XXX vs XXX

[Captain Cadaver]

Even ignoring whatever stance someone has on the "what form was Gohan using/what Cell was Goku referring to" debate which is a topic in itself and just going with Gohan being a SSJ for the sake of the scenario, Dabura wins. Goku stated Dabura was tougher/more difficult to deal with than initially expected due to his magic and Cell's skill as a martial artist isn't that great when Goku could still put up an even fight despite being a step or two behind him in power, whereas Dabura's performance and guidebook entries describe him as a skilled and experienced fighter. Dabura would win regardless of that whole other debate.

ToP Arc PSSB Goku VS Fused Zamasu
- Manga version of both.
- Zamasu's immortality is limited to Pure Boo tier regeneration.

 

[Pakl]

Even ignoring whatever stance someone has on the "what form was Gohan using/what Cell was Goku referring to" debate which is a topic in itself and just going with Gohan being a SSJ for the sake of the scenario, Dabura wins. Goku stated Dabura was tougher/more difficult to deal with than initially expected due to his magic and Cell's skill as a martial artist isn't that great when Goku could still put up an even fight despite being a step or two behind him in power, whereas Dabura's performance and guidebook entries describe him as a skilled and experienced fighter. Dabura would win regardless of that whole other debate.

ToP Arc PSSB Goku VS Fused Zamasu
- Manga version of both.
- Zamasu's immortality is limited to Pure Boo tier regeneration.

Considering the fact Goku was already equal to Zamasu back then. ToP Goku would win.

Enma Daio vs Tenshinhan (Saiyan Saga)

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Considering Kaio was only described as stronger than Enma rather than far stronger, I'd say Enma stomps.

SSJ Future Gohan (TV Special) VS Weighted Kamiccolo

 

[Papasmurf]

SSJ Gohan was outmatched when he had to fight two of the cyborgs, so he only has a similar lead as initial Namek Vegeta to base Zarbon and Dodoria imo. Kamiccolo should win since he's comfortably above Vegeta and Gingertown Cell.

SSJ4 Gohan (DBH) vs. Super Yi Xing Long

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Assuming this is Xeno Gohan, he oneshots considering Xeno characters in DBH are ridiculous inflated on the power scale in general from SSJ Xeno Galu's feats against Demigra and this Gohan helping out SS4 Xeno Gogeta in the manga. If it's the SS4 Gohan from the opening with Hermaphrodite #17 Super #17 with #18 absorbed, I'd probably say Super Yi Xing Long as this Gohan isn't suggested to be in a different league from the Artificial Human and they didn't seem to dominate SS4 Galu/Vegeta to the extent YXL did.

Giant Slug runs the Freeza form gauntlet:
2nd form Freeza (Initial)
2nd form Freeza (Full power)
3rd form Freeza
True form Freeza (warm up against Goku)

 

[Void]

I think he loses to True form Freeza.

Android Arc Piccolo (Pre-Kami) Kaioken x7 vs. No. 16

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Assuming the Gekiretsu Kodan was used due to being superior in power to the Makanksappo, the bloat in the power scale would be enough not even a x7 Kaioken is going to cut it for Pre-Kami Piccolo.

SSJ Vegetto (FT Arc) VS Initial Jiren
- Manga versions of both.

 

[Papasmurf]

Full Power Jiren should at least be more powerful than SSJG Vegetto, and I doubt Jiren powered up enough to overshadow the huge gap between SSJ and SSJG. Jiren wins.

SSJ3 Vegetto (current) vs. 70% Beerus

If Vegetto loses, make it SSJG Vegetto against 100% Beerus.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

I imagine Beerus will just get buffed to being above them regardless of their gains. Assuming not, then it's a bit difficult to judge how strong Vegetto will be until Vegeta shows some feats. I'd say SSG should be able to win, though I'll side with Beerus against SS3 Vegetto due to the stamina difference.

BoGT Base Goku VS SSJ Gotenks (pre)

 

[Papasmurf]

Depends how much of Pure Boo's power Oob unlocked by the time of BoGT. If he's only on par with Pure Boo or weaker, Gotenks wins. If he's stronger by some good amount, then Galu wins with his superior skills and because pre-Rosat Gotenks has yet to develop his arsenal of wacky attacks.

SSJ3 Gogeta (Broly arc) vs. 2nd power up Jiren (manga)

-Gogeta doesn't suffer from his time limit being shortened to 5 minutes.

-If Gogeta loses, make it SSJG Gogeta, but he now has a shortened time limit from SSJG's power.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

I'd probably say Vegetto edges it out in power, with superior skill providing him a more solid win.

Base Garlic Jr. (Filler Arc) VS Initial 2nd form Freeza
- No immortality for Garlic Jr, obviously.

 

[Papasmurf]

I don't really think Piccolo improved since the Freeza arc, so I give it to 2nd form Freeza by a bit.

ToP arc vs. Anoyoichi Budokai in shitty power scaling contest

 

[Captain Cadaver]

If it's manga ToP, then the Anoyoichi Budokai as the former's at least consistent in its scaling despite the huge asspulls. If it's the anime version, then that takes it due to far more varied problems with power-scaling than just Galu.

Piccolo fused with Daimao (Supersonic Warriors) VS Ultimate Goku (Z Galu after Elder Kaioshin ritual)

 

[Papasmurf]

Post-Daimao Piccolo was slightly stronger than Super Boo, while I doubt Galu's potential is anywhere near enough Gohan's that he'd end up defeating Super Boo or edging him out in power. Piccolo wins unless Galu pulls a DBS Gohan and becomes god tier by feeling like it.

Freeza vs. Twitter homos in hypocrisy contest

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Twitter's hive mind easily since at least Freeza's has the benefit of being consistent (until DBS Broly, at least).

7 Cell Juniors VS SSJ Gohan (Cell Games)
- If Gohan loses, add Galu from the same time to help him.

 

[Papasmurf]

If Gohan has a rage boost from being beaten up or something, he might manage a win. If not, he loses unless he has Galu's help since SSJ2 Gohan easily dispatching the Cell Jr.s seems to be indication that he couldn't do the same as a SSJ1.

SSJ Vegetto (BoG arc) vs. SSJ3 Vegetto (Boo arc)

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Logically, SSJ Vegetto should be stronger anime-wise with the implication that SS2 Goku/Vegeta > Ultimate Gohan or not that far from him in the manga with how the image training suggests BoG SSJ Goku isn't far off from his Boo Arc SS3 self. Even for the anime though, I'd go with SS3 Vegetto as the Potara's boost has been nerfed as a whole in Super.

Kibitoshin VS SS2 Gohan (Cell Games)

 

[Papasmurf]

I'd probably give it to Kibitoshin considering that Rou Dai Kaioshin stated he worried that Boo would try to absorb Kibitoshit, which at least implies to me that he's above SSJ2 tier. All we know is that he's below Pure Boo, really.

Zamasu arc Kibitoshin vs. initial #17 (vs. SSJ3 Galu)

-assume that Kibito wasn't just being toyed with by Zamasu.
-Kibitoshin can still paralyze #17 and use magic materialization.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Probably still #17 as Shin's minuscule power probably wouldn't give much more than a marginal boost when considering someone far more power relevant like Caulifla was treat as barely a factor into Kefla's power by Vados. If Kibitoshin can access Ssjin3 though...

Current Piccolo VS SSJ Kefla
- Manga versions of both.

 

[Papasmurf]

Probably Kefla since while I don't doubt that current Gohan would easily win against Kefla, Piccolo was still way weaker than him in his last fight with that power-copying android and I doubt he made the gainz to catch up with PSSJB tiers.

Current Piccolo vs. ToP Hit

-Piccolo has knowledge of all of Hit's abilities.