Recent Chapter Discussion

[sei'taer]

Ok, russian dolls and king taco? Lol Oda.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Not really much content in terms of story progression this chapter and most of the Reverie characters it introduced seem like they'll be irrelevant, but at least it was entertaining with the interactions Garp had with Stelly and Shirahoshi's lack of knowledge on the land.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Was there any reason to infodump/recap the role characters like Vivi, Dalton and Wapol played? Not sure how anyone who'd stayed current with the series wouldn't be aware of these characters.

The link of almost everyone at the Reverie having interacted with Luffy got pretty old fast and took up an unnecessary percentage of the chapter, though seeing Mariejois as well as Doflamingo at the end was pretty good. Not anything more than average, though still better than most of the chapters to have come out of the Whole Cake Island arc.

 

[sei'taer]

If you haven't read one piece all the way through those characters haven't appeared in hundreds of chapters. People that picked up one piece later may not know the history of some of those characters. Also it would be weird if those characters were all at reverie and didn't meet, so it was good to get that all out of the way in one chapter.

And yeah so this weeks chapter, like shit. Kaidou and Big mom working together in a crew in the past that Garp finished the captain of?, Shanks meeting the elder stars? Doffy's Uncle and fishman island call back? This chapter was wild.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

If you haven't read one piece all the way through those characters haven't appeared in hundreds of chapters. People that picked up one piece later may not know the history of some of those characters.

Whilst I understand that way of thinking, it overall feels unnecessary from a narrative standpoint to constantly stop and recap. After all, there's a lot more information that isn't recapped despite newer readers likely being out of the loop and it can be considered unwise for a new reader to pick up the story over 900 chapters into it in the first place.

Also it would be weird if those characters were all at reverie and didn't meet, so it was good to get that all out of the way in one chapter.

My problem wasn't with that. It was with the fact the core of their conversations boil down to "Oh wow we all know Luffy." Gives Luffy far too much relevance for an arc where the drawing point is his absence from the limelight.

---

New chapter was...actually really good for once. It was great to see a lot of well established characters being brought to the front, with the Yonko alliance, possibility of Admirals getting involved in Wano and Shanks making some deal with the Gorosei. Also, seems like the presentation of Lucci's strength in Film Gold may be canon considering how easily he stomped Sai. It does seem somewhat erratic in just how much content was crammed into this chapter compared to the slow pacing of the past several dozen chapters, yet if all the ideas brought to the table are executed well this could be the first genuinely good post-timeskip arc.

 

[SSJ2]

That chapter was awesome. Finally, I am actually waiting eagerly for the next chapter..

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Another pretty good chapter. It was disappointing that the meeting Shanks had didn't continue and will probably be used to justify a contrived twist later on, but having it there as build up is better than nothing I suppose. It was good to finally see Bonney be utilised and confirm or hint at quite a few theories about her involving the Tenryubito, as well as learn a little about Kuma's past.

Seems Shirahoshi may have an assassination attempt on her soon based on the ending and the Alabasta group are in danger too. I hope Cobra gets killed off to bring some solid consequences from this arc and perhaps give Vivi more relevance.

Spoiler

I'm not too keen on the idea of someone being above the Gorosei though, since the idea of a corrupt democracy controlled by the elite is a far more interesting one than presenting a single character with the "Final Villain" presence.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

909 was pretty good. It was nice to learn more about Whitebeard's (aka. Best One Piece character) past and see what Marco's been doing, plus moving to Wano's a great way to get the bad taste of Whole Cake Island out of the mouth. The disguises the Wano team have are pretty cool and I hope that unlike the wasted potential with Sanji, this ends up fully being Zoro's Arc.
Shame that we didn't see more of the Reverie events immediately, given the high note the last chapter ended on. Hope they don't immediately go into Wano so we can get some actual answers for the end of 908 quickly.

 

[SSJ2]

I thought 909 was done in typical Oda fashion. I thought the reintroduction of the missing characters was done well, and like CC, I enjoyed their attire. I'm already interested to see what happened with these guys over the past 2 years, and how they got to where they are. Zoro looks beast with that little knife, similar to Mihawk at Baratie.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

So, Luffy's now part of the Wano Arc. Guess I can drop what anticipation I had for the arc. Hope it goes back to the Reverie events next chapter.

 

[SSJ2]

The fact that everyone is ALREADY separated is a turn off to me. I hate that shit.

 

[Symbiote]

Kind of bullshit that they made it to Wano so fast.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

911 was an inside jobdecent I guess. Nothing too good, but at least had far better pacing than most of the previous arc's chapter and it was decent how we got a throwback to the plot thread set up in Marineford of Ace having visited Wano in the past, plus it's nice to see Hawkins will have some spotlight soon. It's also a relief that Luffy didn't go full retard and think the man in the Tengu mask was Usopp or Sogeking.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

912 was alright. Given OP's predictable nature at this point, I'm guessing Zoro will lose the Sandai Kitetsu some time during the arc and Hitetsu will have to give him the Nidai Kitetsu. Either that, or the Shusui gets destroyed, but I doubt that'll be the case given the hype it was presented in Thriller Bark.
Kind've bullshit that Luffy conveniently ran into Zoro, but I'd take focus on Zoro over just Luffy any day and the fight against Hawkins ought to be entertaining.

 

[SSJ2]

The trio of Toro, Luffy and Hawkins all meeting up at the same time made me cringe.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

Well, looks like Hawkins brought out his Stand.

Not much to say on 913 beyond that JoJoke.

 

[Diamond Ryan]

Imagine if he died by getting punched through the abdomen in this arc

 

[Symbiote]

Hopefully we see more of Hawkings soon.

 

[SSJ2]

I would like to see Hawkins get killed.

 

[Captain Cadaver]

And people still complain about the version of Batman from Batman and Robin...