- Joined
- Dec 12, 2015
- Messages
- 6,149
- Age
- 22
He's not a prodigy in the sense that he has an innate biological advantage towards someone, like Freeza who never trained a day in his life but was still the threat he was on Namek.
Future Warrior said:He's not a prodigy in the sense that he has an innate biological advantage towards someone, like Freeza who never trained a day in his life but was still the threat he was on Namek.
The thing is, these are all different characters with varying methods of handling a situation. Cell wouldn't have seen a desire to train when the former believed he'd naturally become the perfect lifeform from purely what Gero provided to his programming, Piccolo was likely influenced by both his original self's desire for general improvement when wishing to become Earth's Kami (Piccolo noting Kami slacked off in his training) and the desire his current incarnation had to beat Goku before pursuing more pure reasons for training and Vegeta has the Saiyan instincts to grow stronger and an upbringing of being controlled by far stronger masters to motivate him. Moreover, Cell's initial characterisation is more in line with someone like Piccolo who was more than willing to play the waiting game, whereas Freeza is clearly far less patient or willing to wait with how he was more than willing to kill the Saiyans just on seeing the rise of Saiyans still far weaker than his top soldiers and summoned the Ginyus to Namek purely on an inkling of another Saiyan growing in power, not to mention heading to Earth immediately after being reconstructed without any sort of backup plan. Again, I don't like the whole idea of DBS characters just boosting themselves to whatever level the plot requires because "muh potential" but I wouldn't say the motivations of these villains act as a solid counter to Freeza's gains.Kenshi said:Plus, Cell had the patience to sit in a hole for 4 years just to regain his fighting form and Babidi scoured the universe for a decade just to attempt to revive Boo. Not a big stretch when other (former) villains like Piccolo and Vegeta trained basically their whole lives to pursue greater power. Freeza just being able to get like 4 million times stronger in 4 months makes Cell look like an absolute loser for not just training off-screen and even traveling across time just to reach levels below a newly attained SSJ2.
Captain Cadaver said:Goku is a prodigy from his experience rather than innate talent like Freeza, so Gohan is a far more comparable benchmark. Even then though, the fact that Gohan needed several years of training to approach the level of power Freeza was born with speaks volumes as to who truly had more innate talent. Using ToP Gohan as a counter isn't really an accurate comparison either when this was long after Rou-Dai Kaioshin had drawn him far beyond his natural limits. I don't like the idea of Freeza just reaching God level from 4 months of training either, though I still wouldn't say it's completely inconsistent for him to reach such levels in a limited time with the right type of training.
The thing is, these are all different characters with varying methods of handling a situation. Cell wouldn't have seen a desire to train when the former believed he'd naturally become the perfect lifeform from purely what Gero provided to his programming, Piccolo was likely influenced by both his original self's desire for general improvement when wishing to become Earth's Kami (Piccolo noting Kami slacked off in his training) and the desire his current incarnation had to beat Goku before pursuing more pure reasons for training and Vegeta has the Saiyan instincts to grow stronger and an upbringing of being controlled by far stronger masters to motivate him.Kenshi said:Plus, Cell had the patience to sit in a hole for 4 years just to regain his fighting form and Babidi scoured the universe for a decade just to attempt to revive Boo. Not a big stretch when other (former) villains like Piccolo and Vegeta trained basically their whole lives to pursue greater power. Freeza just being able to get like 4 million times stronger in 4 months makes Cell look like an absolute loser for not just training off-screen and even traveling across time just to reach levels below a newly attained SSJ2.
Moreover, Cell's initial characterisation is more in line with someone like Piccolo who was more than willing to play the waiting game, whereas Freeza is clearly far less patient or willing to wait with how he was more than willing to kill the Saiyans just on seeing the rise of Saiyans still far weaker than his top soldiers and summoned the Ginyus to Namek purely on an inkling of another Saiyan growing in power, not to mention heading to Earth immediately after being reconstructed without any sort of backup plan. Again, I don't like the whole idea of DBS characters just boosting themselves to whatever level the plot requires because "muh potential" but I wouldn't say the motivations of these villains act as a solid counter to Freeza's gains.
Future Warrior said:I don't know how you can compare Cell to someone like Freeza who was literally bloodthirsty for revenge. He would most certainly not sit in an empty void for 40 years thinking of it either. I think you're blowing it way out of proportion here.
Future Warrior said:We'll just have to agree to disagree then. Either way, I don't even think you would have to go as far as to say Freeza needs 40 years to achieve the power he did. That just sounds excessive. 4 months might be too short, sure, but there's also a case of too much.
Kenshi said:but is certainly less of a cop out than muh prodigious latent potential.Future Warrior said:We'll just have to agree to disagree then. Either way, I don't even think you would have to go as far as to say Freeza needs 40 years to achieve the power he did. That just sounds excessive. 4 months might be too short, sure, but there's also a case of too much.
The most talented Earthlings still seem to cap out from similar training and benefits far earlier than regular Saiyans do though, nevermind the far more talented Saiyan-Earthling hybrids.Kenshi said:The side characters in the ToP comment that Gohan is a natural well of talent when they see how much progress he made in such limited time, though. The narrative of DBS in general (Vegeta stating Gohan has the most potential even with their SSJB forms being taken into account and such) implies Gohan is just that talented. Even if say Tenshinhan got the Ultimate unlock he would never make such progress, and he's still one of the most talented Earthlings.
Both versions of Cell had been told by the computer that achieving their perfect form would grant them the ultimate power rather than training and had no necessity to go back in time initially when the Cell we know was, and his Future self believed himself to be, unchallenged in their timeline anyway.Both the main incarnation of Cell and the one killed by Future Trunks immediately resorted to time travel to absorb the cyborgs rather than make any attempt at self-improvement, even though they know for a fact that everything Galu or Trunks achieved was through their own hard work.
Not necessarily. Information unknown to the characters at the time doesn't damage the narrative at that time, and it's not as though Cell had an opportunity to freely go train until he achieved perfection; at which point he'd believed himself to have already gained the ultimate power.If Cell could just use his Freeza genes to get to God tier in a few months as well, that makes the entire narrative of the Cell/artificial humans arc beyond laughable.
The Mafuba Gaeshi isn't exactly something he could do inside a Denshi Jar and not something he'd get time to do when regaining his youth was the imperative, nor did he even expect anyone who had mastered it to still be alive in this era with how shocked he was at Roshi's reveal. Kami and Popo were irrelevant to his goals as he knew full well they wouldn't kill him for obvious reasons.Plus, Piccolo Daimao made no attempt to train to learn the Mafuuba Gaeshi or to surpass Kami and Popo, making it doubtful that Piccolo's desire for self-improvement is one innate to Kami's pre-split qualities.
Captain Cadaver said:The most talented Earthlings still seem to cap out from similar training and benefits far earlier than regular Saiyans do though, nevermind the far more talented Saiyan-Earthling hybrids.Kenshi said:The side characters in the ToP comment that Gohan is a natural well of talent when they see how much progress he made in such limited time, though. The narrative of DBS in general (Vegeta stating Gohan has the most potential even with their SSJB forms being taken into account and such) implies Gohan is just that talented. Even if say Tenshinhan got the Ultimate unlock he would never make such progress, and he's still one of the most talented Earthlings.
Both versions of Cell had been told by the computer that achieving their perfect form would grant them the ultimate power rather than training and had no necessity to go back in time initially when the Cell we know was, and his Future self believed himself to be, unchallenged in their timeline anyway.Both the main incarnation of Cell and the one killed by Future Trunks immediately resorted to time travel to absorb the cyborgs rather than make any attempt at self-improvement, even though they know for a fact that everything Galu or Trunks achieved was through their own hard work.
Not necessarily. Information unknown to the characters at the time doesn't damage the narrative at that time, and it's not as though Cell had an opportunity to freely go train until he achieved perfection; at which point he'd believed himself to have already gained the ultimate power.If Cell could just use his Freeza genes to get to God tier in a few months as well, that makes the entire narrative of the Cell/artificial humans arc beyond laughable.
He couldn't do it inside the Denshi Jar, but he clearly feared it so much that he freaked out at Galu merely pointing his hands towards him because he mistook it for the Mafuuba. When Roshi actually used the real thing, he literally tried to fly away. On top of this, Daimao didn't even fix his other major weakness, the fact that his full power shortens his life (which isn't even seen with 100% Freeza). Why this happens is anyone's guess (such as him being an imperfect Namekian due to the split), but the point is that in the years that he was free, he never attempted to remedy this issue. Daimao isn't the self improvement type, but Piccolo Jr. who has his exact same memories trained for 9 years straight after his birth until facing Nappa and had no complaints about resorting to training his nemesis' child to protect the Earth despite still being a villain. Piccolo became so diligent out of necessity, not because Daimao/Kami were naturally the self-improvement type.The Mafuba Gaeshi isn't exactly something he could do inside a Denshi Jar and not something he'd get time to do when regaining his youth was the imperative, nor did he even expect anyone who had mastered it to still be alive in this era with how shocked he was at Roshi's reveal. Kami and Popo were irrelevant to his goals as he knew full well they wouldn't kill him for obvious reasons.Plus, Piccolo Daimao made no attempt to train to learn the Mafuuba Gaeshi or to surpass Kami and Popo, making it doubtful that Piccolo's desire for self-improvement is one innate to Kami's pre-split qualities.
Future Warrior said:Kenshi said:but is certainly less of a cop out than muh prodigious latent potential.Future Warrior said:We'll just have to agree to disagree then. Either way, I don't even think you would have to go as far as to say Freeza needs 40 years to achieve the power he did. That just sounds excessive. 4 months might be too short, sure, but there's also a case of too much.
Freeza has a godly amount of potential. That is an objective fact. It's clearly not normal for someone who never trained a day in his life to completely shit on multiple skilled martial art Saiyans and Namekians who've spend their whole lives pushing themselves.
Him taking 40 years to accomplish that power removes that aspect. Goku complimented Freeza on him catching up to him in the short amount of time despite all the hardships he's faced. Again, I think about 3-5 years is suitable to get that message across.
It's almost like the 4 months bit gave you some kind of PTSD lol.
Future Warrior said:We know nothing about the history of Beerus before he was recruited as a Hakaishin and how he came to reach such power, so let's not get ahead of ourselves.
But you are saying that a few decades is too long for his training, even though as I've proven above Beerus has been training longer, and probably achieved power greater than SSJ3 BoG Vegetto even before becoming a god judging by Whis offering Galu the job only after he gave Beerus a decent fight as SSJG.You're acting like I disagree with the premise of your argument lol. I never once tried to justify that 4 months of training would allow Freeza to reach God tier.
Future Warrior said:Then that just proves Beerus just isn't as talented as you think he is, if a mortal like Goku was able to get a better grasp of UI than he did. Goku with also 40 years of training was enough to be a Hakaishin candidate, but it's already established that he's isn't quite as gifted as you thought.
It's not useless information because Cell had more power at birth, Boo had more power at birth and they still acted like going to great lengths to absorb other people was the greatest way to gain power, which is made laughable by the prospect of Freeza training for 120 days to completely dwarf any power they ever achieved.You started typing multiple paragraphs worth of useless information such as how strong Cell and Boo can get in 10 days or whatever as if it had any relevance to what I was saying. My point is that Freeza training for 40 years to get to the level of Goku (who is about 40 yrs old) does not do favors for his natural talent if it takes him the same amount of time to get there. I think if the movie gave him a bit more time (a few years) and gave better detail on exactly the kind of training regimen he went through, then there's no issue imo.
Kenshi said:The fact that Beerus was shown to tool Champa with ease despite them having been evenly matched at some point shows that Beerus has kept up his training much more than some of the other Hakaishin.
Future Warrior said:Kenshi said:The fact that Beerus was shown to tool Champa with ease despite them having been evenly matched at some point shows that Beerus has kept up his training much more than some of the other Hakaishin.
When exactly did Beerus ''tool'' Champa?