- Joined
- Apr 2, 2017
- Messages
- 11,136
- Age
- 7
This mysterious green figure just killed a man
Pocket-Gog~ said:
Pocket-Gog~ said:Kenshi said:I also heavily disagree with Galu turning to a child allowing the writers to actually pretend he was a character that could now be developed again. He didn't lose any of his abilities sans his Shunkan Idou, he didn't lose his memories (although he does act like a child during comic relief moments, but so did Z Galu whenever needles were in the vicinity and in other situations), and the mightiest enemies prior to Baby couldn't even make him turn SSJ2. He could've more than likely Dragon Fist'd Lood out of existence at SSJ2 or SSJ3, and the same could be said of all the M2 faggots.
I don't really think so. The pre Baby antagonists ironically enough were versatile enough that Galu couldn't really overpower them, Lood needed to be attacked from inside and outside at once. Rildo could turn into an entire planet full of metal and could easily outlast SSJ3 Galu. Its also a moot point talking about SSJ2 in GT considering the form is treated as if it doesn't exist in the show.
Pocket-Gog~ said:What they really should've done was kill him off and make him proud that his sons' generation was now handling themselves fine as Z seemingly was building up to until Gohan got absorbed by Boo, or if they weren't gonna do that, they should've at least made him unable to turn Super Saiyan anymore without rage as a catalyst and worked up to him regaining SSJ2 and SSJ3 afterwards, while developing Trunks, Goten and Pan in the process. GT failed to deliver on all of these counts. Can't call it remotely close to good for those reasons.
That ship had LONG since passed by the time Toriyama decided that Gohan was inadequate to be the main protagonist. GT didn't set any trends in how it treated Goku and the cast, that was established by Toriyama in the Buu arc.
Pocket-Gog~ said:There's a reason why even some ardent defenders of GT (that aren't :withheld COH) usually open up by saying it was below average by anime standards, because it really is that bad. Mind you when I was watching GT as it was airing on Toonami, some of my favorite shows were Megas XLR, Teen Titans, Inuyasha (albeit, before it went into filler/Naraku chasing hell), pre-Dartz Yu-Gi-Oh!, and Yu Yu Hakusho (which I'd only seen up to the middle of the Dark Tournament). Even then, I hated pretty much all of GT except the SSJ4 Galu vs. Oozaru Baby fight, and perhaps the last two episodes because they had a more "Z" feel to them.
I definitely agree that by other anime standards it is below average, but I also think that the bar got so low in the Cell and Buu arc that Baby arc had an easy time surpassing it.
Kenshi said:
Goku accessing SSJ2 to blast away Rild's metal shows he could access it any time. It's not a "moot point" at all, unlike say SSJ2 Gotenks which is a form that literally never saw a single ounce of movement or action.
Rildo was the entire world lol. It was stated that he had essentially turned into the entire planet. There was nothing Galu could do to actually beat him at that point. Sure he could destroy the planet, if he could breathe in space and didn't care about saving Earth, Pan and Trunks. But since Rildo had frozen the ship in carbonite and just teleported Trunks off world - Goku just nuking the world would've been monstrously irresponsible.If anything this compounds the problem of Galu never using his higher forms prior to Baby, because to think he could match Baby with SSJ3 (an infinitely more draining form than SSJ2), he ought to have had no problem fighting in SSJ2 (especially when a similarly young Gohan could maintain it upon unlocking it). Yet, he did not, even though Rild's only advantage was covering the planet's surface with metal... and planet busting has been a thing ever since Saiyan arc Vegeta
Lood not being one-shot material for SSJ2/SSJ3 Galu is a no limits fallacy by the way. After all, nobody would make the argument that SSJ4 Galu couldn't defeat Rild without having help from the inside, so that point is pretty moot.
It passed for Goten and Trunks. Let's be real. By the time of End of Z, Toriyama was especially clear that while Goten and Trunks might be prodigies they had zero interest in actually training or fighting. Just as I said, Toriyama had effectively retired most of the cast by the time End of Z ran around and GT had to carry on with that.It didn't pass for Goten and Trunks, who carried the Boo arc in Gohan, Goku and Vegeta's absence and were considered "ultra-prodigies." They had just as much if not even more potential than Galu to be protagonists, especially since it was stated that they were slacking off after Boo's defeat and have much room to grow. Gohan also ended Z (the Boo arc to be specific, to avoid Super/EoZ bullshit) much stronger than Goku and the strongest unfused character, yet he got no such respect here. That's called not being faithful to your source material, lmao.
It gives Piccolo the spotlight who ends up fighting android 17 and then jobbing to Cell.If an arc is below average, it doesn't merit an 8/10 lmao. 8 is 3 points higher than 5/10. And I also disagree with Baby arc being better than Cell when the Cell arc at least could keep power chains consistent and give Piccolo, Vegeta and Trunks the spotlight as well as provide a satisfying conclusion to Trunks' character arc (even if it was later marred by Super, but that's another can of worms). With Boo it's debatable, but AT already said during an interview discussing the last couple of chapters in the Boo arc that he made sure the message was sent that Goku's journeys and battles were now over, and he was now the master and not the disciple.
I feel GT tarnished that considerably, plus Galu stressed to not just Gohan/Goten/Trunks but even to Oob that they were now to be the Earth's defenders, right down to the last chapter. When did GT live up to this message? The most Oob accomplished was attacking Baby from the inside when Goku could win without such aid just by teleporting somewhere else and receiving energy there.
Pocket-Gog~ said:Kenshi said:
Goku accessing SSJ2 to blast away Rild's metal shows he could access it any time. It's not a "moot point" at all, unlike say SSJ2 Gotenks which is a form that literally never saw a single ounce of movement or action.
Galu never uses SSJ2 in the entirety of the Baby arc and BSDB arc - as confirmed by the Perfect Files. I swear SSJ2 is flat out not used by anyone, even Baby skips past the form and is implied to be using a twisted version of SSJ3 in the perfect files.
Rildo was the entire world lol. It was stated that he had essentially turned into the entire planet. There was nothing Galu could do to actually beat him at that point. Sure he could destroy the planet, if he could breathe in space and didn't care about saving Earth, Pan and Trunks. But since Rildo had frozen the ship in carbonite and just teleported Trunks off world - Goku just nuking the world would've been monstrously irresponsible.If anything this compounds the problem of Galu never using his higher forms prior to Baby, because to think he could match Baby with SSJ3 (an infinitely more draining form than SSJ2), he ought to have had no problem fighting in SSJ2 (especially when a similarly young Gohan could maintain it upon unlocking it). Yet, he did not, even though Rild's only advantage was covering the planet's surface with metal... and planet busting has been a thing ever since Saiyan arc Vegeta
And what could have SSJ3 Goku done? Run out of energy faster like what happened with his first encounter with Baby? The childs body is even worse at handling SSJ3s might than the adult body is.
Lood not being one-shot material for SSJ2/SSJ3 Galu is a no limits fallacy by the way. After all, nobody would make the argument that SSJ4 Galu couldn't defeat Rild without having help from the inside, so that point is pretty moot.
Its the implication that was given, especially considering Goku never even bothered to power up against it.
It passed for Goten and Trunks. Let's be real. By the time of End of Z, Toriyama was especially clear that while Goten and Trunks might be prodigies they had zero interest in actually training or fighting. Just as I said, Toriyama had effectively retired most of the cast by the time End of Z ran around and GT had to carry on with that.It didn't pass for Goten and Trunks, who carried the Boo arc in Gohan, Goku and Vegeta's absence and were considered "ultra-prodigies." They had just as much if not even more potential than Galu to be protagonists, especially since it was stated that they were slacking off after Boo's defeat and have much room to grow. Gohan also ended Z (the Boo arc to be specific, to avoid Super/EoZ bullshit) much stronger than Goku and the strongest unfused character, yet he got no such respect here. That's called not being faithful to your source material, lmao.
It gives Piccolo the spotlight who ends up fighting android 17 and then jobbing to Cell.If an arc is below average, it doesn't merit an 8/10 lmao. 8 is 3 points higher than 5/10. And I also disagree with Baby arc being better than Cell when the Cell arc at least could keep power chains consistent and give Piccolo, Vegeta and Trunks the spotlight as well as provide a satisfying conclusion to Trunks' character arc (even if it was later marred by Super, but that's another can of worms). With Boo it's debatable, but AT already said during an interview discussing the last couple of chapters in the Boo arc that he made sure the message was sent that Goku's journeys and battles were now over, and he was now the master and not the disciple.
I feel GT tarnished that considerably, plus Galu stressed to not just Gohan/Goten/Trunks but even to Oob that they were now to be the Earth's defenders, right down to the last chapter. When did GT live up to this message? The most Oob accomplished was attacking Baby from the inside when Goku could win without such aid just by teleporting somewhere else and receiving energy there.
It gives Vegeta the spotlight who is handed a massive sized idiot ball to allow Cell to reach his perfect form.
Trunks as a character is Kaioshin tier useless and Trunks in GT (at least for the BSDB arc and baby arc) was far more useful and central to the plot than he ever was.
The power chains were more consistent in Cell arc and that's the most that arc can boast about.
That's a missed opportunity then.Kenshi said:The Perfect Files are inaccurate in this case seeing as both the screenshot I posted above, as well as the scene of Goku cycling through his forms to go SSJ3 against Vegeta-Baby on Planet Plant showed Galu with his SSJ2 hairstyle, on top of the latter instance having the trademark lightning aura. It's worth noting that the Perfect Files state that Gohan kept up his training, yet one of GT's lead writers said that Gohan had not trained or been a warrior at all, and that he planned to have a returning to his warrior roots episode for Gohan (similar to ToP Gohan) to develop his character.
Guidebooks are fine to use, but not when they contradict the source material. Hell, the guidebook entry you referred to also said Goku only used SSJ2 against Majin Vegeta and in the GT opening, even though Toei's own anime adaptation showed Galu using it against Kid Boo for an entire episode, and GT is a direct sequel to the anime DBZ.
Rildo was the entire world lol. It was stated that he had essentially turned into the entire planet. There was nothing Galu could do to actually beat him at that point. Sure he could destroy the planet, if he could breathe in space and didn't care about saving Earth, Pan and Trunks. But since Rildo had frozen the ship in carbonite and just teleported Trunks off world - Goku just nuking the world would've been monstrously irresponsible.
And the entire planet is toast too. M-2 was a machine mutant - as stated in one of the guidebooks - destroying the planet was the only way to get rid of Rildo in his transformed state.Goku knows where his ship was and can sense Pan's ki (who was fighting Rild's robots in his factory just before Galu's battle with Rild). All Goku needed to do was spam about 10 continent level attacks on the planet while not destroying his own ship or attacking Pan, and Rild's one advantage is toaaaaaaast.
It refutes the SSJ3 argument even if Galu was too retarded to use it against Rildo, it would not have won him the battle.Something which he didn't even discover until he ran the form for its first fight in GT, about 15 episodes after Rild's demise. This is an intellectually dishonest argument, and this doesn't refute my SSJ2 Goku argument.
Probably, 50/50 chance depending on what tone the writers are going for.Would SSJ4 Gogeta be unable to defeat Lood without help? Or Yi Xing Long, or Super 17?
Again, no limits fallacy. And the fact that Galu never needed forms higher than SSJ until Baby shows that what I said about there being no true progression, or room for progression for Galu (barring Toei haxes/illogical power chains) until he achieved SSJ4. A protagonist who doesn't progress is a stagnant protagonist, and GT itself is a stagnant show when Goku and Pan are carrying the whole series, all while Goku doesn't develop as a character at all because his development was already finished 2/3rds into Z.
Which then leads into Gohan getting adsorbed by Buu and being taken out for the entire arc - leaving Goku to deal with Buu himself. Then when we cut to the EoZ chapters Gohan is pretty much shown having turned into a bookworm like before.And Toriyama still developed Gohan's character in the Boo arc by having him realize the importance of keeping up his training with the Z Sword segment upon realizing that Galu trained so hard in the afterlife, and by having him do a 180 on his prior meekness upon becoming Ultimate Gohan.
If Goten and Trunks aren't motivated heroes, then they just need to be developed in a way that they will be. It's not hard. Look how unmotivated Saiyan arc Gohan was, and then compare him to his Freeza arc self. Z did it already, developing a character to be Galu's successor which culminated in Gohan turning SSJ2 and avenging his father. Even if the Boo arc ultimately ended with Gohan's protagonist status being rescinded, he had plenty of hightlights and development before he retired to the sidelines. Goten and Trunks didn't have shit in GT.
Piccolo had a single fight in the Cell arc (which in the manga was essentially just a few badly drawn pages) before he got molested by Cell and became instantly irrelevant.Piccolo literally had one fight in GT and that was his attempted murder by Baby, which in of itself is PIS when attacking Piccolo enough to seriously injure or even kill him puts the BSDBs in danger
Piccolo also had to face his own inner demons to merge with Kami (his counterpart whom he hated), while in GT his only character moment was choosing death.
And that still gave him a gigantic sized idiot ball by letting Cell go perfect. But Vegeta by himself would be alright, but almost every other character in the Cell arc had to act like an idiot in order for the plot to move. Goku and friends were aware of Gero and how he and android 19 killed them all in the future, but just decide to let them go? Its a good thing Future Trunks wasn't there or he'd have a heart attack of his own!It was stated that Vegeta became more prideful than ever upon unlocking Super Saiyan, and he'd now gone a step beyond it - Goku himself had the same idiot ball moment when he allowed Freeza to go 100% just for a good fight. Toriyama's characterization of Vegeta was consistent with prior showings of Super Saiyans.
Future Trunks ended the Cell arc tied as the third strongest Z Senshi after Gohan and the deceased Goku, and killed not only Freeza but all of Gero's creations and saved the world multiple times in the process. GT Trunks' biggest feat was... tricking Dr. Myu with Gill's help. You are just parroting CC's old argument that Trunks is as useless as Kaioshin, even though he showed the most promise of any of the half-breeds by continuing to train to uphold peace, and going in the RoSaT twice. GT Trunks showed basically no such progress, his greatest accomplishment being pounding on Oozaru Baby's face a little bit when he gave him those free hits
Or more accurately that the real reason why Goku even bothered wishing back Uub was so he could have a good fight. We're also getting ahead of ourselves with the future of GT, since I'm talking about the Baby arc here.You're also not addressing the fact that the last chapter of the manga and Episode 291 of Z both illustrate Oob as Goku's one true successor in defending the Earth, yet Oob escaped irrelevance for two whole episodes before being swallowed by Baby and then going on to be as useless as tits on a bull.