XXX vs XXX

[Captain Cadaver]

2 Gokus likely take it through their superior skill that would make it even more difficult for Gohan to fight 2 V 1.

LSSJ Broly (Budokai 3) VS Base Rild
- In Goku/Vegeta's story mode, they cite the evil Ki they sense (Broly) to be stronger than Boo's.
- Fight takes place on New Planet Vegeta.

 

[Papasmurf]

Depends whether Budokai 3 runs on manga logic for Kid Boo's power (outside of God ki ) or the anime's. If it's the manga and they're referring to the newly formed Kid Boo, then Rild stomps. If it's the anime version and Kid Boo > Gohan Boo, then Rild still probably wins because Broly is so arrogant that he let Galu get a free Kamehameha on him and will probably be turned to metal.

Meta-Rild vs. SSJ Gohan (Super 17 arc)

If Gohan loses, make it SSJ2 Gohan, but on Planet M2.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Assuming we're talking about Rild's final form (considering the terminology of his forms gets very complicated depending on the source), then Rild wins. He was more or less on par with SSJ Goku despite Base Galu being able to hold a noticeable lead on him, whereas Base Gohan was at best just able to hold his own against Base Rild. SS2 Gohan would stomp him before Rild could use M2's power in any sort of game-changing way though.

Anime Mr. Satan VS General White

 

[Papasmurf]

Probably Satan, unless you go by White > Silver due to outranking him.

Base Vegetto (Evil Dragons arc) vs. SSJ4 Galu and Vegeta (same arc)

Assume that Gogeta and Vegetto's base-SSJ4 gap is about the same as the middle ground between Galu and Vegeta's gaps for said forms.

 

[SIAD]

I have Vegetto Base would be at the level of Gogeta SSJ3 of that Arc. Therefore Vegetto Base wins.

2 Teen Gohan SSJ2 vs Vegeta SSJ2 (Pre Majin)?

If Gohan wins, then is it 3 Teen Gohan SSJ2 vs 2 Vegeta SSJ2 (Pre Majin)?

 

[Animelover5487]

2 SSJ2 Gohans beat Pre-Majin Vegeta. Still going with Gohan on the 3 vs 2 scenario.

Pre-Korin Tower Yajirobe vs Tambourine

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Yajirobe fought evenly with the same Goku capable of stomping Tambourine, something backed up by official sources such as his bio entry in Kakarot, so he wins with no difficulty. His reaction wouldn't seem to denote Goku could do the same to him when it seemed to revolve more around the merciless nature of Goku's assault on Tambourine rather than a power statement.

Za Preecho (the ToP Cell lookalike) VS Base Goku and Vegeta (ToP)
- Manga versions of all.

 

[Animelover5487]

Goku and Vegeta as there as no context on Za Preecho's fight with Cabba, we don't even know if he had to use Super Saiyan.

Hakaishim Toppo vs Current UI Goku

- Manga scaling

- Toppo gets the same boost as his anime counterpart

 

[Captain Cadaver]

The boost in the anime was around 20x or so via scaling from Goku's Kaioken and initial SSBE Vegeta, so Toppo oneshots.

Buyon VS BoDB Goku
- Buyon's elasticity is taken away, with his durability only being equal to his attack power.

 

[Animelover5487]

Buyon one shots. Goku struggled to get out of his jaws and I doubt Goku lost that much strength at that point.

General White vs Manwolf

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Difficult to say. White endured a hit from a very fatigued Goku, but how that Goku compared to his BoDB self is vague when he was KO'd by a pistol far superior to normal ones. Meanwhile, Man-Wolf's best feat was his proclamation of being a 30th Dan in Kenpo, which is pretty vague beyond being above regular human limits and it's not as though we have any indication of how strong the fodder he beat in the prelims were. I'd probably give it to White given his rank within the RRA and confidence in beating a fatigued Goku despite what the latter could do at full strength making it very much a stretch he was brought down to the level of regular martial artists.

Anime Chichi VS Prime Piccolo Daimao

 

[Animelover5487]

Daimao wins since she couldn't follow Weighted Goku's speed and Ten still says in the anime that Goku hasn't become much faster.

Post-Korin Tower Climbs Yajirobe vs Drum

 

[Captain Cadaver]

I wouldn't doubt Yajirobe got a significant boost when considering he has enough potential to be so strong from what was essentially BoDB Goku's lifestyle and almost hit 1k without putting in even half the effort of his peers, though I doubt one climb up the tower would be enough for him to have surpassed someone capable of blitzing and stomping Tenshinhan when Yajirobe's prior self was at best not too much stronger than the latter. He might be close enough to at least put up a fight though.

Fatigued Jiren (no resolve boost) VS ToP Piccolo
- Manga versions of both.

 

[Animelover5487]

Jiren wins. I think Piccolo is closer to Base Goku/Vegeta than their SSJ forms.

23rd Chaozu vs ~50% Old Daimao

- If Chaozu wins, make it full power Old Daimao

 

[Captain Cadaver]

I'd probably say Chaozu barely wins against less than 50% Daimao, but gets stomped by 100%. I can't imagine him being too irrelevant when considering he wasn't a complete ant to the other Earthlings 3 years prior.

Post-Choshinsui 22nd TB Kuririn VS 100% Old Piccolo Daimao

 

[Papasmurf]

I think Choshinsui's potential unlock stacks on your current power level (just like how Rou Dai Kaioshin said that his Ultimate unlock should bring someone who pulled out the Z Sword to the level of the universe's mightiest), so since Kuririn is weaker than Match LeveL Galu, Kuririn gets stomped like a black guy being lynched during Jim Crow

Choshinsui Super Oob vs. San Xing Long

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Considering the Choshinsui is so limited compared to other potential unlocks it at best brought Galu's Ki into the 200 range and Karin made it apparent it not even providing a boost at all was a genuine possibility (not to mention the Z and GT anime not even treating it as any more than a cure for possession), it probably wouldn't boost Oob in the slightest. Taking Super logic for Boo's gains into account though, even just drinking this rancid supplement would probably be enough for Oob to oneshot if shooting clay pigeons is enough to boost his other half to Universe level in an afternoon 2.

Base Garlic Jr. (Filler) VS FP 2nd form Freeza
- No immortality/regeneration.

 

[Papasmurf]

The Choshinsui they sprayed on the Earth was only exposed to those Earthlings in trace amounts though, while you needed to take a full glass of it to unlock your hidden power. Not much of a fair comparison.


As for the matchup... Don't remember much from the Garlic Jr. arc since I haven't watched it in its entirety since the Toonami days, but I would guess 2nd form Freeza because the giant form boost seemed considerable in the 1st DBZ movie and even as a giant, Piccolo was able to outspeed and match him.

SSJ4 Goten vs. Super Yi

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Probably Yi Xing Long. Vegeta said the half-Saiyans could defeat Yi through training, but never specified they could do so 1 V 1.

Post-Zamasu Kibitoshin VS ToP SS3 Goku
- Manga versions of both.
- Assume Zamasu was fighting seriously against Kibito for this scenario.

 

[Papasmurf]

Depends whether has been indulging in some Kaioshit GODLY GAINZ training with Kibito. Based on him being one-shotted by a frivolous Zamasu, though, I'm not sure he is much stronger, and even if he is, he's probably not providing enough of a boost for Kibito to close the gap between himself and SSJ3 Galu (who is somewhat stronger than Zamasu who beat Kibito). If Kibitoshin can paralyze Galu he stomps though.

South Kaioshin (w/ Kibito's GODLY KAIOSHIT GAINZ) runs the Super gauntlet

Assuming he gets the same gainz that Kibito got after the Boo arc, how far does he get in Super (manga timeline)?