Goku, Trunks and Piccolo's power in the Android saga

GokhanDBZfan

Mid Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
727
Continuing off from the off-topic debate in this topic:http://dbzeta.net/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=5447

Evil Vegeta said:
Well, that's because the Androids took all of them out in that time. What can be said for certain is neither Krillin nor Tien were actually apart of the solution in the present. Only Piccolo and Vegeta were. I don't think "we" is supposed to be taken literally here. They're a team, so the focus would be based on them as a whole rather than individuals.

Obviously, but then neither can the ''we'' be interprented as Piccolo comparing his strength to Trunks'.

Anyway, Piccolo calls the androids' lack of knowledge of the Super Saiyan form ''a fatal mistake''.
But from what he was told, the androids were supposed to have defeated Trunks as a Super Saiyan and the training was supposed to make the difference.
This supports my theory of Goku not gaining much power, if any, from his training with Gohan and Piccolo.
 

Evil Vegeta

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
3,431
There's certainly room for it to be. If it's a toss-up between the Androids either being piss weak or them getting too strong, the latter would imply Piccolo and Vegeta both displayed enough power to change their fates unlike Trunks. It still wouldn't include Krillin or Tien because neither did anything but watch the entire time. The only ones who displayed any power worth acknowledging was Vegeta and Piccolo. Tien's annoyance at it tells us it can't be anything other than those two in this context.
 

GokhanDBZfan

Mid Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
727
But then Tenshinhan is the one to use Trunks' feat as a measuring stick of the androids' power.
Kami later again uses Trunks' feat to hype up the androids, while completely ignoring Piccolo's supposed SSJ power.
 

Evil Vegeta

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
3,431
This line?

Tenshinhan: “Th-this is the man who took down Freeza…And he was helpless before these androids…I’ll be frank…! No matter how strong Goku may be, he shouldn’t be that different from Trunks or Vegeta…”

From what I see, he's pretty much putting the Super Saiyans in a class of their own. That in itself is fine. The issue seems to come from Trunks improving or not improving before arriving back. Outside of that, it's hard to get an understanding of his power. I guess I'll try to do it:

1) Goku was greater than the stories. Even though Trunks held-back, I think it's okay to put Goku above Trunks here:

Super Saiyan Goku>Super Saiyan Trunks

2) According to Piccolo, Goku's real power as a Super Saiyan was far more stupendous than what he displayed against #19. Knowing this, Goku improved enough for Piccolo to think he wasn't showing anything close to what he was capable of. Piccolo knew something was up from the beginning, but Tien was taken aback by the transformation. I think we can go with this:

Super Saiyan Goku>>Super Saiyan Goku (#19 battle)>Super Saiyan Goku (Yardrat)>Super Saiyan Trunks

3) Piccolo believes Super Saiyan Vegeta might've surpassed Goku's highest level. So:

Super Saiyan Vegeta>=Super Saiyan Goku>Super Saiyan Goku (#19 battle)>Super Saiyan Goku (Yardrat)>Super Saiyan Trunks

3) While Goku wasn't at his best, his attacks were strong enough to potentially empty #19 of his energy had their been no opportunity for him to absorb any energy. Knowing this, he was still more than capable of utilizing his current power as a Super Saiyan to an extent. He was close to full-power, though still far from his best. Piccolo defeated a more powerful #20 at a much quicker pace than Super Saiyan Goku was able to do against a weaker #19. Now I know the heart virus didn't allow Goku to wield all of his power, but based on Tien's reaction to the transformation and the reaction of the others immediately detecting his Super Saiyan Chi, we know Goku couldn't have been pathetically weak. So:

Super Saiyan Vegeta>=Super Saiyan Goku>>Piccolo>>Super Saiyan Goku (#19 battle)>Super Saiyan Goku (Yardrat)>Super Saiyan Trunks

4) Trunks was weaker than Vegeta, but not to the point where he couldn't keep up with him. Vegeta does call his attack a waste of energy, as well as calling him and the others useless when they arrive to help him fight the Androids. Once Vegeta gets serious, Trunks is amazed at Vegeta's display of power. Vegeta wasn't actually on #18's level, but Trunks' reaction tells us Vegeta is on another level.

5) Tien's statement implies the Saiyans are all in the same vicinity of power. I doubt it's anything similar to what Krillin said about the Ginyu Force, but it tells us Trunks can't be significantly below Goku and Vegeta.

6) Kami later admits Vegeta is superior to Trunks, so we know Vegeta is undoubtedly stronger. Even still, Trunks is up there with the other Super Saiyans, which means he's also above Piccolo.

Trunks' improvement or lack thereof is still something that isn't elaborated on. I try to use the other Super Saiyans, Guru's statement on the Piccolo/Kami assimilation, and Piccolo himself to find a level for Trunks. This still leaves us with our own interpretations, since I don't believe there's any other way to assess Trunks' power.

Super Saiyan Vegeta>=Super Saiyan Goku>Super Saiyan Trunks>>Piccolo>Super Saiyan Goku (#19 battle)>Super Saiyan Goku (Yardrat)>Super Saiyan Trunks (Mecha Freeza Arc)

When taking everything into consideration, that's the most accurate comparison chart I could come up with. Piccolo seems like a low-level Super Saiyan at this point to me. Really powerful as a non Super Saiyan, but not on the level of the current Super Saiyans just yet.
 

Evil Vegeta

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
3,431
GokhanDBZfan said:
But Tenshinhan's reaction isn't a comparison with what he sensed before, he outright acts, as if he never saw the Super Saiyan transformation, ever. Thus his reaction cannot be taken to mean Super Saiyan Goku (#19 battle)>Super Saiyan Goku (Yardrat).

Yet we know he did. So, you can either assume he a) forgot, or b) thought the power was even greater than what he sensed before.

What we know for a fact is he talks about Super Saiyan being in another dimension entirely while fighting. At the very least, Goku showed greater power than he did a few yrs back.

As I said, Tenshinhan's reaction isn't a comparison with what he sensed before, because he outright acts, as if he never saw the Super Saiyan transformation ever.
Thus his reaction cannot be taken to mean Super Saiyan Goku (#19 battle)>Super Saiyan Goku (Yardrat).

This doesn't change the fact that he did, nor does it change the fact that he says Goku was fighting with power in a different dimension. Kaioshin questions if Super Saiyan was really that strong when he was just shown questioning if he was capable of stopping such a huge power. We know he sensed Gohan there just like we know Tien sensed Goku a few yrs before. Their dialogue is just written to a point where it makes them look stupid.

But that be attributed to Vegeta's attitude.

Not so sure about that. He watched Trunks transform and unleash a useless Chi-blast right in front of him. I think he knows how strong Trunks is.

Trunks in that instance actually wasn't paying attention to Vegeta's ki, as he doesn't notice Vegeta's decreasing ki, so that doesn't really make Vegeta much stronger than Trunks.

Piccolo said he was slowly wearing himself out. That isn't an indication of his Chi diminishing to the point where it's obvious. Piccolo was just looking at the fact that he was fighting someone with limitless power. I don't really see how it can be said Trunks wasn't paying attention when he outright says he had no clue Vegeta was that powerful. I find it hard to believe that Tien's quote is enough to override everything stated and shown if the guy can be so forgetful as to what a Super Saiyan feels like.

As you said, Trunks' supposed power up isn't never mentioned , but he is said to be in the same tier as Goku and Vegeta, unlike Piccolo.

This just means the Super Saiyans at that point are above Piccolo. There isn't a specific level that determines what Super Saiyan tier is. If simply being a Super Saiyan meant they were above Piccolo, he'd be inferior to Super Saiyan Future Kid Trunks. There's a wide range Piccolo can fall into while still being below the Super Saiyans without any issues. Kami definitely says Vegeta is above Trunks, though, so it's enough for the difference to stand out to him. If it wasn't noticeable, I doubt Kami would've noted it.

Given that there really isn't anything mentioning Goku's improvement from the years of training and the opposite is implied with him calling RoSaT training useless unless he finds a way to go beyond SSJ, I just think Goku didn't improve much from the years of training and Vegeta only surpassed him by becoming a Super Saiyan, which makes sense, as two weaklings(Piccolo and Gohan) would only get in Goku's way, instead of being proper sparring partners, as is the case with Gohan in the RoSaT.

Piccolo says Goku's power as a Super Saiyan was far greater than what they were seeing against #19. That's enough of an indication that he was different than he was from 3 yrs before. If he was literally the same guy, it would've been pointless to even bring up. Even from a story-telling perspective, it wouldn't make sense. Trunks warned these guys about the Androids, so Goku proceeds to....barely gain any power and yet he's eager to go at the Androids right off the bat? Seems rather odd to me.

The only reason why I could see him being eager is because he was confident in his power. The Androids being capable of handling a Super Saiyan without any issue would naturally be something Goku had in mind going on, so that's all the more reason for him to improve. Also, 3 yrs is enough time for Goku to not only train with the others, but to get some of his own training in as well.

The expectations in the rosat were entirely different. Goku wanted to go beyond Super Saiyan and make Gohan stronger than himself. For the Androids, Goku just wanted to get stronger sparring for 3 yrs. Like Trunks said, sparring is a more effective way of training, but that doesn't mean it's the only way of training. Piccolo spent 6 months training alone before returning and training Gohan on everything. That didn't stop him from getting a significant increase in power. There's no one way to acquire power.

At least you have Piccolo around Goku's level while fighting #19.
 

ahill1

Super Elite
Donor
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
14,646
I personally find Piccolo's comment about the androids not knowing the SSJ a bit nonsense since he knew future Trunks SSJ was no match for these androids and that Goku had to train in order to match their strength.

The "we" should be referring to the ones who fought the androids, which would be Goku, Vegeta and Piccolo and Green Man probably said "we" because he is the weakest. I don't think Piccolo would include the humans in that statement since one [or two?] chapters before Green Man flat out stated to Gohan, Kuririn and Tenshinhan not to try to fight 20, because he is too much for them. He even said it's better to call him or Vegeta.

While Tenshinhan's comments might imply he forgot about SSJ Goku's power from 3 years ago, I find it a bit hard to believe due to him still remembering and mentioning Freeza's murder in Trunks' hands. It's like when Kaioshin was surprised with base Vegeta's power, but still mentioned the toughness in holding SSJ2 Gohan.
 

Evil Vegeta

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
3,431
GokhanDBZfan said:
None of that makes Sick Goku stronger than Yadrat Goku, though.

He specifically tells Trunks he has something to work towards, and he's going to train very hard for the next 3 yrs. It just wouldn't make any sense for him to be the exact same guy he was when he met Trunks. The same Trunks said he could barely hold his own against one Android, while Goku is perfectly willing to take on both alone. That actually would be enough to put him way above Trunks from back then.

All it means is Sick Goku is way stronger than Tenshinhan and suppressed Piccolo, which was obvious.

All we really know is that he's not fighting at his best. That in itself doesn't mean he's particularly weak--just not where he should be.

See my previous reply.

If Tien can be considered a clueless idiot, then there's little reason to believe his assessment on the Saiyans needs to be an absolute fact.

Kaioshin is shown to have forgotten about the Saiyan's true abilities though and is recalling them after they called Dabra weak.
He also implies Gohan wasn't at full power when he stopped him.

It was still a stupid comment no matter how you look at it. Questioning if Super Saiyans are strong after admitting you're not sure if you can actually stop the one in front of you is just....:wat

Maybe, but this is the same guy, who thought he didn't need the Z-Fighters' help even after 18 tanked his punch to the gut.

When you look at how quickly they were all swept aside while he continued to fight with a broken arm, what he said actually has merit.

Judging by the short amount of time it takes 18 to to drain his stamina(in comparison with Kamiccolo's fight with 17), I don't think he was losing stamina at a slow rate. Because he is appeared to be fighting evenly with the Android 18.Notice he never calls Vegeta's ki being amazing.

Highlighting someone's Chi isn't the only way compliment their power. Trunks said Goku was greater than all of the stories he's heard about him. That's an acknowledgement of Goku's power without commenting on his Chi. Tien says Super Saiyan Goku had an incredible Chi, then later says Piccolo and Vegeta both powered-up incredibly without never commenting on either's Chi. I doubt his quote on Goku is more significant because he mentioned his Chi. A compliment to ones power is a compliment.

Tenshinhan's statement regarding Trunks' placement though is supported by Kami, by Vegeta's inability to shrug off Trunks and by the power of a Super Saiyan being considered a set tier of power.

Thing is, Kami and Tien's quote differs because Tien doesn't believe Goku would be any different than Trunks or Vegeta, whereas Kami makes it a point to highlight Vegeta's superiority to Trunks. When going by that, we can deduce that Vegeta is noticeably ahead of Trunks. To Krillin and Tien, Super Saiyans were the greatest things ever. Their reactions to them being easily defeated aren't really that surprising.

That actually can be considered a possibility, as, unlike what that manga panel might look like, Trunks was said to be strong enough to surpass Gohan in few months, which also supports Trunks not being the type of guy to train hard after Gohan's death.

Gohan was under the impression that he'd continue training Trunks when he said he might surpass him in a few months. Once it became clear that his battle with the Androids might be his final one, he changed his mind about Trunks:

Gohan: “If you died, then there wouldn’t be any more warriors to save the Earth…You’re the last warrior with the potential to be capable of defeating those androids after a few years…”

Keep in mind that this is the same Gohan who believed he improved enough to beat #17 on his own at the very least.


Trunks definitely continued to train hard after Gohan was gone. That explains why he was so sure of himself after doing it for 3 whole yrs.

It doesn't have to be an indication of that, especially when Tenshinhan acts like a clueless idiot.

Well, like I said, if he's clueless, then he also apparently sucks at comparing the Super Saiyans. Kami makes it clear who's without a doubt the strongest between Vegeta and Trunks.

It wouldn't be pointless, because Sick Goku is still weaker than what he should be at full power.

That's all we're told. Super Saiyan Goku can still be powerful even though he's not at his best. That's my point. H

The characters are all banking on Goku being alive and the only Super Saiyan, while the supposed years of training are disregarded.

That still requires him to be better than he was from 3 yrs before. If he didn't change that much from the training, then it was pointless for him.

Only Vegeta becoming a Super Saiyan and Piccolo powering up is brought up later, but nothing else.

Considering those were the only things worth mentioning, I can understand why.

Krillin:''The guy from the future said we fought the androids without Goku and all of us got killed''.
To which Piccolo responds:''The timing on Goku's virus is off, thus things might not go the same way as he said.''
and not:''We trained hard for many years for this, I am confident in my power.''

Things don't have to be a stated a certain way when the context can convey the message. The only way they wouldn't be killed is if they're strong enough to prevent it. Piccolo took Gero's eye lasers like it was nothing and said the attack wasn't enough to stop him. While he'd likely assume that wasn't his full-power, he'd be able to gauge his power to an extent to know he's certainly not out of his league. There's literally no other way they wouldn't get picked off by the Androids unless the Androids decided not to do it for some reason. If anything, this goes along with what Piccolo later said to Gero perfectly.

I brought this up before, but against Dr.Gero, Piccolo says their lack of information on the Super Saiyan form will cost them victory and not the Z-Fighters' years of training, which contradicts Piccolo having any high expectations of the androids' power like SSJ Trunks<the androids.

Yeah, Piccolo said that. Piccolo wasn't questioning the Androids power, just their shit calculations. He couldn't possibly know anything about their power outside of what he's been told. Anything more, and you end up with Piccolo coming up with his own scenario (though to be fair, he was thinking of the Androids potentially hiding if they started getting their asses handed to them) of what may or may not transpire. It doesn't make any sense and creates unnecessary confusion. Gero told Goku the level of power was a surprise, but not to a point where they couldn't handle it. Things only began to change when Piccolo realized the timing of Goku's virus was different.

Before he was knocked down by Gero's eye lasers, there was nothing to base the Androids power on outside of what Trunks said. Super Saiyan itself wouldn't have decided the victory. A strong Super Saiyan Goku would've.

Goku had no reason to not be confident, because he was a Super Saiyan among them and Trunks didn't explictly say he was much weaker than one android alone.

Trunks pretty much says taking on one Android is a handful, yet Goku is willing to fight both of them without any help. Goku has to be way above Trunks for that to even be considered, or it just makes Goku look like an overconfident moron.

It doesn't mean it's the only way of training, but Goku pretty much says, that unless he finds a way to go beyond Super Saiyan, he won't grow any stronger. The same concept is mentioned many times in that portion of the story.

Sparring in general is a good way of training. Goku asked Piccolo to train with him and Gohan because he wanted to spar. For him to suggest that method of training knowing Piccolo wasn't on his level, he had to have thought he could still improve enough to make a difference in 3 yrs. Going beyond Super Saiyan became a thing when they realized Super Saiyan was useless against the Androids. Before the Androids arrived, Goku most likely assumed normal sparring would give him the necessary gains to take them on without an issue.
 

GokhanDBZfan

Mid Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
727
Gohan is Base Saiyan tier though.He isn't any more useful than the likes of Krillin or Tenshinhan.
 

ahill1

Super Elite
Donor
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
14,646
@GokhanDBZfan

I'm saying it's nonsense to Piccolo to say they [the androids] made a mistake when he knew very well Trunks SSJ was no match for them. Because of it I don't like to consider that quote to be much.

No, I don't think so. I think it's most likely Piccolo was just referring to the ones who fought the Androids (him, Vegeta and Goku), even more when just a little ago he said Kuririn, Tenshinhan and Gohan were no match for 20. It doesn't make any sense he consider them in the "we grew too strong", because Piccolo himself knew they were far too weak to fight them and would better to call him or Vegeta.

It's not just Tenshinhan's reaction though. There's also Kuririn and Yamcha don't questioning why Goku didn't improve al all in the 3 years gap. Piccolo said Goku should be a lot stronger but he wasn't panicking as if he was at a level completely incapable of fighting the Androids that were told to be stronger than Goku and Trunks from 3 years ago.
 

xmysticgohanx

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2015
Messages
1,925
Age
27
@gokhandbzfan

Piccolo can still be SSJ tier and not be in the Android arc SSJ tier:

Tier 1:

SSJ Vegeta
SSJ Goku
-
SSJ Trunks

Tier 2:

Piccolo

Tier 3:

Sick Goku

Tier 4

Yardrat Goku

tier 5

Namek SSJ Goku
 

xmysticgohanx

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2015
Messages
1,925
Age
27
@gokhandbzfan you think Android arc Trunks = Mecha Freeza arc Trunks?
 

Latest profile posts

I don't want to live anymore
Sovran Nila wrote on Pocket-Gog~'s profile.
Goo Goo Ga Ga!
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 Free Ukraine 🇺🇦
Top