Since the bandwagon for this has appeared...

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
Ultimate Cell said:
What is your reason for you having Part 5 the weakest of the bunch?
Has perhaps the most plot armour out of the parts at several points, messy placements of backstories instead of much actual character development, Notorious B.I.G. breaks any kind of rule previously set up about Stands all for the sake of giving one character an opponent and Diavlo was easily the most disappointing and non-fleshed out main villain of the series. Also, Requiem Stands are the most overpowered thing in the series and only existed as a plot device to take down King Crimson's broken ability with a more broken ability.
Only major positives about the part beyond the creativity of several Stands and the entertainment factor of the torture dance would be it handling death in more of a realistic and varied way than any of the parts that came before it and it probably doing the best job overall at tying character personalities to their Stands' ability, Abacchio and Diavlo being the most major examples.

Fearless In Quarantine said:
Thoughts on Mission Impossible franchise?
Haven't seen any of the films.
 

SSJ2

Zeta Elite
Staff member
Founder
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
65,727
Age
28
Part 3 is only marginally better than 1? Oh boy.
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
Pretty much, and even that's arguable when it's easily the most repetitive Part in the series. It has some pretty major flaws that hold it back such as a few retcons, contrivances and overall pointless segments, though it edges out over Part 1 due to the positives of having pretty good character chemistry, some interesting tactics in some of the Stand battles and the time taken to showcase the culture of each of the location's visited on the journey making the journey/adventure aspect of it quite strong. Despite its repetitiveness, it's also a lot more entertaining than Part 1 as well due to the comedy, interesting action scenarios, decent creativity in the Stand abilities and not just being a Hokuto no Ken knockoff with vampires where Dio's the only thing keeping it entertaining.
 

SSJ2

Zeta Elite
Staff member
Founder
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
65,727
Age
28
Jonathan Joestar didn’t entertain you??
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
Not when he's an entirely reactive character who's gentlemanly attitude is the only thing stopping him from being a Kenshiro clone. His history with Dio did make their conflict engaging, though that's still just a point to Dio.
Sunlight Yellow Overdrive was cool, though mainly jut for the anime's ost.

I mean, Jotaro was basically just a delinquent Kenshiro, though at least he had a lot cooler one-liners and more independence when it came to conflict, not to mention some decent maturing later on in the series.
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
Fearless In Quarantine said:
Watched any DiCaprio's film?
If talking about those he's produced, no. As far as those he's acted in, I've seen Romeo + Juliet, Titanic and Django Unchained. Romeo + Juliet felt completely out of place with its dialogue as the choice of making it the Shakespearean English of the original work whilst giving it a modern setting caused the film to be completely immersion breaking and make little sense, even though the original work is a decent romantic tragedy. Titanic is overall an average film with a fair few highs and lows, with little complete strong points to place it any higher beyond the budget. Django Unchained is a decent satire of the Blacksploitation films of the 70s, though doesn't have much going for it beyond that and some good dialogue.

Super Saiyan said:
Is hokuto ni Ken good?
Very. It doesn't take too many risks when it comes to breaking narrative trends, but that ends up being its strength in displaying traditional ideas and doing them well. There's still a few problems it has such as a certain resolve hax, a small build up without a real payoff and Hokuto Shinken functioning as a bit of a swiss army plot device, but none of the flaws are overblown to the egregious extent of most other Shonen. As for the positives, the characters all have interlinked history with each other to make for good character driven conflict, several characters are well developed, the setting is bleak enough for the themes of love to actually be relevant within it and despite using some Shonen tropes, many aspects of it can seem different from the Shonen of today. Its protagonist is mature in his actions and merciless to his enemies, as well as being close to his peak of skill by the start. Many characters die, ranging from children to main characters. The power inflation is never to the extent previous top tiers become total fodder and skill does play a fair role in many battles. From those alone and far less negatives than positives, it's easily one of the best Shonen out there, definitely top 5 Shonen material.

That's as long as you ignore the post-timeskip material that retcons a lot of events and even introduces a chosen one trope, so best to stop reading after chapter 137. Unlike something such as say, One Piece, the end of part 1 leaves no major plot points unresolved, so you'll get a complete story from that material.

Super Saiyan said:
Do you like Joseph Joestar?
Yeah. Joseph was a definite improvement on Jonathan, even more so when propping them up as comparisons. His uncouth yet strategic nature make him both more engaging and entertaining than his grandfather and seeing him mature through Part 2, as well as become a group leader in Part 3, make for an interesting character arc for him.
Not all about him is great though. Compared to a later JoJo such as Josuke, some of his strategies do seem quite loose or lacking in comprehensible planning to the point some of them come off as plot armour. Also, Part 3 Joseph was fairly underutilised in the plot, which was quite disappointing. Nevertheless, as a mix of the stern and snarky personalities of various 80s action heroes with a decent arc and his maturing into a flawed but lovable mentor figure, he's easily a great protagonist by Shonen standards and one of the best JoJos, probably third only to Johnny and Jolyne.

7/10
 

SSJ2

Zeta Elite
Staff member
Founder
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
65,727
Age
28
What are your general thoughts on he pillar men?
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
Esidisi was entertaining in his battle with Joseph and his use of deception was interesting, but was definitely the blandest of the bunch and only amounted to being a measuring stick to build up Joseph for the rematch with Wammu. 5/10

As for Wammu, he was probably the member with the most characterisation of the group with his honour, along with his younger age compared to his peers giving him a good reason to be subservient to Kars despite being physically superior. He isn't anything too deep as a character, but was well done for the role he played in the story. 6/10

Then for their leader, Kars had his interesting traits such as the subtle showing of his respect towards animals and nature such as the dog he saved or the flower he avoided crushing, which when contrasted with his disdain for humanity, shows how his respect for those who have what he lacks drives him to achieve his goal. He would've easily been the best of the group for that alone, but him just becoming a generic God complex villain after becoming the ultimate life form knocks him down a few points. Also, his backstory was pretty lacking when it came to major motivation for his goal. 6/10
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
Fearless In Quarantine said:
Do you like Boo as a villain?
No. I find Fat Boo to be average as a villain with him having decent potential to be explored such as internal conflict and a lack of focus due to his childish personality, but that ended up meaning little when the conflict became externalised. Evil Boo was just pink Cell with less intelligence and Pure Boo was a nothing character just there to have Galu be the hero.
Still a better character as a whole than Cell though.

Fearless In Quarantine said:
Favorite Harry Potter movie?
Half-Blood Prince probably had the least amount of many glaring flaws to it, so probably that.
 

SSJ2

Zeta Elite
Staff member
Founder
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
65,727
Age
28
Do you think Dion is a good villain?
 

Ultimate Cell

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2017
Messages
2,870
Captain Cadaver said:
Esidisi was entertaining in his battle with Joseph and his use of deception was interesting, but was definitely the blandest of the bunch and only amounted to being a measuring stick to build up Joseph for the rematch with Wammu. 5/10

As for Wammu, he was probably the member with the most characterisation of the group with his honour, along with his younger age compared to his peers giving him a good reason to be subservient to Kars despite being physically superior. He isn't anything too deep as a character, but was well done for the role he played in the story. 6/10

Then for their leader, Kars had his interesting traits such as the subtle showing of his respect towards animals and nature such as the dog he saved or the flower he avoided crushing, which when contrasted with his disdain for humanity, shows how his respect for those who have what he lacks drives him to achieve his goal. He would've easily been the best of the group for that alone, but him just becoming a generic God complex villain after becoming the ultimate life form knocks him down a few points. Also, his backstory was pretty lacking when it came to major motivation for his goal. 6/10
Your opinion on the Pillar Men theme ost?
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
Super Saiyan said:
Do you think Dion is a good villain?
Dion? The fabled fusion between Dio-sama and Lord :donovan? He's the GOAT, obviously. :giraffe

As for Dio, he's entertaining as a villain, but not anything too deep, being just a foil to the main cast and overly evil for the sake of it. He does have some qualities to help place him above the average villain tier such as his genuine care for his mother as well as the thematic contrast between him and Jonathan make his irredeemable and unjustifiable nature somewhat essential to Part 1's themes though he's basically just got that and his charisma. He's a decent villain overall, but for the most iconic villain of the franchise, he's probably second worst written out of the 6 main villains (Diavlo taking the #1 in that category) and his SBR equivalent Diego Brando is a lot better written of a character overall.

6/10

Ultimate Cell said:
Your opinion on the Pillar Men theme ost?
Probably the best track of the Part 2 anime, with its meme potential or without, though Stroheim's theme "Propaganda" and Caesar's death theme are honourable mentions. The mix between somewhat Arabic vocals with a techno/hip-hop beat is the kind of absurdity that really helps the Bizarre aspect of JoJo shine. This track awakens my Pillar. :panties
 

Captain Cadaver

Zeta Elite
Retired Staff
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
27,967
theallpowerfulpuipui said:
Better third movie:

Rambo III or Rocky III
Considering all Rambo films after the first one were mindless action flicks that betrayed the themes and premise of the original whereas Rocky III expands on Rocky's character arc, Rocky III wins easily.

GreatSaiyaman123 said:
Top 10 worst original trilogy post release edits? (Stuff like Greedo shooting first etc).
#1 - CGI Jabba (and Han saying he's a wonderful human being)
#2 - Vader saying it's impossible the son of Anakin Skywalker is alive, when tracking down Luke was his #1 priority in Empire (not to mention Disney Canon comics making the plot hole even worse)
#3 - Luke being given Palpatine's shout when jumping down the hole at the end of the Vader fight in Empire
#4 - Luke's quip at R2 not being tasty being changed to "You were lucky to get out of there" on Dagobah
#5 - Greedo shoots first
#6 - CGI creatures flooding Mos Eisley
#7 - Jedi Rocks
#8 - Hayden Christensen Anakin Force Ghost (I personally didn't mind it too much, but I'm having to reach to make this a top 10. Don't think I can make it a top 10, really)

If include reinterpretations of the OT such as Galaxy of Heroes, then the SJW episode that made Leia seem godlike would be #1.
 

Latest profile posts

LlfudXi.gif
Trump is the rightful democratically elected president of Brazil :trump
Top