XXX vs XXX One Piece Edition

[Diamond Ryan]

I don't see Enel breaking Kaku's Tekkai with his basic attacks, meanwhile Shigan and Rankyaku are both fairly lethal techniques that could end the fight quickly, and adding Soru and Geppo serves to give Kaku far greater speed + mobility. Enel's CoO will only serve to delay his inevitable loss.

Enel vs. 2 Pacifistas
- Enel can be harmed by attacks, but other than that has full usage of his DF
- Fight is at Sabaody, starting distance is 50m

 

[ahill1]

Well, considering Zoro and Whiper weren't one shotted by Eneru's attacks, not even the El Thor accomplishing such, I don't see Eneru's attacks easily working against an enemy to which all the monster trio special attacks had to be used against... on the other hand, Eneru could be injured by basic attacks from Skypiea Luffy, which proves his durability isn't all that, so I think a simple Kizaru-esque beam would be already enough to seriously injure or take out Eneru. One Pacifista should be able to bring Eneru down imo.

Zoro (post TS) vs Ace (at his peak before dying)

 

[Pocket-God]

I honestly have no idea how strong Ace was at his strongest but based on the little we saw of him I'd think that Zoro could probably win more often than not.

CP9 vs A Pacifista

The CP9 members start in base but can transform if needed.
Battle takes place on thriller bark.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

The top 3 CP9 members are still inferior to the Monster Trio's peak power during the same arc, who even after they got stronger from their later battles (or at least Luffy and Zoro would have), they still barely managed to beat a Pacifista. Granted, Luffy only used G3 as the finisher and Zoro was wounded, but the principal's the same, not to mention CP9's abilities being somewhat less varied than the Straw Hats' and the Pacifista would have data on them. Pacifista wins with high-diff.

Buggy runs the East Blue Gauntlet

Kuro
Don Krieg
Arlong
Alvida (post-DF)

Strength/speed stats equalised and no intel. Fight takes place at Arlong Park.

 

[Pocket-God]

So can Kuro still boost his speed or nah? Well either way I can't see him beating buggy when his main way of attacking is just slashing. So Buggy probably wins this round easily.

Is this proper Don Krieg or 4Kids Don Krieg? 4kids Don Krieg would win with his poison suction cups. 2
Anyway I think I'd still go with Don Krieg thanks to his larger variety in the weaponry department.

So he stops at 2

----

The Supernovas (pre-ts) vs 2 Pacifistas and Sentomaru

The Supernovas have agreed to work together.
If it's a stomp in team 2's favor then make it 1 Pacifista and Sentomaru

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Considering the only Supernova tier Straw Hats who fought against the Pacifista whilst still being in peak condition was Luffy (maybe Sanji as well) and an injured Ashura Zoro was still able to deal damage to one, I'd say the Supernovas definitely beat one of them. They could probably manage two as well, though Sentomaru would be more of a challenge after most of them would be fatigued. Luckily, Bonney would grant them the win by turning him into a child with an off-guard attack from hiding throughout most of the battle.

CP0 Lucci and Kaku VS Current Law
- Assume Lucci's feats in Film Gold are canon and Kaku made comparable gains from the timeskip. Both have intel on Law's DF.
- If Law loses, have Current Gear 2nd Luffy assist him.

 

[Pocket-God]

CP0 Lucci was comparable to Sabo iirc, I feel like if that's the case Lucci might be able to win on his own so adding Kaku ensures his win. I don't think Luffy is going to make that big of a difference unless he creates an opening for Law to use Gamma Knife. Still I'd go with Lucci and Kaku more often than not.

Bartolomeo and Cavendish vs the straw hats.

Round 1: Chopper and Robin
Round 2: Brook and Franky
Round 3: Sanji, Nami and Ussop
Round 4: Zoro
Round 5: Luffy

Dressrosa versions for everyone.
Luffy can't use gear 4th.
If Barto and Cabbage lose then replace Cabbage with Hakuba, Hakuba won't attack Barto.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

They stomp the first 2 rounds, and probably win Round 3 considering Cavendish traded blows with Chinjao as well as Gear 2nd Luffy did. They win Round 4 only if Zoro's restricted to his base form though even if getting Round 5 or including Hakuba, they're not besting Gear 3rd Luffy.

Current Gear 4th Luffy VS Marco
- Luffy has no stamina issues.

 

[Papasmurf]

I'd probably say Marco, since he can regenerate and he has to be pulling his weight as the new interim captain of the Whitebeard Pirates crew somehow.

Alabasta Crocodile vs. post-timeskip Nami

Nami knows of Crocodile's water/blood weakness.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Unless treating it as PIS, Nami ought to have far greater reactions on account of her Enies Lobby self having dodged attacks from Kalifa who in turn could dodge her clima tact lightning at point blank range. She blitzes and then oneshots with the clima tact. Prepping with a water attack wouldn't even be necessary, considering lightning can obliterate even grains of sand.

Don Krieg VS Wapol
- Krieg can't use MH5.

 

[ahill1]

Probably Wapol. Luffy was considerably stronger when battling him, and it isn't like Krieg was that much troublesome to Luffy barring his MH5. Wapol has also defeated Dalton easily, someone with a Zoan and good feats for the East Blue arc. His thin form also ought to pack an impressive power to East Blue, I'd say.

As a side note, no way Cavendish stands up to Sanji, I'd say. Not a chance.

Sabo vs Marco

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Marco wins. He performed as well against Aokiji or Kizaru as Sabo did against Fujitora and has the added benefit of having some level of regen.

Current Buggy & Galdino VS CP9 Lucci
- Buggy is aware of Lucci's power. His plan is for Galdino to distract Lucci with Candle Wall and then hit him with a Muggy Ball. Buggy has 3 Muggy Balls and Galdino has armed himself within his Candle Champion.
- Lucci is aware of Buggy's reputation and is starting the fight in his Leopard Hybrid form.

 

[ahill1]

The Muggy Ball impressed Luffy, but is it enough to KO Lucci? I don't think so. Lucci withstood a G3 attack and with his cunningness and cautiouness, as well as possessing meaningful abilities as the Moon wall that could be used to counter Mr. 2's wall, he would get this.

Mihawk vs Aokiji

Pre TS

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Mihawk is likely the stronger of the two, given his hype of having fought with Shanks or being the world's strongest swordsman whilst also being brought up by Oda in SBS statements about the strongest characters. Aokiji's ice would prove troublesome, however, and if Aokiji can avoid being fatally wounded by Whitebeard, he can avoid Mihawk landing a fatal wound and probably outlast him.

Yama VS Mr. 4

 

[Fantastische Hure]

I don't know that sadly but some-one else could maybe answer that. I didn't know this is where the vs. gets posted. I have a match I want to know:

Current Coby vs Luffy (beginning of series)

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Koby stomps. Even if chalking him causing Luffy to cough up blood as being due to his injuries against Lucci, he still caught post-Enies Lobby Luffy off-guard and was able to recover from a punch from his Marineford self. His current self is likely far stronger than pre-timeskip given he'd likely have been taught to control his Haki and his current status and stationing in the New World (at least in anime material), likely make him comparable to Current Tashigi.

Same matchup as I posted prior.

 

[ahill1]

@FH

We haven't seen anything from current Coby, but considering Marineford Coby had already the first signs of the Observation Haki, with Coby from post Ennies Loby already employing Soru, a technique that really impressed Water 7 Luffy by its sheer speed, he should be easily defeating beginning of OP Luffy, imo. To add in, Coby has also endured a Jet Bullet from Marineford Luffy and was relatively fine afterwards, an impactful feat in comparison to East Blue arc, for sure.

@CC

We haven't seen much from Yama besides jobbering to Robin. Mr. 4 was said to be stronger physically than Mr. 3, but seemed pretty stupid from the looks of it and he couldn't take Usopp down with his attacks. Being also physically strong apparently, and facing Robin in a subsequent arc, I'd say that Yama should get this.


Usopp (post TS) vs Zoro (pre TS, Thriller Bark)

 

[Captain Cadaver]

With all his weaponry, Usopp wins considering he was able to tag Caesar and beat Baby 5 (albeit, after Franky had softened him up). Without weapons, he lacks major feats to place him on the same level as post-Enies Lobby Zoro.

Prime Rayleigh VS Kizaru & Akainu

 

[ahill1]

Rayleigh stated that he has gotten old when he couldn't do more than stalemating Kizaru, implying his prime self was above Kizaru at least. Still, I'd say he lacks major implications to say he could defeat both at the same time, with the magma and light being a powerful combo, as in, packing huge speed and destructive power.

Pedro vs Kyros

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Kyros needed some effort to take down Diamante who ought to be more or less equal to Pica, and Zoro's short scuffle with Carrot seemed to require more effort than stomping Pica, with Pedro being above her based on status alone. Pedro takes this with mid or high-diff.

Current Sanji VS Gear 2nd Luffy (Fishman Island Arc)
- Sanji can't use Hell's Memories.