BoG and FnF vs Super anime

SSJ2

Zeta Elite
Staff member
Founder
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
69,959
Age
30
Which is canon here? I realize they both have some differences here and there (haven't seen Super anime), so which is canon?
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,114
Age
30
The Dragonball Super Anime should be held to a higher level of authority than those particular movies. The Anime is rehashing very similar ideas to them -to a greater degree and to a larger audience, but it does make some notable changes. But these alternative series of events are grounded in concrete and aren't prone to change like they were.

GT is intended as a side story to the original Manga.
The movies all take place in alternate Universes.
The Anime follows it's own set of rules; seemingly those of Toei, which is accustomed to giving Goku strength boosts without any sort of valid reasoning.
Whereas Dragonball Super is intended as a direct continuation of the Manga.
 

SSJ2

Zeta Elite
Staff member
Founder
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
69,959
Age
30
Alternate Universes is fine, but they were both created with strong influence by Toriyama, and I feel he played more of a part there than he did with the Super anime, where it seems to me that Toei is running free.
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,114
Age
30
I'm going to throw my idea out there, but it's not meant to be taken as offensive -or even as constructive criticism for that matter, it's regarding a common trend that I've noticed.

Prior to pursuing the continuance of Dragonball, Toriyama re-read the entire original Japanese Manga. He did so to remind himself of things that he may have previously forgotten. Later, Toriyama essentially wrote every piece of dialogue within Battle of Gods and obviously conformed to very specific ideas. Some of these ideas include Gotenks not being as powerful as originally thought -or even Ultimate Gohan for that matter, or Goku not being able to progress any further than where he was at. Another one of these ideas include Base Saiyans being weaker than Organic Frieza, which completely went against the common norm of Dragonball enthusiasts prior to the introduction of Battle of Gods. Dragonball Super rehashes the original trek of thought originally established from Battle of Gods and even the Manga, and continues from then-on. Because fans don't enjoy these particular ideas they tend to come up with their own rules as a means to handicap the new ideas that Dragonball Super brings forth. Addressing the events of Dragonball Super as taking place in an alternate Universe is a fan made myth so fans can create a very specific distinction between Super and the Manga -as a defensive tactic to maintain their ideas, even if it doesn't collaborate with the author's intentions.

For myself personally, I take in the new material and make it fit in with the ideas of the Manga. Hence why I had to take another look into the Majin Boo Saga and currently have the Base Saiyans so weak. I'll continue to adapt to the new material into my logic and I definitely won't consider it apart of some alternate Universe just because it doesn't work with what I THINK to be considered official. It's an insult to the T.V. show and it's an insult to the author.
 

Mystic

Zeta Elite
Global Moderator
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
30,603
Age
19
I'm not sure if I'd consider any of it canon. Perhaps the Chou manga, but who knows how involved Toriyama is with that. They skipped over the entire FNF arc, so that's telling.

I'd hold the movies to a higher standard simply because they're better. Super is a watered down monstrosity.
 

Mystic

Zeta Elite
Global Moderator
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
30,603
Age
19
When they release the blu-ray sets or whatever, they should cut out anything pre-U6 and just include the movies instead.
 

Papasmurf

Zeta Elite
Legend
Member
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
32,247
That's literally the most dishonest packaging ever though. and Toei lives to milk all their products for all they're worth.
 

Let's Go Fearless!

Zeta Elite
25k
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
41,531
Age
27
Super is just retelling the story and add more things which covered the plots of the movie.
 

Papasmurf

Zeta Elite
Legend
Member
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
32,247
Honestly if we're aiming to improve storytelling just cutting out the entire FNF storyline would do just that :et
 

kriss-

Elite
Suspended
Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
7,114
Age
30
People would probably respect Super more if the movies hadn't come out first, and if they weren't around 20 years old at the time of viewing it. (Jokes on you)
 

Papasmurf

Zeta Elite
Legend
Member
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
32,247
I find the Super adaptation of FNF to actually be arguably better than its movie source material. But that doesn't help it become too much less of a pile of written sewage because the original was such a mess that even being 23 years old and having 17 prior years of DB nostalgia at the time couldn't redeem it. :et

Conversely, I personally didn't like BOG but found it to have its appeal to some extent - but the Super version was so bad I'd have hidden under the couch waiting for it to be over if I were forced to marathon through it, lest I fork my eyes out in fear of its horrendousness.
 

Latest profile posts

Fantastische Hure wrote on Very fast Coconut's profile.
Hello hello is this chase?
Very fast Coconut wrote on JefferyWA's profile.
Jeffery are you okay ? Should we contact the police ?
Very fast Coconut wrote on Fantastische Hure's profile.
Why is your name yellow now ?
Top