I'll reply to your arguments at a later point but as a side note I can understand why you would take issue with my comment. I do often say things without realizing how others may react to it so I'll restrain from doing that again. My fault.
I'm gonna keep it 100% with you ahill, I think you're actually a smart guy but you lack common sense. We've already explained to you why not everyone has a blade blade.
What are you arguing for?
Mihawk's sword isn't originally black, it became like that after years of training. He's not talking about simply reinforcing a blade with CoA temporarily.
I think it's a given they get stronger, even if it's not by a lot. Battle experience, adaptability, ect.
Hell, just read the latest DBS chapter and it's pretty much told to us, at least as far as what Toyotaro thinks of the matter.
It is possible to turn a blade permanent black by a master swordsman. Mihawk's Yoru and Ryuma's Shisui are such examples. Roger has not been able to do this.
Because to me if that were the case then Mihawk's title of ''World's Strongest Swordsmen'' means nothing if there are guys that only fight with swords can beat him.
But you are right that we don't know enough about Shanks' ability, so we'll see.
If both are fighters that purely rely on swordsmanship and Haki (Roger as far as we know has no DF), wouldn't the fact that Mihawk being able to turn his blade black while Roger couldn't mean that the former is the more powerful and skilled one?
Just wanted to add also that there's a theory that some of the CP0 members in Wano were the foster siblings of Big Mom as kids before she presumably ate them. Maybe they'll get involved with Big Mom in some way.
Depending on the purpose behind the Gomu Gomu no mi in the eyes of the WG, it’s not unlikely that they knew Shanks who stole the fruit was residing in East Blue for a long while and would give it to someone. How do we know for sure that CP-0 never paid a visit to the village while Luffy was with...