XXX vs XXX One Piece Edition

[Pocket-God]

Pretty much the same as http://www.dbzeta.net/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=2945 except of course the focus will be on One Piece characters as opposed to DBZ characters. Let's begin.

Sanji (Little Garden) vs Mr. 5 and Mr. 3

 

[SSJ2]

I don't think he could win. Didn't Mr. 3's wax give Luffy some trouble, or am I remembering incorrectly?

Ace and Blackbeard (pre fruit) vs Jack

 

[Pocket-God]

((Yeah, the wax was troublesome, Luffy couldn't break it, but I'd say Sanji could win as long as he doesn't get hit by Candle Lock))

I'm really not sure honestly, I need a feat or something to show that the Dog Guy and Cat guy are actually strong, otherwise imo Jack seems rather weak, I'll give it to Ace and Blackbeard for now.

Current Brook vs Zoro pre-skip

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Considering the general average of New World Pirates, Brook stomps. His ice techniques and hypnotism are also too hax for Zoro to counter.

Lucci (Film Gold) VS Burgess
- Lucci starts out in his Leopard Hybrid form
- Both have intel on each other's abilities.

 

[Pocket-God]

Honestly, despite not seeing Lucci's fight against Sabo and not knowing if they were actually fighting or just screwing around I'd still vote for the former since Burgess couldn't really do anything against Sabo.

Sanji (Enies Lobby) vs Kaku

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Likely Kaku with extreme diff. I don't think Sanji would be able to get close when Kaku uses his ultimate Rankyaku technique, even with Diable Jambe.

Hajrudin VS Franky
- No Shogun or Radical Beam for Franky.

 

[Pocket-God]

I'd say Franky 7/10, Hajrudin's only chance at winning is if he sends Franky flying with Gungnir. I mean, Franky > Machvise and Machvise was pretty much stomping the giant.

Gekko Moriah vs Pre-Skip Law and Kid

-Battle takes place on Thriller Bark.
-Gekko starts in base but has access to shadow asgard if needed.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

In terms of pure power, I'd place Base Moria above either, though Law's hax is easily enough to take the win, assuming he doesn't give Moria the chance to access Shadow Asgard or if so, avoids being hit by it. A single hit from Asgard Moria would oneshot either.

Part 2 Nami VS Kuroobi
- Nami only has access to a normal pole as a weapon.

 

[Symbiote]

If it's just a normal pole then I'll give it to Kuroobi since she literally has nothing else going for her.

Alabasta Crocodile vs Part 2 Ussopp.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

She's got a lot more going for her in terms of strength. She easily blocked an attack from a Fishman, plus Sanji was able to still use Blue Walk somewhat effectively in her body.

All depends on the situation of battle. Does Usopp have prep? Do they start out close to eachother? In a normal close range fight, Usopp would lose hard due to not having Haki or much time to come up with a plan. If Usopp starts the battle out the way he wants to, he should win when considering he was able to aid in taking down Baby 5 & Buffalo, plus it seems as though he has Kairoseki cuffs in his inventory based on him capturing Caesar.
I'm not sure if this is fake, since I haven't bothered to check the entirety of Part 2's SBS, but it seems to be a common rumour that Oda stated Part 2 Usopp's strength is on par with Part 1 Zoro's. If that's more than just a fan rumour, then Usopp stomps once he negates Croc's intangibility.

Ace (Marineford) VS Gear 3rd Luffy (Dressrosa)

 

[xmysticgohanx]

Probably Ace, non G4 Luffy is pretty bad. We can see that from the Cracker fight and when Fujitora decides to use his fruit. Ace is weird to rank though

Vista vs Cracker

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Cracker. Not sure who has stronger Haki, considering the accuracy of the implication that Cracker's Haki > Doflamingo's is very debatable, however, his DF would be near impossible for a swordsman like Vista to counter. If things turn into a war of attrition, Vista would stand no chance.

Asura Zoro (Sabaody) VS Leopard Hybrid Lucci (Pre-Timeskip)
- Zoro can handle Asura as naturally as his regular power in this scenario.
- Zoro isn't wounded like he was in the arc.
- Lucci can use up to 2 Rokuogun if he finds an opportunity.

 

[xmysticgohanx]

I have Zoro going back to Luffy's level in Thriller Bark so Zoro

Jinbe vs Sanji. On land

 

[Pocket-God]

I think Sanji could take this, it won't in any way be easy though.

Doffy vs Current Zoro, Sanji and Hakuba

-No awakening or Parasite string for Doffy
-Hakuba won't attack Sanji or Zoro

 

[xmysticgohanx]

No awakening and parasite is huge. Doffy would win this battle with either. I honestly think full power Zoro can win alone here but even if he can't Sanji and Hakuba def make up for it.

Hakuba vs Kyros

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Cavendish blocking Chinjao's strike was a lot more impressive than anything Kyros showed imo, so Hakuba low diffs.

Magellan VS Ace
- No Devil Fruit/Haki abilities for either.

 

[ahill1]

Ace surely seems like the best fighter to me. Seeing as Haki isn't allowed, then it would come down for a hand to hand combat skills, to which Ace wins.

Law (post Time-Skip) vs Ace (at his peak before dying)

 

[Captain Cadaver]

I'd place Law as slightly superior in terms of power, with his DF hax allowing him to low diff as long as Ace isn't prepared for it. Op Op Fruit is too OP for most matchups that aren't against those bordering Admiral tier or above.

Hannyabal VS Base Zoro (Thriller Bark)

 

[Pocket-God]

If Hannyabal wasn't at least as strong as TB Zoro I couldn't imagine him taking the eating he did and surviving however while he does seem to have the durability he doesn't seem to have much fighting skill so I';d give the match to Zoro more often than not.

Current Sanji vs Current Brook

-Sanji is wearing the Newkama fighting outfit
-Brook wants to see Sanji's panties

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Brook manages to see his panties, but his soul gets torn to pieces when discovering he's fallen into a trap.

Base Sengoku (Marineford) VS Jozu