Why do English dub shounen protagonists all have raspy voices?

Warmmedown

Super Elite
Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2015
Messages
12,895
Age
31
Is this true?
Does it extend to main young male MCs outside of battle shounen and all shounen? Like the main guy in sailor moon or princess jellyfish (that even have a dub?)

If it is super common, why is that? Japanese voices don't seem to do it. Do real teenagers talk so raspy? I don't think they do. Is it because grown men VAs usually sound too manly, there are no teen VAs (plus labour laws for minors) and women sound too womanly?

Does anyone know if Japanese female VAs of shounen protags have voiced female characters too and if so do they sound different when doing those voices compared to their male characters - basically do they have some voice change to sound like a male teen, similar to English-lang VAs making it raspy?
 

sei'taer

High Class Warrior
Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2015
Messages
4,272
Main character voices in dub are why I don't watch dubs.
 

Yoshi

Super Elite
Ultimate
Joined
May 30, 2015
Messages
10,550
Age
31
Ichigo and Natsu are probably the only exceptions when it comes to mainstream battle shonen anime.
 

Sovran Nila

Elite
Sovereign Master of Spamifestation
Joined
Aug 3, 2016
Messages
5,216
This was too short to upload to Youtube, so I uploaded here:


:LUL:

As a real man, with interest in voiceover and voice acting, I can't sound like a teenager. We usually hear the same batch of actors, more or less. Anime is about acting, not the exact sound of the voice. Anime won't hire a newbie with no experience in acting, and I believe this is why we've arrived at this point.
 

Latest profile posts

You have to admit, that is doesn't matter. Whatever your spam is, mine is simply better.
Sovran Nila wrote on King Gattsu's profile.
Spam is my friend. :mad:
Sovran Nila wrote on Nila Watch's profile.
Will you log in this year?
Top