How strong is Android Piccolo compared to Goku/Vegeta?

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
It doesn't even make sense. If 19 had absorbed all of that energy to make Vegeta that weak, then why is he running? Sure, he has no hands, but he should be able to kick very well. He can fly. It doesn't really make sense. Unless 19 lost the energy he was absorbing. How can Vegeta lose so much power, yet 19 not be stronger than him? That whole sequence doesn't make sense.

20 should not be on a different level than 19 Post. Let's not forget Gero was shitting his pants watching Goku fight.
 

freezamite

Mid Class Warrior
Suspended
Joined
Nov 16, 2016
Messages
687
Saiyan Paladin said:
freezamite said:
Lol, made some mistakes, his writing proved to be of a high enough level that most of the "readers" (more like anime spectators) can't even understand things as obvious as #18 and Vegeta being more or less at the same ballpark in terms of power, Nappa being stronger than Goku, SSJ Goku in Namek being much weaker than KKx20 Namek Goku (and that one was even clarified by himself)

Lol, the manga doesn't push that message whatsoever, you are delusional.
That's why I laugh when I read that Toriyama was a bad writer. Yes, the manga doesn't "push" those messages in the sense that it isn't an "in your face" situation that even a 3 year old kid could understand, but it's obvious that this is how things were (even Toriyama had to explain the Namek SSJ Goku thing!).
So if even at his "bad" level he was writing at a level most of the "anime first" people can't comprehend, imagine if he had been even better.

Because Nappa > Goku, A18 = SSJ Vegeta and Freezer >>> SSJ Goku (even SSJ Goku = KKx10 Goku can be argued with numbers and statements) are perfectly demonstrable through manga feats and statements.

Regarding 19 and 20, 19 was much weaker than 20, which wasn't "that" far apart from Vegeta. SSJ Vegeta ended being weaker than A20 (he had to bluff in order to scare him, and the proof of that is that he asked for a senzu bean before going after the android) after having had his energy absorbed by 19.
Even if Vegeta let 19 absorb more energy to see how those absorption capabilities worked, the energy 19 had to absorb could be 25%-30% of Vegeta's energy at best.
So A20 > 70% SSJ Vegeta (minus the energy he had lost with the Big Bang, but let's not pretend that's a lot).
 

Void

Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
Sep 10, 2016
Messages
6,305
Age
45
freezamite said:
Because Nappa > Goku, A18 = SSJ Vegeta and Freezer >>> SSJ Goku (even SSJ Goku = KKx10 Goku can be argued with numbers and statements) are perfectly demonstrable through manga feats and statements.

I disagree wholeheartedly with all of that, and I've owned all 42 volumes of the manga for years. You've been saying this for a while and you have yet to prove any of it, you are incredibly stubborn, but at least you're not an asshole about it.

:sponge
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
Well 20 is actually not that much stronger than 19. 20 is in complete shock and awe while he watches Goku beat on 19. Nothing about 20's reactions suggest he was on Goku's level and when 19 absorbs some of Goku's energy, not even reaching Goku's level, 20 becomes jealous of 19's power. 20 is clearly overstating his superiority over 19. Also note that Goku is not staggeringly superior to 19. He's superior by a good margin for sure, but he's not even as superior as Kkx3 Goku was over Vegeta, or Reecome was over Vegeta. 19 can still track majority of Goku's movements while he is going all out as stated.
 

Pyro

Elite
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
9,061
p123 said:
Well 20 is actually not that much stronger than 19. 20 is in complete shock and awe while he watches Goku beat on 19. Nothing about 20's reactions suggest he was on Goku's level and when 19 absorbs some of Goku's energy, not even reaching Goku's level, 20 becomes jealous of 19's power. 20 is clearly overstating his superiority over 19. Also note that Goku is not staggeringly superior to 19. He's superior by a good margin for sure, but he's not even as superior as Kkx3 Goku was over Vegeta, or Reecome was over Vegeta. 19 can still track majority of Goku's movements while he is going all out as stated.
So #19 is at least 75% of sick Goku?
 

Kyo

High Class Warrior
Donor
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
4,717
19 post: 100?
Sick Goku: 100
19 pre: 75
Yardrat Goku: 75
Trunks: 66

eh
 

Void

Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
Sep 10, 2016
Messages
6,305
Age
45
Why do we try to stick a static number on Sick Goku?
 

Kyo

High Class Warrior
Donor
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
4,717
Whenever I do it it's just his starting level
 

Diamond Ryan

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,809
Age
23
This is what I have:

Sick Goku - 67.5
19 post - 63
Trunks - 60
19 pre - 55

Anything wrong with this?
 

freezamite

Mid Class Warrior
Suspended
Joined
Nov 16, 2016
Messages
687
Saiyan Paladin said:
I disagree wholeheartedly with all of that, and I've owned all 42 volumes of the manga for years. You've been saying this for a while and you have yet to prove any of it, you are incredibly stubborn, but at least you're not an asshole about it.

:sponge
And even if you owned the manga (which I don't doubt), I wouldn't hesitate to affirm that you first learned about this series through the anime, which conditioned the way you read the manga afterwards.

I mean, Nappa > Goku is undeniable. Nappa loses strength fighting the z-warriors with his disturbed ki (he doesn't take a lot of damage, but still loses some strength), then he is beat by 8000k+ Goku while his Ki is still disturbed which also took a toll on his power, and even after all that, he managed to fight Goku at his same speed and physical strength (while still having a much higher damage endurance than Goku).
It's only the circumstances that make Goku seem stronger, but when sticking to the facts, he is undeniably weaker.

Regarding Freezer >>> SSJ Goku, even if we don't look at the feats given in the Cell saga that demonstrate how big was the difference and limit our analysis to the fight they had, a pretty injured and weakened Freezer managed to fight SSJ Goku at his same level when he decided to use all his strength (in other words, 100% of power). That alone already puts him above SSJ Goku.

Finally, A18 = SSJ Vegeta. We are discussing this in the other thread to avoid repeating myself and thus making this message one of the shortest I've ever written in here :alex2

p123 said:
Well 20 is actually not that much stronger than 19. 20 is in complete shock and awe while he watches Goku beat on 19. Nothing about 20's reactions suggest he was on Goku's level and when 19 absorbs some of Goku's energy, not even reaching Goku's level, 20 becomes jealous of 19's power.
He was considerably stronger considering that 19 was weaker than ill SSJ Goku, while 20 was stronger than 70% SSJ Vegeta. Him being impressed can be explained by the expectations they originally had, I mean, 20 clearly states that even if Goku could've improved a bit after his fight with Vegeta, he wouldn't be much stronger than that.
Regarding 20's comment, it's not him being envious of 19's power, he just was afraid Goku was going to win 19 and enjoyed 19 turning the tables on the fight, he never stated that 19 being stronger than him (although that could be the case after having absorbed the KHH considering that a 10% difference would already explain SSJ Vegeta's superiority and that unlike 16, 17 and 18, those androids didn't have unlimited energy and lost strength when they were injured).
 

Void

Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
Sep 10, 2016
Messages
6,305
Age
45
Nappa loses strength fighting the z-warriors with his disturbed ki (he doesn't take a lot of damage, but still loses some strength)

Provide evidence Nappa lost strength before fighting Goku.

Regarding Freezer >>> SSJ Goku, even if we don't look at the feats given in the Cell saga that demonstrate how big was the difference and limit our analysis to the fight they had, a pretty injured and weakened Freezer managed to fight SSJ Goku

Provide evidence Freeza's ki had dropped by the time SS Goku made his debut.

Finally, A18 = SSJ Vegeta

Gingertown Cell is stronger than SS Vegeta. Gingertown Cell is weaker than Weighted Piccolo w/Kami. No.16 says that same Piccolo is rivals No.18. How do you fit Vegeta in there and still have him be equal to No.18? You can't, the manga paints a clear picture.
 

Evil Vegeta

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2015
Messages
3,428
Vegeta saying "they're all easily surpassing the Super Saiyan" tells us all we need to know.
 

Void

Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
Sep 10, 2016
Messages
6,305
Age
45
IHHi0gq.png


1VGrbru.png


Seems pretty clear.
 

Pyro

Elite
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
9,061
Don't bring Nappa into this. Keep that jank discussion to its own thread.

Also, yeah, agreed with the basic chain: 18 ~ weighted Kamiccolo > Ginger Cell >/~ Vegeta. No way 18 and Vegeta are equals.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
No, Gero is in shock and fearful of Goku's power. He wants nothing to do with him.
 

p123

Elite
Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
5,587
No, 19 Post without a doubt is not stronger than Sick Goku...

Super Saiyan Vegeta > Piccolo > 20 Post > Sick Goku > 19 Post > Sick Goku (Post KHH) / 20 > 19

If you are any sort of gentleman, you go by this chain herhmmm
 

Latest profile posts

Trump is the rightful democratically elected president of Brazil :trump
SHOW ME UR PREZIDENT FACE!!!
Top