.5/10
Itachi pursuit: 7.5/10
Pain arc: 8/10
Kage summit: 4.5/10
4th shinobi: 4/10
Kaguya: 0.9/10 (bad mood) 1/10 (good mood)

Hunter X Hunter

Hunter exam: 6/10
Heavens arena: 6/10
Yorknew: 8/10
Greed island: 3/10
Chimera: 8.5/10
Election: 5.5/10

Fullmetal

East city: 8.5/10
Central city: 9/10
Briggs: 8/10
Promised day: 8.5/10

Death Note

L: 8.5/10
No: 3.5/10

Berserk:
Black swordsman arc: 7/10

 

[Yoshi]

Edited my list.

 

[Yoshi]

I revamped my ratings.

 

[Kyo]

Dragon Ball
Pilaf: 4.5/10
21st Budokai: 5/10
RRA: 3/10
22nd Budokai: 5.5/10
Piccolo Daimao: 6/10
23rd Budokai: 4/10
Saiyan: 5/10
Freeza: 6/10
Cell: 3/10
Boo: 1/10

Naruto
Land of Waves: 5.5/10
Chunin Exams/Konoha Invasion: 6/10
Tsunade: 4/10
Sasuke Retrieval: 3/10
Kazekage Resuce: 3/10
Sai Arc: 2/10
Hidan/Kakuzu: 3/10
Itachi Pursuit: 2/10
Pain Arc: 3/10
Five Kage Summit: 1/10
Fourth Shinobi World War: 2/10
Jubi Revival: 1/10

Bleach
Substitute Shinigami: 5/10
Soul Society: 6/10
Arrancar: 2/10
Hueco Mundo: 1/10
Fake Karakura Town: 1/10
Fullbring: 0/10
Thousand Year Blood War: 0/10

Yu Yu Hakusho
Spirit Detective: 5/10
Dark Tournament: 6/10
Chapter Black: 6/10
Three Kings: 2/10

Hunter x Hunter
Hunter Exam: 7/10
Heavens Arena: 6/10
Yorknew City: 8/10
Greed Island: 6/10
Chimera Ant: 7.5/10
Election: 5/10

One Piece
Romance Dawn through Baratie: 5/10
Arlong Park: 7/10
Loguetown: 6/10
Alabasta Saga: 7.5/10
Sky Island Saga: 6.5/10
Water 7/Enies Lobby: 8/10
Thriller Bark Saga: 4.5/10
Sabaody Archipelago: 8/10
Amazon Lily: 6/10
Impel Down/Marineford: 7.5/10
Fishman Island: 3/10
Punk Hazard: 4/10
Dressrosa: 6/10

Fullmetal Alchemist
East City: 8/10
Central City: 8/10
Briggs: 6/10
Promised Day: 7/10

Berserk
Black Swordsman Arc: 5/10
Golden Age Arc: 10/10
Elf Arc: 5/10
Tower Arc: 7/10
Kushan War Arc: 4/10
Fantasia Arc: 2/10

Slam Dunk
In Training Arc: 5/10
Practice Matches Arc: 5/10
National Preliminaries Arc - 6/10
National Championships Arc - 6/10

Rurouni Kenshin
Tokyo Arc: 5/10
Kyoto Arc: 6/10
Jinchu Arc: 6/10
Epilogue: 5/10

 

[Jeff Styles]

Dragon Ball

Son Goku Arc: 8/10
21st Budokai Arc: 6.5/10
red ribbion army Arc: 7/10
22nd Budokai Arc: 8/10
Piccolo Daimao Arc: 6/10
23rd Budokai Arc: 7/10
Saiyan Arc: 5.5/10
Freeza Arc: 7/10
Android Arc: 5/10
Boo Saga: 4/10


Naruto

Part I:
Land Of Waves: 5/10
Chuunin Exams: 6/10
Tsunade: 4/10
Sasuke: 5.5/10


Part II:
Gaara: 4.5/10
Itachi: 7/10
Pain: 5/10
Five Kage Summit: 3.5/10
Shinobi War: 5/10
Juubi Revival: 6/10
Infinite Tsukiyomi: 4/10


Only got to the first 3 Arcs of Bleach.

Bleach: 1/10

Shinigami: 5/10
Soul Society: 7/10
Arrancar: 3/10


Only got to the 4 Arcs of One Piece.

One Piece
Romance Dawn through Baratie: 6/10
Arlong Park: 7/10
Loguetown: 6/10
Alabasta: 5/10

 

[Cal]

Hunter x Hunter

Hunter Exam: 6/10
Heavens Arena: 7/10
Yorknew City: 7.5/10
Greed Island: 8.5/10
Chimera Ant: 8/10
Election: 7.5/10

Only ranking my favorite one.

Although Rurouni Kenshin is almost as good.

 

[withheldforprivacy]

Dragonball
-Pilaf: 7/10 (could stand itself as a fairytale for adults)
-21st TB: 8/10 (enjoyable gags and fights)
-Red Ribbon: 8/10 (same as 21st TB)
-22nd TB: 8/10 (same as RR and 21st TB)
-King Piccolo: 9/10 (great drama)
-23rd TB: 7/10 (great fights, but it didn't give me the feeling of the world being in danger from Piccolo;
also, i didn't like the idea of Goku fighting shoeless)
-Saiyans: 9/10 (great drama)
-Freeza: 9/10 (great fights and drama, but unnecessarily high PL numbers)
-Androids: 10/10 (awesome handling of time travel theory)
-25th TB: 3/10 (turning the story into a high school comedy was an awful idea)
-Buu: 9/10 (great gags and fights; also, it gave us tons of material to discuss for 20 years until the new
movies/series came out)
-Ubb: 6/10 (still, i can't see the point of that last chapter)

Yugioh
-Original: 10/10 (every single short story was exceptional)
-Duelist Kingdom: 9/10 (messy rules, but has emotional value to me)
-Dungeon Dice Monsters: 8/10 (great game, but the story of Duke's father was a little freaky)
-Battle City: 10/10 (more understandable rules than Duelist Kingdom and a great villain story (Marik))
-Millenium World: 9/10 (if the editors hadn't pushed Kazuki to finish it early, it'd be a 10/10)
-Ceremonial Battle: 8/10 (some rules inaccuracy and misplay)

 

[Tapion]

Dragon Ball:
Pilaf 6/10
21st TB 8/10
Red Ribbon 9/10
22nd TB 9/10
King Piccolo 10/10
23rd TB 7/10
Saiyan Saga 9/10
Freeza Saga 8/10
Cell Saga 10/10
Buu 8/10 because Gotenks, otherwise 6/10

Death Note:
-Beginning - 8/10
-13 Agents - 9.25/10
-Second Death Note - 8.5/10
- Mello and Near - 9/10
- Ending - 10/10

Code Geass:
-R1 - 9/10
-R2 - 10/10

Pokemon:
-Indigo Arc 9/10
-Orange Islands Arc - 7.5/10
-Johto Arc - 8.5/10
-Hoenn Arc - 9/10
- Battle Frontier Arc - 8.5/10
-Sinnoh Arc - 8/10
- Unova Arc - 7.5/10
- Kalos Arc - 8/10

etc.

 

[Papasmurf]

Dragon Ball

Son Goku Arc - 4/10
21st Budokai Arc - 4/10
Red Ribbon Arc - 2/10
22nd Budokai Arc - 5/10
Piccolo Daimao Arc - 5/10
23rd Budokai Arc - 4/10
Saiyan Arc - 5.5/10
Freeza Arc - 6.5/10
Cell Arc - 3.5/10
Boo Arc - 1.5/10
Spopovitch Mini-arc - 10,000,000/10
GT- 1/10
BoG - 3/10 movie, 2/10 animu
RoF - less than dog shit
U6 - 2/10
Zamasu - 3/10


One Piece

East Blue Saga - 4/10
Alabasta Saga - 7/10
Skypiea Saga - 3/10
CP9 Saga - 7.5/10
Whitebeard War Saga - 6/10
Fishman Island/Punk Hazard Sagas - 2/10
Dressrosa Saga - 3/10



Naruto

Land Of Waves Arc - 3/10
Chuunin Exams Arc - 4/10
Tsunade Arc - 3/10
Sasuke Retrieval Arc - 2/10
Kazekage Rescue Arc - 2/10
Sai Arc - 1.5/10
Hidan/Kakuzu Arc - 1.5/10
Itachi Pursuit Arc - 1.5/10
Pain Arc - 2.5/10
Five Kage Summit Arc - 1.5/10
Fourth Shinobi World War Arc - 1.5/10
Juubi Revival Arc (and everything afterwards) - -1/10

Bleach

Substitute Shinigami Arc - 3/10
Soul Society Arc - 3.5/10
Arrancar Arc - 1/10
Hueco Mundo Arc - 0/10
Fake Karakura Town Arc - 0/10
Fullbring Arc - -3/10
Thousand Year Blood War Arc - -5/10





Berserk

Black Swordsman Arc - 5.5/10
Golden Age Arc - 10/10
Elf Arc - 5/10
Tower Arc - 7.5/10
Kushan War Arc - 3.5/10
Fantasia Arc - 1.5/10

Hunter X Hunter

Hunter Exams Arc - 2.5/10
Zoldyck Family Arc - 1/10
Heavens Arena Arc - 2.5/10
Yorknew City Arc - 6.5/10
Greed Island Arc- 4/10
Chimera Ant Arc - 6/10 (anime version so dragged out lul)
Chairman Election Arc - 2/10

Yu Yu Hakusho

Spirit Detective Arc - 4/10
Dark Tournament Arc - 5/10
Chapter Black Arc - 5/10
Three Kings Arc - 1/10

Slam Dunk

In Training Arc - 5/10
Practice Matches Arc - 5/10
National Preliminaries Arc - 7/10
National Championships Arc - 8/10

Fullmetal Alchemist

East City Arc - 4/10
Central City Arc - 7/10
Briggs Arc - 5/10
Promised Day - 6/10

Hokuto no Ken

Initial Events - 4/10
Rei Arc - 5/10
Souther/Ryuga Arcs - 4/10
Last Nanto General Arc - 6/10
Tentei Arc - 3/10
Shura Arc - 2/10
Post-Shura - crap/10


JoJo's Bizarre Adventure

Phantom Blood - 4.5/10
Battle Tendency - 6/10
Stardust Crusaders - 4/10
Diamond is Unbreakable - 7/10
Vento Aurero - 3.5/10
Stone Ocean - 6.5/10
Steel Ball Run - N/A/10
JoJolion - N/A/10

Rurouni Kenshin

Tokyo Arc - 4.5/10
Kyoto Arc - 6/10
Jinchu Arc - 5/10
Epilogue - 4/10

 

[Kyo]

BIG BUMP

Dragon Ball
Pilaf: 6/10
21st Budokai: 6/10
RRA: 3/10
22nd Budokai: 5.5/10
Piccolo Daimao: 6/10
23rd Budokai: 3/10
Saiyan: 6.5/10
Freeza: 6/10
Cell: 2/10
Boo: 1.5/10

Naruto
Land of Waves: 5/10
Chunin Exams/Konoha Invasion: 6/10
Tsunade: 3.5/10
Sasuke Retrieval: 2/10
Kazekage Rescue: 2/10
Sai Arc: 1/10
Hidan/Kakuzu: 3/10
Itachi Pursuit: 2/10
Pain Arc: 2/10
Five Kage Summit: 1/10
Fourth Shinobi World War: 3/10
Jubi Revival+: 1/10

Bleach
Substitute Shinigami: 4/10
Soul Society: 5.5/10
Arrancar: 2/10
Hueco Mundo: 1/10
Fake Karakura Town: 1/10
Fullbring: 0/10
Thousand Year Blood War: 0/10

Yu Yu Hakusho
Spirit Detective: 5/10
Dark Tournament: 6/10
Chapter Black: 6/10
Three Kings: 2/10

Hunter x Hunter
Hunter Exam: 7/10
Heavens Arena: 7/10
Yorknew City: 8/10
Greed Island: 5/10
Chimera Ant: 8.5/10
Election: 3/10

One Piece
Romance Dawn through Baratie: 5/10
Arlong Park: 7/10
Loguetown: 6/10
Alabasta Saga: 7/10
Sky Island Saga: 4/10
Water 7/Enies Lobby: 6/10
Thriller Bark Saga: 3.5/10
Sabaody Archipelago: 7.5/10
Amazon Lily: 5/10
Impel Down/Marineford: 7/10
Fishman Island: 2/10
Punk Hazard: 2.5/10

Fullmetal Alchemist
East City: 8/10
Central City: 8/10
Briggs: 6/10
Promised Day: 7/10

Berserk
Black Swordsman Arc: 5/10
Golden Age Arc: 10/10
Elf Arc: 5/10
Tower Arc: 7/10
Kushan War Arc: 4/10
Fantasia Arc: 2/10

Slam Dunk
In Training Arc: 5/10
Practice Matches Arc: 5/10
National Preliminaries Arc - 6/10
National Championships Arc - 7/10

Rurouni Kenshin
Tokyo Arc: 4/10
Kyoto Arc: 6/10
Jinchu Arc: 6/10

JJBA
Phantom Blood: 5/10
Battle Tendency: 7/10
Stardust Crusaders: 4.5/10

 

[Fantastische Hure]

Are you scaling them in comparison to other arcs in the series or scaling them in a general sense of how good they are (thus a 5/10 for two different series'd mean they are about the same quality/your liking anyway)?

 

[Kyo]

The latter, as best as I can

 

[Papasmurf]

Did you stop reading OP after punk hazard?

 

[Kyo]

I read some of dressrosa which I had rated in the previous posts but I left it alone this time

 

[ahill1]

Wow, you guys sure take a dump on Cell's arc.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Wow, you guys sure take a dump on Cell's arc.

Inconsistent time travel + inconsistent character writing + poorly executed character focus + contrived changing of the goalposts + retcons = Shit

Are you scaling them in comparison to other arcs in the series or scaling them in a general sense of how good they are (thus a 5/10 for two different series'd mean they are about the same quality/your liking anyway)?

The latter, for me at least.

 

[Fantastische Hure]

Shaman-King:

Tao Family Mission Arc - ?/10
Round 1 Arc (or I guess you could separate here and say Round 1 arc and Rescue Ren arc if you want to) - ?/10
Patch-Village arc (or I guess you could separate and say Journey to Patch-Village arc and then Patch-Village arc) - ?/10

???

 

[Kyo]

waowee

 

[Fantastische Hure]

...

 

[Papasmurf]

Kyo is a lesbian