He's not low diff material, but he's by no means a rival to Garp. He's probably Yonko level.
Shiki putting up a struggle in that 2v1 makes more sense knowing he's below Garp but still edges out Sengoku.
A lot depends on the abilities shown by Roger and Rocks during this event. Haki is a part of swordsmanship. I've always thought there could be more advanced techniques that could allow Shanks to still be stronger but that has yet to be proven.
It's said that all of the fiercest of the seas made it to God Valley. He's a year older than Garp and he was still Vice Admiral by the time Garp was having duels with Roger.
This flashback solidifies him as barely scraping Yonko level at his peak.
Got up to ch 75. It might not just be for me. My unmedicated ADHD ass brain simply can't fully resonate with this kind of storytelling, even though I know intuitively that it's a very well crafted one.
I came into this completely blind thinking it was going to be something other than what it...
But shouldn't they be relative in their primes? Unless you want to make the argument that WB is less taxed by his elder status since he's 4 years younger.