XXX vs XXX One Piece Edition

[ahill1]

If Sanji can't use his strongest attack, then I'd say they are pretty much evened out here, with their feats seemingly pointing to a similarity in power. I'd say Luffy takes this at equal firepower given he has shown more in the resilience field, plus he seems to pack more deadly combos like the Hawk Bazooka, which seemed to worry Doflamingo somewhat (see his face when Luffy launches this attack upon him after his Gear Third got blocked by the Kumo no Sugaki).

Kaido and Big Mom vs Shanks and Whitebeard

Shanks currently and WB just like he was at Marineford. Kaido and Big Mom are both current.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

The Shanks-WB combo likely has the power advantage with WB still holding the title of world's strongest man until his death and Big Mam being the least impressive Yonko feat-wise, though her soul manipulation hax would be the most difficult ability to get around in the fight. I'd say the Kaido-Big Mam team win with extreme-diff due to Big Mam's hax and Kaido's durability trumping WB's stamina issues.

Dorry and Broggy VS CP9 Arc Base Zoro

 

[ahill1]

Tough to say. Zoro could already tangle with an opponent considerably stronger than Alabasta Luffy. Meanwhile, Dorry and Broggy were individually stronger than Luffy at that point, emphasized by everyone's surprise at their feat of opening up the way to the crew after the ordeal in the island, with Luffy only managing to wound Dorry due to him being injured by Mr. 3. I'd give Dorry and Broggy the benefit of the doubt and say that them working together could take out that Zoro. Their strength sparking Luffy and Usopp's interest in going to Elbaf ought to account for something as well.

Current Franky vs a Pacifista

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Franky wins. His upgrades and use of Vegapunk's technology, he ought to essentially be a Pacifista with free thought now. Couple this with him being able to hold his own or even defeat high ranked executives of the Donquixote family when one such as Gladion was able to give Base/Gear 2nd Luffy some difficulty and (for what it's worth) the tv special leading up to Film Gold presenting his base self as rivalling Base Luffy's strength (who ought to not be much different to Base Sanji who broke a Pacifista's neck) and Franky has shown all it takes to win, a stomp if he's allowed to use the Shogun.

Zephyr VS Doflamingo
- Assume Z's loss to Luffy in Film Z was due to poor durability/stamina akin to WB's health issues rather than Toei PIS.
- Doflamingo can't use Awakening.

 

[ahill1]

Well, if we assume that, then Zephyr, being a former admiral, would have what it takes to defeat Doflamingo, who shouldn't be at that level.

Katakuri vs Nekomamushi

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Katakuri wins. Jack doesn't seem to be too impressive compared to the best of the Yonko Fleet Commanders like Katakuri and Marco, yet was still able to fight Nekomamushi and Inuarashi in turn without a break, and with just raw strength on his side. Katakuri has top tier Kenbunshoku Haki and a tricky DF to deal with, and Nekomamushi hasn't presented any special abilities to help him with them. If it's a Sulong Nekomamushi though, he'd win via-scaling if he can beat Katakuri in time.

Wiper's Reject Dial VS Pre-Timeskip Lucci's Rokuogan

 

[Pocket-God]

I'd go with Wiper's Reject Dial, it seemed more impressive. At least I think it did, I could be remembering wrong but oh well.

Judge and his five kids (all wearing raid suits) vs Fujitora

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Even in her Raid Suit, Reiju could only prove some slight difficulty to Smoothie and, aside from bounty hype, she hasn't really presented any feats to place her close to the likes of Marco and her brothers and father are less impressive, Ichiji not managing to significantly damage Perospero and Judge being weaker than him via-scaling. Couple in gravity hax, and Fujitora stomps.

50% Big Mom VS Current Gear 4th Luffy

 

[ahill1]

Tough to say with accurace, but considering G4 Luffy was soundly one-shotted by Kaido, the same Kaido that couldn't edge out Big Mom without a long drawn out battle, I'd say Big Mom takes it. A 2x gap mignt be enough to accomplish that considering how big it seems to be in other stories, but considering a G2 Luffy couldn't impressively one-shot Blueno when holding a multi-fold gap when going by the kiri scaling, I'd say it takes more than that to show the level of superiority Big Mom would have over Luffy. Big Mom wins.

Current Zoro and Sanji vs Doflamingo

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Hard to say. Zoro should be stronger than he's shown thus far as he hasn't had to use Asura or any new ultimate technique, though saying by how much compared to his base self right now would be pure conjecture. In any case, his peak would probably be at best between Gear 3rd and 4th Luffy at Dressrosa and using a sword he has yet to master would do more harm than good atm. Meanwhile, Raid Suit Sanji won't be the best support when he ought to still be significantly below Raid Suit Ichiji who couldn't deal significant damage to Perospero. With all that said, until some more substantial feats, the best the duo can do is force Doffy to use his awakening.

Kalifa VS Arlong
- Arlong has no intel on Kalifa's Rokushiki or DF and both are going for the kill.

 

[Pocket-God]

Kalifa probably out stats him in everything outside of strength imo. Arlong ends up getting bubbled.

Base Lucci vs Sanji, Zoro and Franky.

-Water 7 versions of everyone
-If Lucci loses then do a round 2 where he can transform

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Lucci loses round 1 if this is at the start of Water 7 before the Straw Hats' power became affected by their mindset, considering after that even Blueno could fight on Base Luffy's level. In Round 2 and assuming no mindset problems, he solos when considering Zoro implied he could kill all the Straw Hats sans Luffy's Gears.

Raid Suit Sanji VS Current Base Zoro
- Zoro is aware of the suit's invisibility.

 

[ahill1]

I'd give it to Sanji. I don't have a big gap even between their post timeskip selves and Sanji's upgrade with the suit ought to force Zoro to use more than just his base imo.

Zoro (power healed post archipelago sabaody) vs Lucci

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Considering his durability in Thriller Bark and the decent superficial damage his damaged Asura self did to the Pacifista, I'd say a fully healed Asura Ichibugin Zoro ought to beat Lucci, perhaps even enduring the Rokuogan.

Calgara VS Gear 2nd Luffy (Enies Lobby)
- Assume the giant snake Calgara killed isn't much weaker than Nola.
- Round 1: Calgara can't use Kenbunshoku Haki. Round 2: Kenbunshoku Haki is allowed.

 

[ahill1]

I like to give the great warrior Calgara the benefit of the doubt and assume he was still above gear 2nd Luffy.

Current Zoro vs Doflamingo

 

[SSJ2]

Lmao Doflamingo gets vaporized. Zoro is strong enough that Big Mom had to warn Kaido to dodge his attack. If he can kill Kaido, there's no question that he can kill Doflamingo with little effort at all. Hell, even being able to damage Kaido at all is a feat beyond what G4 Luffy showed in his first fight with Kaido, and that Luffy was much stronger than even Katakuri.

Prime Rayleigh + Oden + Kaido vs Prime Shiki

 

[Pocket-God]

Team wins, just Rayleigh and Kaido should be enough.

CP9 vs Gecko Moria

If Moria loses give him Oars for a round 2.