XXX vs XXX One Piece Edition

[Captain Cadaver]

That was a typo. I meant Gladius (the bomb guy from Doffy's crew).

 

[Papasmurf]

Luffy would probably win assuming he got a zenkai post Doffy

Current Mr. 3 vs. Alabasta Mr. 1

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Daz Bones stomps since nothing proves Galdino's gotten any stronger, since most of his feats are purely defensive ones based on his DF's ability more than anything.

Current Base Zoro VS Hancock

 

[Symbiote]

Since he's never really shown any interest in a woman yet I'll give it to Zoro since Hancock is nothing if she can't turn you into stone.

Current Usopp vs the giraffe CP9 guy (pre-skip). Forgot his name.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

With his best weaponry, Usopp stomps by trapping Kaku in Kairoseki cuffs and blasting an Impact Wolf at him. Without weapons, Kaku stomps though, considering Usopp bothering to mention Hody being far stronger than Arlong whilst scared of his power implies Arlong is still a level above Usopp's raw power.

Leopard Hybrid Lucci (Film Gold) VS Current Burgess

 

[xmysticgohanx]

Lucci stomps if he really is on par with Sabo

Kalifa vs Arlong

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Arlong is far stronger physically, though as long as the battle doesn't take place near water, Kalifa wins by taking his attacks with Tekkai and speedblitzing him with Soru until enough Shigan and Rankyaku wear him down.

Base Moria VS Gear 3rd Luffy (Marineford)

 

[Pocket-God]

Moria gets wrecked, he was nothing special.

Barto and Cabbage vs Law

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Law's DF is too haxed for Bartolomeo's to be of use if he steps into Room. At most, they'd give law high-diff.

Katakuri VS Cracker

 

[Pocket-God]

Katakuri should win, right?

Nightmare luffy Vs a Pacifista

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Considering the Straw Hats needed everything they had just to beat a Pacifista and needed similar effort to defeat Moria/Oars, whereas Nightmare Luffy was stomping the latter, I'd say Luffy beats the Pacifista as easily as his post-timeskip self did.

Sulong Carrot VS Current Base Zoro
- No stamina drain for Carrot.
- If Carrot wins, Zoro can use Asura.

 

[Epicnessbeyond]

I think Base Zoro can probably take it based on the speculation that we haven’t seen anything closed to Zoro’s full power yet. It was clear that in all fights so far he is not going all out. I see Sulong Carrot being just as strong as Sanji.

Jinbei vs Cracker on water

 

[Pocket-God]

On water? Jinbei wins by default I guess. But if you meant like on a boat that's in the water I'd still go with Jinbei since all he'd have to do is sink the boat.

5 Pacifistas vs Current Straw hats without the monster trio

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Franky is basically a Pacifista with intelligence now and for what non-canon stuff is worth, he's shown to be equal in strength to post-Dressrosa Base Luffy in a Film Gold short. With the Shogun, he can probably take out two Pacifista and Monster Chopper can probably do the same seeing as how Luffy felt the need to use the Elephant Gun to take down Franky in Monster Chopper's body. The other Pacifista should be taken down by the rest of the Straw Hats due to good teamwork, considering how the low and mid tier Straw Hats fared against comparable opponents such as the Dragon and Buffalo/Baby 5.

Reiju & Ichiji VS Zoro and Law
- The Vinsmokes have full intel on Law's abilities.
- Zoro is limited to his base form and Law can't use Gamma Knife or his heart swap technique.
- Vinsmokes start off in the suits they used to fight Big Mom's family.

 

[ahill1]

Considering it's implied that every vinsmoke is still weaker than Sanji, due to them resorting to dirty tactics to get the advantage over him, I'd say Law, who ought to be somewhat stronger than Sanji via scalling, can at least get two of them without too much problems. Zoro is restricted to base, but considering Sanji had to use little more than his Diable Jamble to be a threat to his brothers and didn't resort to Hell's Memories, which so far seems to be his most powerful attack, it's likely Zoro won't be needing Ashura to get rid of one of them here, so I'm inclined to say the Zoro + Law team takes this without too much problems even with their restrictions.

Zoro (post Archipelago Sabaody, assuming his injuries were totally healed) vs Leopard Lucci

--> Zoro was at a considerable disadvantage against Lucci back at Ennies Lobby arc, but considering the statement that the Straw Hats get stronger upon overcoming the challenges in the islands they adventure and that Zoro was the Straw Hat that got through the most problematic injury of them all (against Kuma), is a now full-healed Zoro enough to take out Lucci? I always found this a cool battle to especulate about.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

I'd say Zoro ought to take this with Asura given the injuries he sustained on Thriller Bark should yield a great increase. Lucci would win if he manages to land a Rokugan though.

Franky Shogun VS Base Luffy (post-timeskip)

 

[ahill1]

Can't exactly remember a feat from Franky Shogun which gives us an idea of his general standing, but considering base Franky ought to be already on a Pacifista's level and that Luffy had to use Gear Second to one-shot one, I'd say Franky Shogun has got this.

Jimbei vs Vergo

 

[Captain Cadaver]

I'd say Vergo ought to win. The Wadatsumi fight seemed to imply that Jimbei and Sanji aren't too far apart, perhaps even Hell's Memories being slightly above him, yet Sanji was almost low/mid-diffed by Vergo. Unless Fishman Karate can bypass full body Haki or the fight takes place near water, Vergo's definitely taking this.

Current Base Luffy VS G2 Luffy (Fishman Island Arc)

 

[Diamond Ryan]

Current Luffy takes it easily imo. G2 Luffy likely holds the edge still in regards to speed and power, but Current Luffy has an incredible advantage in the form of future sight, which means he could Dodge his past counterpart all day and attack where he is going to dodge. Not to mention, G2 Luffy is going to burn through stamina far faster than Current Luffy.

Overall, a mid diff fight for Current Luffy, if only because Luffy is tough to put down with punches alone.

Zoro, Sanji, and Law vs. Katakuri

Neither party has any knowledge of the other's abilities.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Purely depends on whether or not Katakuri's precog would inform him on Law's Gamma Knife. If so, Katakuri wins with mid-diff at most. If it doesn't, seeing as how he wasn't given caution on several of Luffy's attacks, then the trio win as Katakuri won't be able to just rearrange his intestines like Doffy.

Enel VS Base Kaku
- Enel has all his DF abilities restricted, but can still use Mantra fine.
- Fight takes place at Enies Lobby.